EAGAN, Minn. - The Vikings’ quarterback decision on Tuesday answered one question and immediately opened another.
Kevin O’Connell met with Kyler Murray and J.J. McCarthy in the morning and told them Murray would be the starter. Later, after a team meeting and walk-through, O’Connell explained the move to reporters and pointed to Murray’s experience and upside.
“I think the competition benefitted both of those guys,” O’Connell said, “and maybe accelerated some things, and maybe also let us know exactly where we’re at with both guys in our attempt to get them both ready.”
That decision had been building for months. It started back in January, when O’Connell said “there has to be” competition at quarterback after the 2025 season ended. Minnesota’s offensive staff then dug into the free-agent quarterback market, came out of the combine in Indianapolis with a clear target, and landed on Murray, who signed in mid-March.
Even after that, O’Connell kept the door open for a real battle between Murray and McCarthy, the Vikings’ 2024 first-round pick. The idea was that pressure would sharpen both players and lift the offense as a whole. Locker room leaders supported that approach publicly, even as people around the league - including some inside the Vikings building - expected this outcome from the start.
For McCarthy, the news changes the conversation. He’s now the backup, and O’Connell said the 23-year-old will keep getting meaningful reps.
“We want to be absolutely mindful not only of where he’s at right now,” O’Connell said, “but also where we think he can get by the start of the season. We’ve learned over the years that we don’t hold the cards. We need as many guys (as possible) to be comfortable and ready.”
That mindset fits the reality Minnesota has lived with lately. Since the start of the 2023 season, eight different quarterbacks have started games for the Vikings.
The last three seasons have included two that were derailed by the revolving door under center. So this offseason, the team loaded up.
Murray was the headliner, while veteran Carson Wentz was re-signed for added insurance and depth, a setup that could still lead to a trade.
McCarthy’s 2025 season made the case for Murray even stronger. His play frustrated O’Connell and the offensive staff, with accuracy issues showing up on routine throws, extra hitches disrupting timing and trouble with touch limiting what the offense could call. Then the injuries hit, as a high ankle sprain and hand problems wiped out whatever momentum he had left.
The numbers tell the same story. Among quarterbacks with at least 200 passes in 2025, McCarthy finished 34th in efficiency, 35th in completion percentage and 36th in touchdown-to-interception ratio. O’Connell had to simplify the offense and lean conservative because of it.
McCarthy has publicly said he wanted to stay with the Vikings. In the spring, he described the pairing with Murray as being like two high schoolers sitting on opposite sides of the classroom.
This summer, when asked about trade speculation, he said, “I think I made it very clear I wanted to be here before I got here. I love this organization.
I love the coaching staff. I absolutely love these players to death.
This is where I want to be.”
Still, Tuesday’s move adds a new layer. Minnesota values the quarterback room’s chemistry, especially with O’Connell’s own background at the position. At the same time, McCarthy and his camp have to weigh whether this remains the best spot for his future.
There’s no clean comparison point. The Colts benched Anthony Richardson last fall, and he later asked for a trade but stayed on the roster. The 49ers, meanwhile, moved on from Trey Lance after two seasons and dealt him to the Cowboys for a fourth-round pick.
What McCarthy might bring back in a trade is still unclear.
For now, O’Connell says he still sees a future for him in Minnesota.
Despite the rumors, O’Connell said Tuesday he “absolutely” sees McCarthy as still having a future with the organization. He pointed to McCarthy’s growth in camp and stressed the need for him to remain ready if the Vikings need him.
“As he knows, he’s holding the pen on his story,” O’Connell said. “We’re going to support him and try to help him continue to improve as a young player at the most difficult position in sports.”
In Other News...
J.J. McCarthy Suddenly Has A Vikings Problem Fans Feared
Carson Wentzs arrival gives Minnesota a more experienced hand in the quarterback room, and it also adds a layer of uncertainty around J.J. McCarthys place in the pecking order. The Vikings drafted McCarthy 10th overall and still have plenty invested in his development, but the move signals they want a veteran presence behind Kyler Murray while they sort through their options at the position.
For McCarthy, the next stretch matters more than ever because his preseason work could shape how Minnesota views his long-term fit. If he plays well and another team starts calling, the Vikings may have a difficult decision to make, turning a crowded depth chart into a potential trade conversation they were hoping to avoid. [Read more 🡒]
JJ McCarthy Opens Up After Vikings QB Decision Changes Everything
The Vikings quarterback battle took a sharp turn as training camp gave way to a clear answer, with Kyler Murray winning the job for the 2026 season and JJ McCarthy sliding into the backup role. It was the kind of decision that reshapes the entire tone of camp, especially for a young quarterback still trying to establish his place while the team leans on Murrays experience and what he showed on the practice field.
McCarthy spoke after the announcement and made no secret of the disappointment, but he also kept the focus on the part he can control, staying ready and preparing for whatever comes next. There is still a meaningful next step ahead, too, with McCarthy expected to get game work in the preseason opener, a chance to keep developing even if the depth chart no longer looks the way he hoped. [Read more 🡒]
Vikings Fans Should Watch These 3 Crucial Depth Battles Tonight
The first preseason game against the Giants brings an early look at how the Vikings want to sort through the bottom of the roster, and there are a few spots worth tracking closely. Quarterback, edge rusher and running back all have meaningful depth questions attached to them, with the competition at QB3 drawing attention behind the top of the room and the edge group offering an opportunity for younger players and veterans to carve out a role.
Carson Wentz and Max Brosmer are in the mix for the third quarterback job, while the edge rotation has several names trying to make a case as the Vikings start separating the real contenders from the camp bodies. At running back, Demond Claiborne and Zavier Scott are chasing the third spot on the depth chart, a small but important job in a preseason where every snap can help decide who gets another week to keep pushing. [Read more 🡒]