Twins Suddenly Have A Tough Victor Caratini Decision To Make

With Ryan Jeffers unexpectedly staying, the Twins face a decision on whether Victor Caratini's performance merits a trade to bolster other areas of the team.

Ryan Jeffers’ unexpected decision to accept Minnesota’s one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer changed the Twins’ catching picture in a hurry, and it leaves Victor Caratini in a spot worth watching this offseason.

At the moment, Caratini looks lined up as Jeffers’ backup next year. He can also handle first base, which gives the Twins some flexibility.

But that versatility comes with a price tag that feels heavy for a reserve: Minnesota gave him a two-year, $14 million deal last offseason, and his first year with the club didn’t go smoothly. Over 106 games, he finished with 0.7 fWAR and a 79 wRC+.

Even with that uneven 2026 season, Caratini still has a market. Catchers who can hold up in the majors are not easy to find, and the 33-year-old has a stronger recent track record than his Twins numbers suggest. He was an above-average hitter for the Houston Astros in 2024 and 2025, which could keep other teams interested if Minnesota decides to listen.

That’s where the Twins have a real decision to make. If they can turn Caratini into a useful bullpen arm, or maybe a first baseman or second baseman, that would be a move worth considering. If the return is only lower-level prospects, though, keeping him probably makes more sense than selling low.

The timing matters, too. Because Caratini is on an expiring contract, a prospects-based trade before the Dec. 1 lockout does not sound likely.

Jon Morosi of MLB Network reported that teams are unlikely to give up prospects for players on one-year deals this month. A deal for another player on an expiring contract, however, remains possible.

If forced to guess, the safer bet is that Minnesota keeps Caratini. But general manager Jeremy Zoll at least has to weigh the possibility of moving him.

There’s also a case for holding onto him beyond simple roster math. When Jeffers was out with a hamate bone fracture, Caratini stepped in and produced some of his best work of the year, hitting .281/.361/.491 with a 135 wRC+. That stretch could make the Twins think twice about thinning out the catching depth in case Jeffers misses time again next season.

And that same run could make Caratini appealing to other clubs. A front office looking at those numbers might see a catcher who just needed steady playing time to get rolling at the plate.

Defensively, he does have one clear flaw: he struggles to control the run game. But outside of that, he grades well at the position, including in his work with the ABS challenge system.

In Other News...

Twins Fans Just Lost A Familiar Voice They Trusted

Audra Martins run with the Twins broadcast team is coming to an end after 11 seasons, with the longtime television reporter announcing she will not return to Twins.TV next season. Martin had become a familiar presence for Minnesota viewers, bringing steady coverage to a club she joined after previously working in the Tennessee market with the Titans.

Her exit adds another layer of uncertainty around the Twins as the sport heads toward a possible Major League Baseball work stoppage. The contract decision leaves one of the teams most recognizable media voices on the outside looking in, and it also raises questions about how much more change could be coming around the club before the next season even begins. [Read more 🡒]

Twins Rule 5 Gamble May Not Matter For A Surprising Reason

The Twins went into the 2026 Rule 5 Draft protection deadline without adding any eligible players to their 40-man roster, a move that normally would leave a few prospects exposed to the annual December selection process. Under ordinary circumstances, that would be the kind of decision that invites second-guessing, especially for a club trying to balance present roster needs with future depth.

This year, though, the bigger issue may be the calendar itself. With an MLB lockout expected to begin Dec. 1, the Rule 5 Draft scheduled for Dec. 9 is likely to be canceled, which would allow Minnesota to keep the prospects it left unprotected. The looming shutdown is also expected to push back the start of the 2027 season and disrupt player movement across the league, turning what looked like a roster gamble into a situation the Twins may never have to answer for. [Read more 🡒]

Sonny Gray Reunion Could Force Painful Twins Decision On Bailey Ober

Sonny Grays return to Minnesota gives the Twins a familiar front-line arm, but it also tightens the squeeze on a pitching staff that already had little room to spare. A two-year deal for the veteran right-hander reshapes both the rotation picture and the payroll outlook, and it comes at a time when the club is trying to balance present-day competitiveness with long-term flexibility.

Bailey Ober is now the name most likely to feel the ripple effect. With the arbitration deadline approaching, Minnesota has to weigh his declining performance metrics against the cost of keeping him and the depth already on hand, and a non-tender remains a real possibility. It would be a tough call for a pitcher who has been part of the rotation mix, but the Twins may decide that letting him hit free agency is the cleaner way to preserve both money and roster space. [Read more 🡒]