The Twins may not need to chase a direct Josh Bell replacement, but Paul Goldschmidt still makes sense as a name worth circling.
Minnesota’s current setup already points away from a full-time designated hitter. With Byron Buxton, Luke Keaschall, Emmanuel Rodriguez and Walker Jenkins all appearing to be starting outfielders, the Twins do not have to force a one-for-one answer for Bell. Even so, the idea of adding Goldschmidt has appeal, and former Twins reliever Tyler Duffey made that case on the “Twin Cities Territory” podcast.
“Goldy is a guy who's proven. He's the ultimate veteran, Hall of Fame candidate type player, and he's serviceable at first base,” Duffey said.
“He can help these young guys that are coming into their own and learn the game and how he attacks hitters. The guy won an MVP, he's played in New York now, he's done it under the brightest of lights.
He's kind of checked every box you can, and he's not going to carry that huge premium price tag, I would think. That's right up the Twins' alley.”
Goldschmidt could also fit neatly into a platoon role, similar to what the New York Yankees used him for this past season. The 39-year-old was outstanding against lefties, hitting .299/.393/.573 with 11 home runs in 157 at-bats against southpaws. Against right-handers, though, he struggled more, posting a .213/.239/.351 line in 188 at-bats.
That split matters for Minnesota because Jenkins and Rodriguez both hit from the left side. Goldschmidt would line up well as a platoon partner for those young bats, while Kody Clemens, also a left-handed hitter, has earned regular chances against southpaws. Goldschmidt could handle both first base and DH duties for the Twins.
Beyond the bat, he would bring something else Minnesota will need next season: veteran presence. The Twins are set to be a young club, and Goldschmidt’s background would give the room another experienced voice.
He has 16 years of MLB experience and has put together a resume that points toward Cooperstown. Goldschmidt owns 58.8 career fWAR and 65.1 bWAR, along with 390 home runs and 1,284 RBIs across his 16 big-league seasons. His trophy case includes the 2022 NL MVP award, seven All-Star selections, five Silver Slugger awards and four Gold Glove awards.
In Other News...
Josh Donaldson Just Reopened A Twins Trust Issue Fans Know Too Well
Josh Donaldson has reopened an old conversation around the Twins and one of the more frustrating themes of recent seasons: whether the club can fully trust its late-game decision-making. In looking back at his time in Minnesota, he described a loss of trust tied to bullpen management, a reminder that even talented teams can fray at the edges when the communication between dugout and clubhouse breaks down.
The broader issue has hardly gone away. Minnesotas relief corps has been a source of unease in recent years, and the fix would seem to require both sharper transparency around pitching changes and better arms to deploy when games tighten up late. Donaldsons comments do not change the past, but they do put a familiar pressure point back in view for a club still trying to convince everyone it has the bullpen answers to match the rest of its roster. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Have One Clear Challenge With Andrew Morris Next Season
Andrew Morris first season in the majors gave the Twins a better sense of what they have, even if the role changed along the way. He broke in as a starter before ending up in the bullpen, and the final line was respectable enough at a glance, with a 4.40 ERA and 1.37 WHIP across 73 2/3 innings. The deeper numbers hinted at a pitcher who may have been better than that surface result suggested, especially with a six-pitch mix that gave him plenty to work with.
Still, the next step for Minnesota is figuring out which pieces of that arsenal can truly carry him forward. Morris showed flashes of real effectiveness with his best pitch, but the challenge is finding more consistency around the edges of the mix and smoothing out the pitch that lagged behind the rest. Whether he stays in a relief role or gets another look as a starter, the Twins will want a clearer answer on how to get the most out of him next season. [Read more 🡒]
Former Twins Debuter Faces Another Tough Career Twist
Kyler Fedkos path back into pro baseball has already taken another turn, with the Pirates bringing the outfielder back on a two-year minor league contract while he continues to work his way through rehab. For Twins fans, it is a reminder of how quickly a brief big league look can lead to a new chapter elsewhere, especially for a player who first reached the majors in Minnesota in 2027 before being let go and landing in Pittsburgh.
Fedkos latest setback adds another layer to an already difficult career road. He is still recovering from knee surgery that ended his season early, and the rehab process has become the immediate focus as he tries to put himself back in position to contribute again. The Pirates have kept him in the fold, but his next step depends on getting healthy first. [Read more 🡒]