Tom Pohlad spent his first year running the Minnesota Twins in a spot plenty of owners know well: trying to turn a little hope into something lasting. The club stayed in the American League playoff conversation longer than expected, but the noise around the team suggested the fan base saw the bigger picture. Attendance dropped to its lowest level since the 2000 season, and that told its own story.
Now Pohlad is left with the harder part - proving the promise of a young roster comes with real backing behind it. He said the right things through Dan Hayes of The Athletic, stressing both the core already in place and the urgency to build on it.
“We have a young, exciting core in place and now it’s ownership’s responsibility to support them,” Pohlad said via Dan Hayes of The Athletic. “I understand [fans’] patience in this market has run out, and I can assure you we have a sense of urgency. The work to build on the foundation we laid this year began [when the season ended.]”
That kind of message matters, but Twins fans have heard versions of it before. What they want now is proof that the organization is ready to do more than talk about a turnaround.
The most obvious place to look is payroll, and the numbers have been shrinking. Since the Twins won their first playoff game and first playoff series in nearly two decades in 2023, they have cut about $58 million from payroll, according to Bobby Nightengale of the Minnesota Star Tribune. Their Opening Day payroll this year sat at $109 million, which ranked 22nd among MLB’s 30 teams.
Pohlad did authorize additions before the trade deadline, but the combined cost of Dean Kremer, Jeff Hoffman and A.J. Minter came out to just $8 million. He also said a payroll under $100 million is “not sufficient” to chase a championship, though he would not put a firm number on future spending when Aaron Gleeman of AaronGleeman.com asked him directly.
“In a vacuum, I’d love to level-set, and set expectations, for the fan base,” Pohlad said. “But I think it does this organization, and particular [general manager Jeremy Zoll], a disservice to pigeonhole ourselves in that way.
We’ve talked about a range. We’re not going to be an organization going forward that says, ‘This is the number and you’re going to have to stick to that.’
I don’t think that’s realistic if you want to be flexible and adapt to the opportunities that present themselves.”
There are reasons for that caution. After a year of turbulence around the franchise, Minnesota may not be an easy sell to free agents, even with young names like Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez and Kaelen Culpepper in the system. The Twins can make a real offer and still lose out to a more appealing destination, which is part of why this franchise has often been remembered for being “in on” players who wound up elsewhere.
There’s also the matter of the next collective bargaining agreement. If Pohlad were to publicly lock in a figure, say $130 million, it could become ammunition in labor talks as players push to preserve big-money deals.
So if spending rises, it may look more like 2018, when the Twins added Lance Lynn, Logan Morrison and Addison Reed on shorter-term deals with more meaningful dollars attached, rather than the middle-of-the-night Carlos Correa swing in 2022.
But payroll is only part of the fix. The bigger problem is that the current shape of the roster has already shown what it is: not enough.
The Twins won the American League Central in the COVID-shortened 2020 season, but even that group was heading the wrong way before the sweep by the Houston Astros in the Wild Card round. Then came a 73-89 season in 2021, followed by more collapse and another missed postseason in four of the past five years. This year followed a familiar script, with the Twins hanging around the AL Wild Card race before going 21-30 over the final two months.
The deadline fire sale in 2025 stripped away some players who could have helped, but Minnesota also held onto pieces it has kept through multiple disappointments. There was a real case for dealing Ryan Jeffers and Joe Ryan, especially with the club chasing a possible late run that might have pulled fans back into the building. That run never arrived.
If the Twins did not sell as aggressively as some expected, Jeffers and Ryan could still fit into the next phase. But they are not alone in that conversation. Royce Lewis, Trevor Larnach and Bailey Ober were also named as players who should probably be on the way out.
That leaves Pohlad with a messy, high-stakes balancing act. Moving on from more players would send a harsh signal.
Standing pat would leave the roster stuck in the same place. And if the MLB salary floor ends up above where Minnesota is projecting, the club would have to spend anyway just to fill out the team.
The challenge goes beyond wins and losses, too. Pohlad has to rebuild trust with fans who have drifted away since the 2023 success, and with others whose frustration stretches back decades to the days when Tom’s grandfather, Carl Pohlad, threatened to move the team to North Carolina, put it up for contraction and imposed similar spending limits.
None of that gets fixed with $2 beers, rally dancers or loyalty programs. If the Twins are going to change the conversation, it will have to come through the roster and the results. That is the real test waiting for Tom Pohlad as this offseason begins.
In Other News...
Twins Face A Crucial Pitching Decision After A Disappointing Year
The Twins are moving quickly into a pivotal offseason task on the mound, with Pete Maki gone and a new pitching coach to be hired before the club settles into its next phase. Minnesotas search is expected to reach beyond the organization, as the front office looks for candidates who can bring outside experience and a fresh voice while still fitting with the teams analytical bent.
Derek Shelton is expected to play a major role in shaping that hire, which gives the process a little extra weight after a disappointing year. For a staff that needs both stability and a new direction, this is more than a routine coaching change - it is one of the first signs of how the Twins plan to recalibrate their pitching program going forward. [Read more 🡒]
Former Twin Ty France Is Back In Spotlight For A Brutal Twist
Ty France found himself at the center of one of the strangest moments of the postseason in NLDS Game 1, when a deep ninth-inning drive seemed to have a chance to change everything for the Padres. Instead, the ball hit a cable on the Brewers roof and was caught, a bizarre ending that left France and San Diego without the kind of late momentum they were chasing. After the game, France voiced his frustration with the call, saying technology ought to be able to settle plays like that.
For Minnesota fans, the wrinkle is seeing a former Twin back in the spotlight for a far more painful reason than his season-long revival in San Diego. France has bounced back strongly with the Padres after below-average offensive stretches with both the Twins and Blue Jays, and he has become their most valuable player by bWAR. The twist is how quickly a players postseason narrative can turn, especially when a ball that looked like trouble for the Brewers never quite became the home run it appeared to be. [Read more 🡒]
Emmanuel Rodriguez Already Put One Big Twins Question In Focus
Emmanuel Rodriguezs first look in the majors gave the Twins exactly the kind of glimpse they wanted and a few reminders of how far he still has to go. In 48 plate appearances, the young outfielder showed the power and defensive energy that made him such an intriguing call-up, offering a sample of the upside Minnesota has been waiting to see translate to big-league games.
Rodriguez also ran into the adjustment every rookie eventually faces, with the strikeouts piling up and his walk rate dipping from what he had shown in the minors. For the Twins, the early takeaway is less about a finished product than about a player who already has one major question in focus as he learns what major league pitchers are willing to give him and what they are not. [Read more 🡒]