The Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays are on the way to the World Series, and neither club got there by backing into a top-10 payroll. Milwaukee opened the 2026 season with baseball’s 19th-highest payroll.
Tampa Bay sat 26th. For the Twins, that kind of run can look awfully convenient if you’re trying to make the case that spending less is perfectly fine.
But the lesson here is more complicated than that.
Yes, a strong organization can beat its budget. The Brewers and Rays have done exactly that, and Milwaukee’s sweep of the Los Angeles Dodgers made the point even louder because the Dodgers’ payroll was nearly twice as large.
Three teams in the bottom 11 of Opening Day payrolls reached the League Championship Series this year. That’s real evidence that smart clubs can punch above their weight.
It is not evidence that payroll doesn’t matter.
The bigger history says the opposite. Teams with top-10 payrolls have won 20 of the last 28 World Series titles.
MLB.com has also found that clubs in the upper half of spending are about 1.7 times more likely to make the playoffs, three times more likely to reach the League Championship Series, and six times more likely to get to the World Series than teams in the bottom half. Money doesn’t lock in success, but it clearly tilts the odds.
What Milwaukee and Tampa Bay have built is something rare. Both organizations have shown they can identify talent, develop players and keep turning over the roster without collapsing.
They are among the best-run teams in the sport, and their success is proof of how far sharp decision-making can go when resources are tight. Even so, it’s hard not to wonder how much more dangerous they could be with more money to keep their best players and add around them.
That’s where the Twins come in, and where the comparison starts to fall apart.
Minnesota has not shown the same kind of steady ability to rise above its financial limits. Front-office turnover, managerial changes, coaching changes and too many prospect disappointments have made it tough to trust that the right call will be made again and again.
The Twins absolutely need better scouting, better player development and cleaner roster construction. But they also need more room to operate.
If an organization has not proven it can squeeze the most out of what it already has, the answer is not to hand over even fewer resources and hope for a different result.
That issue hangs over the offseason ahead. Labor negotiations could bring a salary floor, a salary cap or some other shift to baseball’s economic setup, so the exact financial picture is still unclear.
What is clear is that the Twins need to be closer to the middle of the league in payroll than the bottom. They do not have to spend like the Dodgers, but they do need enough flexibility to keep key players, patch holes and avoid depending on every prospect and every internal move to go perfectly.
That’s why a 2024 interview with WCCO keeps coming back into the conversation. Joe Pohlad used the Rays as an example of why the Twins didn’t need to spend heavily to compete. Tampa Bay had shown that a team could win without major free-agent investment, and the Twins believed they could follow that path.
With the Rays now in the World Series again, alongside Milwaukee, that argument will be tempting to revive. Tom Pohlad should be careful with it.
The Rays’ success does not mean the Twins can safely spend less. Tampa Bay has built a machine that can live with financial limits and still contend.
Minnesota has not yet shown that same resilience.
That’s the real takeaway from this World Series for the Twins: payroll matters. The Brewers and Rays earned their trip to the sport’s biggest stage, but their success should not become a reason for Minnesota to cut deeper.
The Twins need better decisions, and they need more resources to work with. Until they prove they can build and sustain a contender on a consistent basis, spending more on the major-league roster remains one of the clearest ways to improve their odds.
In Other News...
Twins Face A Tough Khadim Diaw Decision As His Bat Keeps Rising
Khadim Diaw has given the Twins something to think about as his bat continues to trend up in Double-A, and the conversation around him is no longer just about where he fits on the diamond. Minnesota has a deeper-than-usual group of catching prospects, with Ryan Jeffers, Vahn Lackey and Eduardo Tait also in the mix, but Diaws offensive versatility and steady work behind the plate have made him one of the more intriguing names in the system.
The question now is whether the Twins keep developing him as a catcher or push him toward a different position and let the bat take center stage. There is real roster pressure behind that decision, too, with Jeffers approaching free agency and the organization having to balance short-term major league needs against the longer view of how best to maximize Diaws value. [Read more 🡒]
Former Twins Catcher Suddenly Caught Up In MLB's Manager Shakeup
The Angels are back in the market for a manager after declining Kurt Suzukis 2027 contract option, a move that sends the former Twins catcher into the center of another front-office reset. Suzukis first season on the bench ended with a 62-100 record, and the franchise will now begin searching for a new manager and coaching staff for 2027.
For Twins fans, the news lands with a familiar twist because Suzukis playing career in Minnesota included his lone All-Star nod in 2014 at Target Field. While the Angels sort through their next steps, the Twins have more stability for the moment, with executive chair Tom Pohlad confirming that Derek Shelton will remain manager for at least one more season. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Pitching Staff Could Be Headed For A Dramatic New Direction
The Twins have turned their pitching operation over to Brian Reith, bringing in a coach with a reputation for helping shape arms inside the Rays system. Reith arrives from Durham, where he spent the past five seasons guiding the Bulls as their pitching coach, and he steps into a role that has mattered plenty in Minnesota as the club looks for a fresh voice after Pete Makis exit.
What makes the hire especially intriguing is the Rays connection, given the overlap with pitchers already in the Twins orbit. Reiths influence on Joe Ryan and Taj Bradley will be worth watching as Minnesota tries to see whether his approach translates quickly at the major league level, but for now the real answer is still ahead of them. [Read more 🡒]