The Twins are staring at a deadline call that really boils down to one question: does Joe Ryan want to be part of the long-term plan?
That’s the hinge point. Ryan is 6-6 with a 3.38 ERA, even after giving up six homers in Monday’s loss to the Cleveland Guardians, and he’s under team control through after the 2027 season. He’s also one of the most attractive arms on the market, which is exactly why Minnesota has to think hard about whether to keep him or cash in while his value is high.
On paper, the easy answer is to hold onto him. Ryan has been dependable, he’s pitching well and he’s coming off back-to-back All-Star seasons. But if an extension isn’t in the cards, the Twins may be better off moving him now rather than waiting and risking a messier outcome later.
The contract piece is where this gets complicated. Ryan and the Twins settled on a one-year, $6.2 million deal to avoid arbitration last spring, and that agreement includes a $13 million mutual option for 2027.
Minnesota would surely take that option, but Ryan’s performance makes it likely he’d turn it down. If that happens, the sides could be back in arbitration next offseason.
An extension is the other route, but that comes with its own problems. A four- or five-year deal in the neighborhood of $20 million per year would make sense, and it would be in the ballpark of the four-year, $73.5 million extension the Twins gave Pablo Lopez in 2023. But starting pitching keeps getting more expensive, and by the time Ryan reaches free agency, the price could be pushing $30 million annually.
That kind of number has not exactly been Minnesota’s style. A four-year, $120 million commitment for a pitcher who would be 31 when he hits the open market doesn’t sound like the sort of move the Twins have been eager to make in recent years. Still, a new collective bargaining agreement with a salary floor could change the math and force teams to spend somewhere.
There’s another wrinkle, too: the deal has to work for Ryan as much as it works for the Twins. If last year’s deadline fire sale left a bad taste, he may not be eager to sign on for more years in Minnesota. If that’s the case, the front office may need to act sooner rather than later.
The Twins have seen a version of this before. In 2021, they tried to keep Jose Berrios, but once the gap on a new contract got too wide, they sent him to the trade market. The return was Simeon Woods Richardson and Austin Martin from the Toronto Blue Jays.
At the time, that looked like a strong haul. Martin was MLB Pipeline’s No. 22 prospect in baseball, and Woods Richardson was No.
- But the deal hasn’t aged well.
Martin’s ceiling now looks more like a fourth outfielder, and Woods Richardson is no longer in the organization and is currently at Triple-A after returning to the Blue Jays earlier this year. That history should make fans nervous, but the bigger lesson was that Minnesota took two big swings on high-end talent.
Waiting can make sense if the Twins stay in the race. The Milwaukee Brewers did that with Corbin Burnes in 2023, rode out his penultimate year of control and won the National League Central. But when they finally traded Burnes to the Baltimore Orioles the next offseason, the return was less impactful: infielder Joey Ortiz, DL Hall and the No. 34 overall pick in the MLB Draft, which became first baseman Blake Burke.
Ortiz has become a starter for the Brewers, but he has a career .654 OPS in four major league seasons. Hall is now a reliever with control issues, and Burke is at Double-A Biloxi in his age-23 season.
A return like that would still help Minnesota’s organizational depth. But if the Twins are going to move Ryan, the better play might be to swing big again and try to land a piece they can build around.
A team like the Chicago Cubs, for example, could potentially put Matt Shaw, MLB Pipeline’s No. 19 prospect before the 2025 season, into a package with something extra. Or maybe a club chasing Tarik Skubal would be willing to send a deal that strengthens both the pitching staff and the infield.
That’s the decision ahead. If Ryan is open to staying, the Twins have every reason to explore it. If he isn’t, Minnesota may be wise to take the best offer on the table and keep building for what comes next.
In Other News...
Twins Make A Sudden Infield Decision That Raises Bigger Questions
Orlando Arcias time in the organization has come to an end after the Twins moved on from the veteran infielder at Triple-A St. Paul. Arcia had been part of the big-league picture earlier this season, getting into 19 games before being sent down in mid-June, and his path through the roster reflected how quickly Minnesotas infield depth has shifted over the past few months.
The timing leaves a larger roster question hanging over the clubs bench construction. Arcia had been one of the more experienced options available, with the ability to cover multiple infield spots, and his departure puts even more pressure on the current mix of Brooks Lee, Ryan Kreidler and Kody Clemens to handle the middle of the diamond without a true backup middle infielder waiting in reserve. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Pitchers First St. Paul Outing Brought An Embarrassing New Problem
Woo-Suk Gos return to Triple-A St. Paul was supposed to be a reset, a chance to get his footing again after a rough stretch with the Twins. Instead, the right-handers first outing with the Saints turned into an awkward scene before he even threw a pitch, adding another layer to a frustrating start to his season in Minnesota.
The game quickly shifted from baseball to a rules discussion, with the Saints dugout pulled into the matter as the umpires examined Gos glove. For a pitcher who had just been sent back down after four big-league appearances, the episode only deepened the scrutiny around him and left the Twins with yet another uncomfortable subplot to monitor. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Suddenly Have The Prospect Wave Fans Have Waited For
With the Twins hanging around the AL Central race and still within reach of a wild card spot, the organization suddenly has a different kind of momentum building behind the big league club. Fangraphs latest Top 100 prospect update underlined that depth in a big way, placing seven Minnesota prospects on the list and giving the system the kind of national attention that has been missing for a while. Walker Jenkins and Kaelen Culpepper headline the group, but the bigger takeaway is that this is no longer just a collection of distant lottery tickets.
Several of those names are already moving through the upper levels of the minors, which is what makes this so relevant to the Twins right now. Jenkins is knocking on the door at Triple-A, Culpepper is there too and looks like a potential everyday middle infielder, and the rest of the group gives Minnesota a wave of talent that could start feeding the roster sooner rather than later. The only real question is how soon the front office decides to let that pipeline start shaping the club in St. Paul. [Read more 🡒]