The Twins have spent enough time moving Royce Lewis around that the next decision feels bigger than just picking a spot on the field. If Minnesota keeps him this offseason, it needs to stop treating him like a movable piece and start treating him like a player with a defined job.
That matters because Lewis’s 2026 season has not looked like the bounce-back the Twins were hoping for. In 119 games, he is hitting .228/.291/.383 with 14 homers, 24 doubles and an 88 OPS+. He showed real signs of life after coming back from the minors and carried that improvement well into August, but the finish has been ugly enough to leave the organization with a real question: what exactly is his best path forward?
Second base makes a strong case as the answer. Lewis has the kind of traits that can play there - lateral quickness, soft hands and a bit of speed - and those tools matter more at second than they do at first.
The Twins have already spent time testing him there, including a three-week stretch from the All-Star break through early August. He was back at second base Saturday in Anaheim, and he also played the position in St.
Paul during his minor-league stint. In the majors, he has logged 106 1/3 innings at second base, almost all of them this season, and he owns 1 OAA there, his only positive mark at any position in 2026.
Even so, the sample is still thin enough that Minnesota doesn’t have a perfect read on what that position would look like over a full season. Offensively, though, second base is the cleaner fit.
The league’s second basemen are hitting .248/.317/.380 this year, and the Twins would almost certainly need the version of Lewis who hit .256/.313/.436 in his first 300 plate appearances after returning from St. Paul.
If they don’t believe that bat can clear the bar at second, the rest of the conversation starts to fall apart.
First base changes the equation in a different way. The defensive burden is lighter there, and that can help cover for a player who is still learning the position.
Lewis has shown enough to suggest he can be a useful receiver of throws, with Statcast crediting him for positive value there at 2 OAA. But his overall first-base defense has still been worth -3 OAA as he has tried to pick up the position on the fly.
The catch is that first base raises the offensive standard. A .700 OPS can be lived with from a middle infielder if the glove holds up.
At first, that same production is much harder to sell. League-wide, first basemen have hit .256/.337/.438 this year, and Lewis has only matched that level for stretches of a month or two.
So the question is not just where he can stand. It’s where he can grow.
If Lewis is told he’s the everyday second baseman, he can spend the winter preparing for that job and focus on getting his offense back on track. If he’s moved to first, he can sharpen his work there and try to make his bat carry the position.
Either way, clarity matters. Another season of bouncing around would solve nothing.
That is why second base should be the starting point if the Twins keep him. It gives Minnesota a chance to use more of Lewis’s athleticism and lets his bat develop without the heavier offensive expectations that come with first base.
It also opens up a more flexible infield picture. A Lewis-Kaelen Culpepper-Brooks Lee alignment would give the Twins three players with different defensive profiles, and if Lewis becomes even an average second baseman, Minnesota could have an athletic group with real upside.
Of course, that also assumes the Twins handle the rest of the roster with purpose and go get a productive first baseman this offseason. That may be the most important piece of all.
For Lewis, the assignment is simple enough to say and hard enough to execute: settle in, learn one position, and spend a full season building from there. If that position is second base, the Twins are betting on his athleticism in the middle of the diamond.
If it’s first base, they’re betting the bat can carry the load. Either way, choosing the right home may end up mattering just as much as figuring out why 2026 went sideways at the plate.
In Other News...
Twins Could Turn To A Former First-Round Pick Few Saw Coming
The Twins may be looking in an unexpected place for bullpen help, and it comes with a familiar name. Keoni Cavaco, their 2019 first-round draft pick, has moved from being a position player to pitching after spending two seasons in independent baseball, and the organization is now considering him as a possible relief option.
General manager Jeremy Zoll has already confirmed the clubs interest, while manager Derek Shelton has said he wants to feature as many former first-round picks as possible on the field. If Cavaco gets the call, his path would be one of the more unusual ones in recent Twins memory, taking him from High-A to independent ball and now to the edge of a major-league bullpen opportunity. [Read more 🡒]
Former Twins Arm Is Putting The Jeff Hoffman Trade Back In Focus
The Jeff Hoffman deal has already had one of those little side stories that can make a trade look a lot bigger in hindsight. John Klein, the right-hander the Twins sent to Toronto in the Aug. 3 swap, had just made his major league debut in Minnesota this season before becoming part of the package that brought Hoffman to the bullpen picture.
Kleins next step came quickly, with the Blue Jays recently calling him up for a doubleheader against the Orioles, a reminder that his path is still moving even as his minor league performance has been uneven. Toronto has him ranked as its No. 29 overall prospect, so his progress will keep drawing attention in a trade that Minnesota will be measured against for a while. [Read more 🡒]
Walker Jenkins Is Making The Twins Look Right For Calling Him Up
Walker Jenkins arrived in the majors with the kind of uneven first impression that can come with a late-season call-up, but the Twins have spent the past week seeing more and more of why they brought him up. After opening his MLB career with a low batting average, the young outfielder has started to settle in, going 11-for-25 with three home runs over his last six games and giving Minnesota a much clearer look at the kind of bat he can bring.
Even with the Twins out of playoff contention, Jenkins stretch at the plate has made the promotion look worthwhile in the larger sense. He still has rookie eligibility left for 2027, and his path to this point has already included multiple injuries, which makes every productive game feel a little more meaningful for a team trying to gauge what comes next. What Minnesota is watching now is whether this late-season burst is the start of a longer run toward becoming a regular outfield option. [Read more 🡒]