The Twins have a Ryan Jeffers decision looming, and his rough stretch after the All-Star break has only made it trickier.
At the deadline, Minnesota chose to keep Jeffers instead of moving him for what likely would have been a strong return. That call looked a lot more defensible when the Twins were still in the playoff race. Now, with the club eliminated from contention and six games left in the season, it’s easy to see why the front office may be second-guessing that move.
Jeffers was one of the most obvious trade candidates on the roster in early August. The Twins had spent most of the year below .500, and there were plenty of contenders interested in a catcher who was in the middle of the best offensive season of his career. He’s in his age-29 season and is headed for free agency for the first time.
The second half, though, has cooled the conversation around a qualifying offer. Jeffers is hitting .145 with a .540 OPS in September, a brutal month that follows a much better first half.
Before the All-Star break, he was batting .292 with seven homers and a .940 OPS in 39 games. Since the break, he’s hit .222 with seven homers and a .713 OPS in 50 games.
Even with that drop-off, the full-season line still stands out for a catcher: .252/.351/.461. His season started fast, too. He posted a .927 OPS in March and April, then a .993 OPS in May before fracturing his hamate bone on May 18, an injury that sidelined him for nearly two months.
At the trade deadline, Jeffers looked like a strong bet to get the qualifying offer. That’s no longer so clear after a September slump.
The qualifying offer amount has not been set yet for this season, but it’s based on the mean salary of the 125 highest-paid players in the league. Last offseason, 13 players received the QO, and four accepted: Trent Grisham, Gleyber Torres, Brandon Woodruff, and Shota Imanaga.
The last Twin to get one was Sonny Gray after the 2023 season, and he declined it before signing a multi-year deal with the Cardinals.
There’s also a clear reason Minnesota may have been willing to keep Jeffers rather than trade him. Because he had never received a qualifying offer before and would finish the season with the club, the Twins could recoup draft compensation if he declined a QO and signed elsewhere.
If he lands a deal worth more than $50 million, Minnesota would get a Competitive Balance Round A pick, likely in the mid-30s. If he signs for under $50 million, the compensation would be a Competitive Balance Round B pick, likely in the high-60s.
The Twins have five days after the World Series ends to decide whether to extend the offer. If they do, Jeffers would have 10 days to accept or reject it.
Minnesota’s need at catcher makes the decision even sharper. Victor Caratini is the only other catcher on the 40-man roster, and his bat has been quiet, especially after the break, when he’s hit .176 with a .449 OPS. The defense has been fine, and he’s been really good with the ABS, but with a $7 million salary due next year, he looks more like a backup option for 2027.
If Jeffers leaves, the Twins will need another starter behind the plate, and the free-agent market doesn’t offer much. The top three upcoming unrestricted free-agent catchers by bWAR, not including Jeffers, are Tyler Stephenson at 2.5, Austin Hedges at 0.8, and Christian Vazquez at 0.4.
There is at least some longer-term hope in the system. The Twins used the third overall pick in the 2026 MLB Draft on catcher Vahn Lackey out of Georgia Tech, and he got off to a promising start in pro ball. Over his first 25 games, split between Low-A and High-A, he hit .250/.435/.424 with three homers, 16 RBI and six caught stealing.
That doesn’t change the immediate Jeffers calculus, though. Lackey probably won’t reach the majors until at least 2028, with late 2027 being the earliest realistic window if he tears through the minors next year.
So the Twins are left with the same tough question, only now with a less certain answer. Jeffers’ second-half slide has made the qualifying offer harder to project, but his season as a whole still puts him in the mix. If Minnesota wants him back, the likeliest path may be offering the QO and hoping he takes it.
In Other News...
Twins Enter A Crucial Offseason With One Roster Weakness Looming
The Twins are heading into the offseason with more questions than answers after finishing 2026 below .500, and the front office has a pretty clear starting point for its winter work. The bullpen stands out as the biggest issue, especially with several key left-handed relief options set to hit free agency, leaving a hole that could affect the shape of the entire relief corps if it is not addressed quickly.
Catcher and first base also need attention, even if those spots are further down the priority list. Free-agent help looks limited, which means Minnesota may need to get creative through trades or complementary signings as it tries to rebuild a roster that has too many obvious gaps and not enough easy fixes. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Front Office Reset Just Took Another Significant Turn
The Twins front office makeover picked up another notch this week with the mutual parting of ways with assistant general manager Daniel Adler. Adler had been in the organization since 2017, when he was hired by former president of baseball operations Derek Falvey, and his exit comes as the club continues to reshape its leadership structure under general manager Jeremy Zoll.
Zoll is now expected to keep building out the department with new hires after a string of departures has changed the look of the operation. With Falvey already gone earlier this year and another longtime voice now out of the picture, the Twins are steadily moving into a new era in the front office. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Suddenly Have A Closing Debate They Cant Ignore
The Twins bullpen has been one of the seasons most revealing storylines, and not for the kind of stability clubs usually want at the back end of games. Minnesota set an American League record by turning to 15 different pitchers for saves, a sign of just how often the ninth inning has shifted from one arm to another. Jeff Hoffman became the latest name in that mix, but the larger picture is still centered on how the team has tried to piece together a reliable finish.
Yoendrys Gmez has been the most productive option overall, leading the club with 21 saves, though his season has been uneven enough to keep the debate alive. After a dominant stretch earlier in the year, he struggled in September, which is why the Twins are still weighing what the late-inning hierarchy should look like moving forward. Hoffmans emergence only adds another layer to a bullpen that has spent much of the season searching for a clear answer. [Read more 🡒]