Twins Keep Facing The Same Injury Problem As Winter Plan Looms

As the Twins grapple with injury challenges affecting key players, a strategic shift towards valuing both depth and durability in player selection becomes crucial for sustained success.

Jeremy Zoll isn’t pretending there’s an easy formula for predicting injuries, and that honesty is part of the problem the Twins still have to solve.

Asked last week in Las Vegas how the club weighs injury risk and durability in player evaluations, Zoll admitted the industry is still chasing an answer that keeps slipping away.

"I think if anyone truly has the answer, I would love to meet them, because the more I talk to colleagues around the game, everyone’s like, ‘Man, if only we could figure that out,’," Zoll said last week in Las Vegas. "I think our performance team does a really good job trying to learn from mistakes and things that happen and keep building upon them."

That’s the reality for front offices everywhere: they want to reduce injury risk, but the game still refuses to give up a clean solution. Even when a team trims down total injured-list days, that doesn’t mean the right players stayed on the field.

The Twins learned that the hard way this season, when Ryan Jeffers, Joe Ryan and Byron Buxton absorbed a huge share of the team’s time on the shelf. Their absences mattered because of who they are and when they happened, especially as the club faded out of contention late.

"Our IL days [in 2026] were actually not as poor as they’ve been in some previous years. The IL days that happened were impactful and didn’t come at the best times," Zoll said. "So if you’re evaluating from a pure IL days perspective, it’s like, ‘Well, there’s improvement there,’ but to say that they didn’t have an impact on the season not going exactly how we were hoping also feels not correct, at least in my opinion."

At the same time, the Twins aren’t operating under any illusion that injuries are pure luck. The term "injury-prone" has often been thrown around carelessly, but the pattern is real: some players hold up better than others, and some handle injuries better than others. That’s a skill, and teams still struggle to measure it as well as they measure everything else.

"It’s something that I definitely lose some sleep over along the way and I’m gonna keep trying to chip away on that, but I don’t know that there’s some silver bullet to solve it, by any means," he said.

The challenge is even sharper because the Twins are built around players who have repeatedly dealt with health issues or fragility. Buxton is unlikely to qualify for the batting title in any given season, and if he does, it may come while he’s playing through a significant injury for a month or more.

Ryan has been knocked out of the rotation by injuries or has pitched worse for a fairly obvious physical reason late in every season of his career. Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodríguez, Pablo López, Trevor Larnach, Luke Keaschall, Kaelen Culpepper and Connor Prielipp have all had major injury problems.

Royce Lewis’s career was derailed by injuries.

With that kind of risk already baked in, one obvious path this winter would be to put more weight on durability in the market and look for players who post more consistently. Not necessarily to replace the injury-prone core, but to support it and absorb the damage when those players go down. Zoll, though, framed the approach differently.

"It just makes us try to be more mindful about depth and versatility and, you know, if one player goes down, how do we have the next solve and the next solve?" he said. "And I’m not saying we’ve nailed that in every year, by any means, and I think that showed up at different points this year with ultimately how we had to construct the roster because we didn’t maybe have the next exact fit that was needed at that moment, but I think it’s a lot more about versatility and depth than just straight valuing durability."

That’s a sensible line on its face. A team doesn’t help itself by signing a mediocre player simply because he’s always available.

But the Twins’ reluctance to prioritize availability has also left them leaning too heavily on depth and versatility, which can mean playing bad players in a different form. The stated goal has been to preserve upside, since chasing reliability too aggressively can squeeze out variance.

"Not that we don’t value durability. I just think you also want to be mindful of, ‘How can we chase variance?’"

he said. "Sometimes, that comes with taking on risk, and you’re trying to constantly balance those factors."

That’s an understandable philosophy. The Twins want a roster with a high ceiling, and that often means taking on the kind of risk that makes better talent available at a lower price.

But the results haven’t been kind. Over the last nine seasons, the Twins have reached more than 82 wins only twice.

They’ve made the playoffs three times, including the 2020 COVID season.

So the next step is clear enough: they need a better balance. With a low-cost young core and an owner signaling a willingness to spend more, the Twins should be in position to pursue some higher-priced players this winter - the kind who bring both durability and above-average performance. For once, they can afford to treat availability as a real asset without giving up everything else.

In Other News...

Twins Face A Tough 40-Man Call On A Promising Right-Hander

The Twins have a roster decision looming by Tuesday at 6 p.m., when they must add eligible players to the 40-man roster to shield them from the Rule 5 draft, even if that draft is likely to be pushed back by an expected lockout. Among the 31 players in the mix, right-hander C.J. Culpepper stands out as one of the more compelling names, thanks to the way he has performed in the minors and the sense that his path to the majors could come as soon as 2027.

Culpepper has worked both as a starter and a reliever, and his 2026 results were uneven, but the organization still sees enough in the underlying skills to make him a serious protection candidate. For a front office trying to balance immediate roster needs with long-term value, he represents exactly the kind of arm that can force a difficult call, especially when a promising pitcher is close enough to matter but not so close that the choice feels easy. [Read more 🡒]

Ryan Jeffers Just Defined A Crucial Twins Offseason Decision

Ryan Jeffers decision to accept the Twins qualifying offer gives Minnesota a clear path into a winter that already needed some sorting out behind the plate. The one-year deal, worth $23.15 million, keeps one of the clubs most important everyday pieces in place for at least another season and removes one of the more immediate questions facing the front office as it maps out the roster and payroll.

The bigger picture is what makes the move matter. The qualifying offer is designed to give teams a chance to retain key players while attaching draft-pick compensation if they leave, and several notable names around the league chose to test the market instead. Jeffers did not, which gives the Twins some stability at a premium position, even if the long-term shape of his future in Minnesota still has to be worked out later. [Read more 🡒]

Twins May Finally Be Seeing The Kyle DeBarge Breakthrough

Kyle DeBarges fall in the Arizona Fall League has given the Twins something worth tracking a little more closely. The prospect put together a loud offensive showing over 21 games, and the numbers backed up what the eye test suggested: more impact, more consistency and a version of his swing that looked better suited to do damage without giving away all his contact.

The encouraging part for Minnesota is that this did not come out of nowhere. DeBarge made swing adjustments late in the 2026 season, and those changes appear to have improved both his balance and the quality of his contact. Twins director of player development Drew McPhail said DeBarge found a blend of contact and power, which is exactly the kind of development the organization wants to see as he tries to turn a strong fall into something more lasting. [Read more 🡒]