The Toronto Blue Jays are still hanging around the American League Wild Card race, and that has to sting a little for Jeff Hoffman.
Toronto sent the right-handed reliever to the Minnesota Twins on Aug. 3 in a deadline deal that made sense on paper for both sides. The Twins were buying, the Blue Jays were selling, and Minnesota landed Hoffman while Toronto got a prospect package led by left-hander Dasan Hill.
Now the picture looks a lot different. Minnesota is fading fast after a 9-2 loss to the Cleveland Guardians on Sunday afternoon dropped the club to 70-79. The Twins are 5 1/2 games back of Cleveland for the final AL Wild Card spot with 13 games left, which means they pretty much have to win out to have any real shot at the postseason.
Toronto, meanwhile, is still alive. The Blue Jays sit just one game behind the Guardians for the last Wild Card spot at 75-75, and they own the tiebreaker over Cleveland.
Hoffman has done his part since arriving in Minnesota. In 13 2/3 innings with the Twins, he has posted a 2.63 ERA, a 1.24 WHIP and 21 strikeouts. From Toronto’s perspective, that’s the kind of production that can make a deadline trade look painful in a hurry.
For the Twins, the deal could still turn into something they’re happy with down the line. They gave up Hill, along with right-hander John Klein and infielder Damuery Pena, but Hoffman is under team control through next year.
If he helps Minnesota get back to the playoffs in 2027, the trade will look a lot better. And if the Twins decide to sell at next season’s deadline, they can move Hoffman again.
If Toronto gets into the postseason, Hoffman will probably have a split reaction. He’ll have reasons to be happy for his former teammates, but he’ll also know he’d rather be there with them.
That feeling could hit even harder because of how last season ended for the Blue Jays. Toronto pushed all the way to World Series Game 7 against the Los Angeles Dodgers and was two outs from winning it all before Dodgers infielder Miguel Rojas tied the game with a ninth-inning home run. The Dodgers went on to win in extra innings, and Hoffman was the pitcher who gave up that homer to Rojas.
In Other News...
Twins Have A Byron Buxton Decision That Could Reshape Center Field
Byron Buxton has made his preference clear: he wants to stay in center field, the spot where he has been one of the games most electric defenders and a two-time All-Star. For the Twins, that creates more than a simple lineup note. It ties directly into how they want to structure their outfield in the years ahead, especially with Buxtons health now part of every conversation after the recurring hip issue that will need surgery.
Minnesota is also looking at a changing roster around him, with Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez and Luke Keaschall all adding to the sense that the clubs outfield picture is getting crowded in a hurry. The challenge for the Twins is figuring out how much longer Buxton can stay in the middle while still giving the team the best chance to compete, and whether the answer for 2027 means keeping the defense anchored around him or making room for the next wave. [Read more 🡒]
Joe Ryan Trade Buzz Leaves Twins With One Huge Problem
Joe Ryan has been living in the rumor mill for more than a year, and the talk only picked up after the Twins started moving established players in 2025. Even with all that speculation, Minnesota kept him, and he is now headed into the final year of team control in 2027, which usually means the phone keeps ringing. For a club trying to thread the needle between competing and reworking the roster, Ryan remains one of the most obvious names to monitor.
The problem for the Twins is that a trade path is not nearly as clean as the buzz suggests. Ryans second-half performance has raised questions, his injury status is still unclear, and the possibility of a baseball lockout could change the market in ways that make an offseason deal harder to justify. So while he may keep popping up in conversations, Minnesota has to decide whether the timing is right to move a pitcher who still brings real value, or whether the risk is too high to cash in now. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Prospect C.J. Culpepper Is Forcing A Tough 2025 Decision
C.J. Culpepper is finally getting the kind of uninterrupted season the Twins had been waiting to see since they drafted him in 2022, and the results have made him a more interesting name in the organization. Working out of the bullpen in Double-A and Triple-A, he has settled into a relief role after a long stretch of health setbacks, and the early returns have been encouraging enough to keep him in the conversation as a potential future option.
The move to relief has also asked a different kind of adjustment from Culpepper, especially on the mental side, and he has leaned on veteran teammates to help with that transition. He is carrying a 4.00 ERA while showing promising underlying performance, and the next step is simply to keep stacking good outings as he pushes toward a possible major league opening in 2025. [Read more 🡒]