Twins Deadline Direction Just Got More Complicated Than Fans Expected

As MLB teams strategize ahead of the trade deadline, stars like Bryce Harper and emerging talents like Clay Holmes become central to trade discussions, shaping the season's outcomes.

With five days left before the Aug. 3 trade deadline, the market is still waiting for the big swings. The Connelly-Early-for-Curtis-Mead deal has been the summer’s biggest move so far, but the real fireworks are expected to land close to the 6 p.m.

ET cutoff on Monday. Until then, the rumor mill is starting to heat up.

The Phillies are one of the teams already feeling the pressure. After Tuesday night’s 1-0 loss to Miami, Bryce Harper didn’t dance around the obvious.

“I think we need some help. But you know, I think we've proved pretty much all year we've done a pretty good job.

But anytime you can get some help in here and reinforcements, I think it helps,” Harper said (via MLB.com).

That frustration makes sense given how Philadelphia has played since the break. The Phillies are 3-8 in that stretch and have managed just 43 runs across those 11 games, even with a 10-run outing and an 11-run outing in the mix.

They’re in need of another outfielder, preferably a right-handed bat, and they could also use an upgrade at third base over Alec Bohm. Brian Keller’s elbow injury has created another opening in the bullpen.

Even so, the Phillies still hold a two-game edge on a wild-card spot.

Clay Holmes is also drawing plenty of attention as teams start lining up their plans. Scouts from the Diamondbacks, Rays, Red Sox, White Sox, and others watched his rehab start Tuesday, according to MLB.com.

The Mets right-hander threw 59 pitches over four scoreless innings in Low Class-A and averaged 93.1 mph with his sinker. It was his second rehab appearance after a comebacker broke his leg on May 15.

Holmes’ situation adds another wrinkle. Even with the injury, he is expected to turn down his $12 million player option after the season and head to free agency, which would make him a rental. He can start, and he brings plenty of bullpen and postseason experience, which gives contenders another interesting option even if they already like what they have on the mound.

Minnesota, meanwhile, is leaning the other way. After Tuesday’s 3-2 walk-off win over Kansas City, GM Jeremy Zoll made it clear the Twins are planning to add rather than sell.

“It wasn't some situation where (we) were prepping to sell and we're switching. Now we're looking forward to try and execute on that work ...

All along, we were optimistic we were going to be in this spot to be able to add,” Zoll said (via The Athletic).

The Twins have some pieces that could draw real interest. Catcher Ryan Jeffers is one of the better rentals on the board, and starter Joe Ryan would also be in demand because of his team control.

Minnesota is carrying three catchers - Jeffers, Victor Caratini, and Alex Jackson - so a Jeffers move would not be a shock, though it could come back in a deal for MLB talent rather than prospects. The Twins are just a half-game behind the third wild-card spot.

Miami is also taking calls. With rookie Joe Mack emerging, the Marlins are open to moving first baseman/catcher Liam Hicks, according to MLB.com.

The club wants controllable players in return, not rentals, The Athletic reported. Six teams are known to be looking for catching help: the Dodgers, Rangers, Rays, Red Sox, White Sox, and Yankees.

Hicks, 27, is under team control through 2030. He’s a capable catcher, but right now he’s only behind the plate once every four or five games because Mack has taken over more of the workload.

Hicks has mostly been used at first base and DH. Mack, one of the game’s top throwing catchers, has become a real building block for Miami, so at the very least it makes sense for the Marlins to see what the market says about Hicks.

St. Louis is in a trickier spot.

The Cardinals are still hanging around the wild-card race, but they do not appear ready to abandon the bigger-picture plan, according to The Athletic. Rental pitchers Dustin May and Ryne Stanek are likely to be moved, and the Cardinals want players with control beyond this season rather than more rentals.

That creates a real deadline dilemma for St. Louis.

Moving May would open a rotation spot for Hunter Dobbins, who has handled spot-starting duties well. Rental lefty JoJo Romero is on the injured list after an appendectomy, but he could still be dealt.

Lars Nootbaar, though, is under team control next season, so there is no urgency to move him, and he could remain with the Cardinals past the deadline.

In Other News...

Josh Bell Just Said What Twins Fans Need To Hear

Josh Bell has a simple message for the front office as the trade deadline approaches: dont tear this thing down again. The veteran first baseman sees a Twins club with a real offense, promising young talent and enough in place to keep pushing, and he made it clear the group would rather be reinforced than reshaped. From his perspective, the conversation around Minnesota should be about adding to a roster that still believes it can matter.

The biggest hole still looks familiar, though, and it sits in the bullpen. Relief pitching has emerged as the clearest need if the Twins want to stay in the postseason mix, and the sense around the team is that one or two additions could make a real difference. For a clubhouse trying to prove it belongs together, the deadline will say plenty about whether the organization is ready to back that up. [Read more 🡒]

Twins May Have Found The Smart Deadline Pitching Move Fans Wanted

The Twins appear ready to approach the deadline like a club that believes it can still play into October, and that makes the pitching market especially interesting. Rather than chasing a short-term rental, Minnesota is being linked to a starter with enough quality to help the rotation now and enough team control to matter beyond this season, a combination that fits a front office trying to avoid a one-and-done move.

Seattles surplus on the mound only adds to the intrigue, since the Mariners are in position to deal from strength while looking for offense. For Minnesota, the appeal is obvious: a pitcher who can steady the staff in the stretch run and remain part of the long-term plan would be the kind of deadline addition that feels both aggressive and measured, even if the final price and timing are still very much in play. [Read more 🡒]

Twins Get Troubling David Festa Update No One Wanted To Hear

David Festas season has been headed in the wrong direction for a while, and the latest update only deepens the concern for the Twins. The right-hander, who has been on the 60-day injured list all year, has not pitched in a regular-season game since last July, leaving Minnesota without a young arm it had hoped could factor into the pitching mix.

Now the next step is surgery, with Festa set to have procedures on his shoulder and pectoral muscle. General manager Jeremy Zoll said Festa is likely to miss the entire season, a sobering development for a club that has already had to plan around his absence and now has to wait even longer to see what comes next. [Read more 🡒]