Yasser Mercedes is giving the Twins a timely reason to pause and think about the roster before the Rule 5 draft picture comes into focus.
He’s in the Arizona Fall League getting a chance to show what he can do, but the bigger question hanging over his stint there is what kind of future he has in Minnesota. The Twins have a decision to make in the next few weeks, and it could shape whether he stays in the organization at all.
That decision only becomes real if the Rule 5 draft is held as scheduled on Dec. 9. There’s a caveat, though: the draft could be suspended if Major League owners and the MLB Players Association do not reach an agreement on a new collective bargaining deal.
If the draft does happen, Mercedes is the kind of player who forces a team to make a hard call.
He falls under Rule 5 eligibility because he signed a professional contract after age 19 and has already played at least four years. The Twins brought him in as an undrafted free agent out of Puerto Rico, and his first pro season came in 2022. MLB Pipeline has him ranked as a Top 30 prospect, so if Minnesota leaves him exposed, there could be outside interest.
Protecting him means putting him on the 40-man roster, and that comes with consequences. The Twins would need to clear space, which could mean letting another player go.
On top of that, if Mercedes is added to the 40-man, he would fall under the current MLB CBA and would not be able to play minor league baseball in 2027, which could slow his progress. Minnesota wants him to keep developing.
That development has already shown signs of moving forward. After batting under .200 in 2025, Mercedes improved in 2026, hitting .249/.343/.453 with 18 home runs and 72 RBI. He climbed to High-A Cedar Rapids, and there’s a case that he’s ready for another jump.
The AFL has only strengthened that impression. Mercedes is hitting .269/.412/.500 with one home run and five RBI.
The Twins can choose to take the risk and leave him off the 40-man roster. If nobody takes him, he remains in the system and would be able to keep playing in the minor leagues in 2027. But every strong game he puts together in Arizona raises the chance that another club notices.
And that’s the bind Minnesota is facing: the better Mercedes plays, the harder he becomes to keep. If the Rule 5 draft goes forward, his case will be one of the most complicated roster decisions the Twins have this offseason.
In Other News...
Twins Face One Offseason Question That Could Define Their Next Step
The offseason has already started with a familiar mix of hope and uncertainty for the Twins after a 77-85 finish left them seven games out of the final American League wild-card spot. There are a few obvious areas to sort through, starting with the health of the pitching rotation and whether ownership is ready to back up a more aggressive approach with real spending.
Ryan Jeffers' free agency adds another layer to the puzzle, because catcher suddenly looms as a position the front office has to address. And while there is talk that Tom Pohlad plans to raise payroll for 2027, the more immediate question is how much help the Twins can add now and whether this winter can finally put them on a more competitive track. [Read more 🡒]
Joe Ryans Twins Future Just Became A Real Offseason Debate
Joe Ryan has gone from a stabilizing presence in the Twins rotation to one of the more interesting offseason names on the roster, and the reason is simple enough: Minnesota has pitching depth, and Ryan is getting closer to a point where his contract situation starts to matter more. He has been a quality starter over his career, but the Twins also have enough arms in the system and on the staff that they can at least entertain difficult conversations rather than treating every rotation piece as untouchable.
The bigger question now is whether the Twins decide to listen if the right offer comes along, especially with clubs around the league still searching for starting pitching. San Francisco has emerged as a logical match because of its need and its farm system assets, but for Minnesota the debate goes beyond one possible trade partner. It is about whether Ryans value is at its peak now, or whether keeping him for another season is worth the risk if the second half trends that have followed him begin to carry more weight. [Read more 🡒]
Twins First Base Search Just Sparked A Risky Big-Name Debate
With Josh Bell potentially on the way out, the Twins offseason search at first base and designated hitter is already drawing some outside noise, and former club reliever Tyler Duffey added a notable name to the mix. He floated Seattle first baseman Josh Naylor as a possible fit, a suggestion that at least makes sense on paper for a club looking to shore up the middle of the lineup and keep its options open at a spot that could need immediate help.
The problem is that the idea comes with plenty of baggage. Naylor is already tied to Seattle long term, and his stock has taken a hit after a rough season and wrist surgery following the year, which makes the kind of trade Minnesota would have to assemble feel like a steep ask. Even if the Twins liked the fit, the Mariners would have little incentive to move him, so this is the sort of name that fuels debate more than it points to a realistic deal. [Read more 🡒]