The Giants aren’t done trying to squeeze something useful out of J.J. McCarthy.
That’s the big takeaway after ESPN’s Jordan Raanan reported that New York’s “McCarthy package” is staying in the offense. For now, the former Vikings first-rounder is being used in small doses, mostly in sub-formation and goal-line situations, with the Giants leaning on his legs more than his arm while he sits behind Jameis Winston.
McCarthy finally made his 2026 debut in Week 5 during New York’s ugly tie with the Washington Commanders, after spending the first three weeks without an appearance in Minnesota and then landing with the Giants in a deal that sent him to New York for a 2027 fifth-round pick. On Sunday, his role was tiny but noticeable: he was officially on the field for three plays, and the result was three total yards.
Both of his official snaps went as runs for two yards combined, and two pass attempts were wiped out by penalties. One of them was a 14-yard screen to Malik Nabers that got erased by an illegal shift.
Still, the Giants believe there’s a place for him.
“The J.J. McCarthy package, it’s not going anywhere.
Giants head coach John Harbaugh said he views it as a change of pace. The Giants want to use McCarthy’s legs on certain plays in lieu of Jameis Winston.
McCarthy was officially on the field for three plays on Sunday against the Commanders. It gained three total yards.
They did have a 14-yard gain that was negated by a penalty. It was a screen pass to Malik Nabers, and the Giants think that the package can work moving forward.
Harbaugh said it’s his job as coach to get the most out of the players on his roster and it would be negligent if he didn’t try to do the same with McCarthy.”
That’s the lane New York sees right now: a change-of-pace wrinkle, something designed to get McCarthy on the field without asking him to carry the offense.
The problem is that if the Giants want that package to grow into anything more than a curiosity, McCarthy is going to have to do more than run. He ran 37 times for 181 yards and four touchdowns in 10 starts for Minnesota last season, but those came as part of the normal flow of an offense that was struggling badly. If New York really wants him to develop into a useful weapon, the passing game has to show up too.
That’s where the pressure comes in. McCarthy completed 57.6% of his passes in 2025, with 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions, and the Giants already tried to let him throw against Washington. For now, though, he’s still working from the margins of the playbook.
The opening around him is at least there. New York is off to a 3-1-1 start, even with Dart out for most of the season after a knee injury, and Winston has started three games. Winston is completing 57.6% of his passes this season, down from his 60.9% career mark, matching McCarthy’s 57.6% from 2025.
That doesn’t mean McCarthy is about to take over. It does mean the Giants have enough reason to keep building around him in small pieces, even while he remains behind Winston on the depth chart.
In Other News...
Blake Cashman Is Becoming A Much Bigger Vikings Story Than Expected
The Vikings 5-0 start has been fueled in part by a defense that keeps finding new ways to make life difficult for opposing quarterbacks, and Blake Cashman has quickly become one of the more interesting pieces in Brian Flores scheme. The linebacker has already shown he can affect the passer, bringing quickness and timing that have made him a steady presence in a front that has spent the opening month setting the tone for Minnesota.
Cashmans production has also started to push the conversation beyond his role as a reliable defender and into bigger expectations for the rest of the season. If he keeps generating pressure at this pace, he could wind up with a far more noticeable sack total than anyone might have expected in September, which would only add to a defense that has helped make the Vikings one of the early surprises of the league. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings' Undefeated Start Just Made One Trade Debate Impossible To Ignore
An undefeated start has a way of changing the conversation around a roster, and Minnesotas 5-0 run has only made the question of what comes next louder. The Vikings have held their ground despite some offensive issues and a few concerns about defensive depth, which is why any discussion about adding help is now being viewed through a playoff lens rather than a survival one.
Bleacher Report recently pointed to Khalil Mack as a possible fit, with the Chargers off to a rough start and the veteran edge rusher still performing at a high level. For Minnesota, the appeal is obvious: a proven pass rusher would add another layer to a defense trying to stay ahead of the curve, even if no deal is in place and any move would have to make sense for a team that has given itself plenty of reasons to think big. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings Bye Week Could Put One Intriguing Backfield Option In Focus
The Vikings Week 6 bye comes at a useful time, giving Minnesota a chance to take stock while the rest of the schedule keeps moving around it. The immediate focus is the Titans-Colts game, which matters in part because Indianapolis is next on the calendar for Minnesota and former Vikings quarterback Daniel Jones is now starting there, adding another layer to a matchup the Vikings will be watching closely.
The extra intrigue, though, is whether the trade deadline could eventually pull Minnesota into the market for help at running back. Tennessee has struggled as a team, but one back there has produced solid individual numbers, and that kind of profile can start to look awfully tempting for a team thinking beyond the bye week and into the stretch run. [Read more 🡒]