The Minnesota Twins finally gave Aaron Sabato his shot on Monday, and the timing says plenty about where Matt Wallner stands with the organization.
Sabato, a first-round pick in the 2020 draft, has been waiting years for this moment. The Twins’ decision to bring him up gives the North Carolina product a chance to make a case for a spot on next year’s roster, but it also sends a pretty clear message about Wallner’s future in Minnesota.
Wallner started the season as the Twins’ everyday right fielder, but that role didn’t last. He was sent down to Triple-A St.
Paul after hitting .167/.259/.292 with four homers and 10 RBI in 34 games. Since then, he’s put together a strong run with the Saints, batting .254/.366/.520 with 25 homers and 75 RBI across 94 games.
Even with the Twins out of playoff contention over the weekend, they still didn’t bring him back up to see if that production would carry over.
That silence matters. It strongly suggests the Twins are already moving on.
Sabato earned the promotion on merit. He’s spent six seasons climbing through the minors and has posted a line that looks a lot like Wallner’s this year: .273/.349/.528 with 25 homers and 75 RBI in 113 games. With Josh Bell headed for free agency, Victor Caratini likely shifting behind the plate more often if Ryan Jeffers leaves in free agency, and Royce Lewis possibly becoming trade bait this offseason, Sabato could be in the mix for a roster spot if he makes the most of his one-week look in the majors.
Wallner, though, still has a case on paper. He’s been a real power source in the big leagues, with 55 home runs in 307 career games and a .794 OPS that can play when everything is clicking. The problem is that the upside has come with too much swing-and-miss.
His career strikeout rate sits at 33.2%, and this season he’s become even more of a gamble at the plate, with a 31.6 chase rate in the majors according to Baseball Savant. The numbers get rougher from there: a 44 percent whiff rate and a 39.3 percent strikeout rate this season, and those issues haven’t gotten better in the minors. His speed and fielding have also slipped.
That helps explain why the Twins passed on calling him up when Alan Roden, Austin Martin and others struggled after the trade deadline. It also explains why Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez and Gabriel Gonzalez got the call while Wallner stayed put in St. Paul.
The Twins have been willing to make future-focused moves in other spots, too. They tried Lewis at first base after he spent his career on the left side of the diamond, but that experiment didn’t come until the final week of the regular season.
Sabato’s promotion fits that same pattern. Wallner not getting the same chance feels different.
Minnesota’s outfield could look very different this winter. The team already explored trading Trevor Larnach at the deadline and could revisit that idea again.
Keaschall may not be a full-time outfielder after his defensive struggles this season. Byron Buxton should take a spot once he returns from hip surgery, and Jenkins and Rodriguez are expected to handle the other spots when the season starts.
That leaves Wallner in an awkward place. He could fit as a designated hitter or even try first base, but the Twins clearly aren’t interested in building around that possibility.
If another club is willing to bet on his power, Wallner could become a trade piece. Minnesota, though, would probably be dealing from a weak position.
With nearly 1,000 major league at-bats behind him, the Twins seem to have seen enough. Promoting Sabato instead of Wallner in the final week of the season makes that hard to ignore. Wallner’s time in Minnesota looks numbered.
In Other News...
Twins Could Turn To A Former First-Round Pick Few Saw Coming
The Twins may be looking in an unexpected place for bullpen help, and it comes with a familiar name. Keoni Cavaco, their 2019 first-round draft pick, has moved from being a position player to pitching after spending two seasons in independent baseball, and the organization is now considering him as a possible relief option.
General manager Jeremy Zoll has already confirmed the clubs interest, while manager Derek Shelton has said he wants to feature as many former first-round picks as possible on the field. If Cavaco gets the call, his path would be one of the more unusual ones in recent Twins memory, taking him from High-A to independent ball and now to the edge of a major-league bullpen opportunity. [Read more 🡒]
Former Twins Arm Is Putting The Jeff Hoffman Trade Back In Focus
The Jeff Hoffman deal has already had one of those little side stories that can make a trade look a lot bigger in hindsight. John Klein, the right-hander the Twins sent to Toronto in the Aug. 3 swap, had just made his major league debut in Minnesota this season before becoming part of the package that brought Hoffman to the bullpen picture.
Kleins next step came quickly, with the Blue Jays recently calling him up for a doubleheader against the Orioles, a reminder that his path is still moving even as his minor league performance has been uneven. Toronto has him ranked as its No. 29 overall prospect, so his progress will keep drawing attention in a trade that Minnesota will be measured against for a while. [Read more 🡒]
Walker Jenkins Is Making The Twins Look Right For Calling Him Up
Walker Jenkins arrived in the majors with the kind of uneven first impression that can come with a late-season call-up, but the Twins have spent the past week seeing more and more of why they brought him up. After opening his MLB career with a low batting average, the young outfielder has started to settle in, going 11-for-25 with three home runs over his last six games and giving Minnesota a much clearer look at the kind of bat he can bring.
Even with the Twins out of playoff contention, Jenkins stretch at the plate has made the promotion look worthwhile in the larger sense. He still has rookie eligibility left for 2027, and his path to this point has already included multiple injuries, which makes every productive game feel a little more meaningful for a team trying to gauge what comes next. What Minnesota is watching now is whether this late-season burst is the start of a longer run toward becoming a regular outfield option. [Read more 🡒]