Twins Already Have An Early Catching Debate Worth Watching

As top draft picks Vahn Lackey and Carson Tinney take their first professional at-bats, their performances spotlight both promising potential and areas ripe for growth.

A little more than a month into pro ball, the Twins’ two top picks from the 2026 MLB Draft are already getting a real workload at Low-A Fort Myers. Catchers Vahn Lackey and Carson Tinney have taken on most of the receiving duties there, and even in a small sample, both have flashed the traits that made them attractive draft targets.

Lackey was the first of the two off the board, and his start has been built more on athleticism and strike-zone control than loud damage. In 44 at-bats, he has nine hits, with two doubles and two triples, along with seven RBIs and nine runs scored. He’s also added three stolen bases and drawn nine walks, which stands out even more because he hasn’t exactly been raking.

The swing-and-miss has been the biggest blemish. Lackey has struck out 15 times in those 44 at-bats, but the plate approach behind the numbers still looks promising.

He’s been swinging at only 36.8% of the pitches he’s seen, a sign that the discipline he showed at Georgia Tech has carried over into the pro game. Instead of chasing, he’s letting pitchers come to him, and they haven’t been giving him much to work with.

The power hasn’t shown up yet - he still hasn’t hit his first professional home run - and his contact quality hasn’t been eye-popping. But the early read is still encouraging. Lackey looks like a smart hitter with plus athleticism for the position, someone who can put the ball in play, reach base, and keep the pressure on.

His defense has been part of the story too. Lackey has thrown out six baserunners on 23 attempts, a 26% caught-stealing rate.

That number was higher earlier in the month, but teams have clearly been willing to test him. That was always going to be a major part of his profile, and it will matter just as much as the bat as he keeps moving.

Tinney’s first taste of pro baseball has looked different, but just as intriguing. The University of Texas product was drafted as the more power-oriented bat, and he’s already shown why.

In his first 13 games, he has hit four home runs, including a walk-off shot. His first professional homer left the bat at 115 MPH, a pretty loud introduction to the organization.

At the same time, Tinney has also shown the same selective approach that followed him into pro ball. In 58 plate appearances, he has 13 walks and 19 strikeouts.

He’s hitting .159, but his on-base percentage sits at .362. Like Lackey, he has been extremely choosy at the plate, with a swing rate of 30.9%.

That’s lower than Lackey’s, and it even means he’s taking fewer than half of the pitches he sees in the strike zone. There’s a case to be made that he could stand to be a little more aggressive on strikes, though that’s easier said than done when pitchers aren’t giving him much to hit.

When Tinney connects, the quality has been real. He’s posted a 92 MPH average exit velocity and a 90th-percentile exit velocity of 103.3 MPH. The sample is tiny, but the early power translation is exactly what the Twins were hoping to see.

The defensive side has been less encouraging so far. Tinney came into the draft with a 60-grade arm, but it hasn’t shown up yet in games.

Opposing runners have swiped seven bases against him, and he hasn’t thrown anyone out. Teams haven’t run as often on Tinney as they have on Lackey, but when they have, they’ve been successful.

None of this should be overread. Both players are still in the earliest stages of their professional careers, and there will be plenty of ups and downs from here.

Even so, Lackey and Tinney have already shown enough to hint at why the Twins were so interested in them. They’ve each earned everyday reps, and that alone gives this first stretch a real purpose.

In Other News...

Twins Make A Surprising Roster Choice As Playoff Questions Grow

With playoff questions beginning to hover around the roster, the Twins made a curious-looking move by adding catcher David Bauelos from the St. Paul Saints and bringing him to the majors. The decision gives Minnesota a fourth catcher on its 26-man roster, a choice general manager Jeremy Zoll framed as a matter of flexibility as much as anything else, with the club already carrying three catchers and looking for ways to keep its options open.

The move also says something about how the Twins are balancing the present and the future. Rather than push top prospect Walker Jenkins into the mix, the organization opted to leave him in Triple-A for more development, even as the major league roster takes on a little more protection behind the plate. Bauelos may not be in line for immediate playing time, but his promotion shows Minnesota is willing to use an uncommon roster wrinkle to give itself another layer of coverage as the season enters a more uncertain stretch. [Read more 🡒]

Twins Just Sent A Message With Sweep Of First-Place Braves

Wednesdays finish at Target Field gave the Twins another reminder that this group can make noise even when it is still trying to settle in. Culpepper turned in the first three-hit game of his career, and Minnesota used his timely bat to help fuel a 6-4 win over the Braves, finishing off a three-game sweep of a first-place club. His work in the middle innings helped get rallies moving, including a go-ahead run in the fifth that shifted the tone of the afternoon.

Minnesota kept pushing from there, adding insurance in the seventh and then leaning on strong relief pitching to hold the lead in the eighth. For a Twins team looking to stack meaningful wins early, sweeping Atlanta at home carried the kind of weight that goes beyond one afternoon in the standings. It also left Culpepper's breakout performance and the way the lineup responded as the bigger takeaway, even with plenty of season still ahead. [Read more 🡒]