The Brewers did not sit out the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes nearly as quietly as some around baseball first believed.
After the Dodgers landed the Tigers ace in a blockbuster two days before Monday’s trade deadline, Milwaukee caught plenty of criticism for not doing enough to keep Skubal away from Los Angeles. But reporting from MLB.com’s Adam McCalvy paints a different picture: the Brewers put together a serious offer, one that may have been stronger than the package Detroit ultimately accepted from the Dodgers.
McCalvy reported Tuesday that Milwaukee’s opening proposal included three hitters, and at least two of them were Top 100 prospects. One of those names was shortstop Luis Peña, Milwaukee’s No. 2 prospect and No. 18 on MLB Pipeline’s Top 100.
The Brewers’ other position-player prospects in that top-100 range include Jesús Made, who is No. 1 overall and was off limits, Luis Lara at No. 64, Jett Williams at No. 76 and Josh Adamczewski at No.
- McCalvy wrote that the third hitter was believed to be either on a Top 100 list in one version or just outside it.
The exact full package remains a little murky, but the core of it appears clear enough: Peña was in, and one of Jett Williams or Josh Adamczewski likely was too, along with another highly regarded bat. That would have been a substantial return for Detroit, even before considering the Brewers could have added pitching.
Milwaukee was never going to move Logan Henderson, and that made sense after his strong 10-game start to his major league career. But the Brewers still had paths to top the Dodgers if they wanted to get aggressive. Brandon Sproat or Shane Drohan would have been the kind of controllable MLB arms that fit the Tigers’ ask, and either one paired with Peña and another near-Top-100 hitter would have given Detroit a serious decision.
A hypothetical Brewers package would have looked like this:
Brewers receive: LHP Tarik Skubal
Tigers receive: INF Luis Peña and LHP Shane Drohan OR RHP Brandon Sproat, and mystery hitting prospect
Peña would have been the centerpiece. He’s two years younger than Dodgers outfielder Zyhir Hope and ranked a bit higher, with Peña sitting at No. 18 and Hope at No. 25 on MLB Pipeline’s Top 100.
The 19-year-old has put together a .843 OPS across two minor-league levels this season, along with two home runs, 19 RBIs and 21 stolen bases. He’s a polished hitter with elite speed, though his defense still needs work if he’s going to stick at shortstop.
If not, second or third base may be his future. Detroit’s Kevin McGonigle being locked in as the shortstop of the future would have softened that concern.
Sproat, 25, was part of Milwaukee’s return in the offseason trade that sent Freddy Peralta to the Mets. He has made 25 big league appearances and owns a 5.18 ERA with 117 strikeouts in 116 1/3 innings.
The command has been the issue, with walks piling up, but the stuff is real: a four-pitch mix and a fastball that can get into the upper 90s. He’s also more than two years younger than River Ryan, who turns 28 on Aug. 17 and has not pitched in MLB since 2024.
Drohan would have given the Tigers a different look. The 27-year-old lefty made his MLB debut this season and has handled a mixed role between the bullpen and rotation.
He has posted a 3.48 ERA with 89 strikeouts and 24 walks in 88 innings. He’s a little older than Sproat, but he has already had more success at the big-league level.
Detroit ended up taking the Dodgers’ offer of Hope plus pitchers River Ryan and Brady Smith, and the Tigers were clearly looking for a controllable MLB pitcher in any Skubal deal. Whether Ryan truly fits that description is another question. Still, the Brewers’ pitch appears to have had real teeth, and if the talks had stretched closer to the deadline, Milwaukee might have had a shot to force the issue.
Instead, Skubal is headed to Los Angeles, where the Dodgers now have the back-to-back Cy Young winner as they chase a third straight World Series title.
In Other News...
Twins Turn To Kaelen Culpepper As Shortstop Pressure Builds
The Twins are getting a closer look at one of their most promising young infielders, as Kaelen Culpepper has earned a promotion to the big leagues after a strong run at Triple-A St. Paul. Drafted in the first round last year, Culpepper has shown the kind of power and speed that made him one of the organizations most intriguing prospects, and his rise comes at a time when Minnesota is trying to steady a position that has become increasingly important in the stretch run.
His arrival also gives the Twins a timely option as they head into a key series, where lineup construction and matchups can start to carry extra weight. For a club looking for help at shortstop, Culpeppers call-up adds both intrigue and urgency, and it will now be worth watching how quickly he gets pushed into the mix once the games start to matter even more. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Offensive Slump Is Forcing A Roster Move Fans Can Feel
The Twins entered the second half with the kind of lineup that looked built to keep the pressure on the rest of the American League, but the offense has gone quiet since the All-Star break. Even after the front office spent the trade deadline adding several pitchers, the biggest issue in Minnesota has been the one thing those moves could not solve: run production, with too many regulars underperforming at a time when the club needs steady bats.
That is why the conversation around the roster keeps turning to the farm system, where the next obvious offensive help appears to be waiting. With Byron Buxton still working back from injury and no clear return date in sight, the Twins are staring at a stretch where the easiest way to jolt the lineup may be to lean on young talent already knocking on the door and make a move fans can feel. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Made A Trade Choice Fans Will Debate Into October
The Twins spent their deadline capital on the mound, leaning into an obvious area of need by adding A.J. Minter, Dean Kremer and Jeff Hoffman. It was a clear message about where the front office believed the biggest problems sat, with bullpen depth and rotation help getting the nod over a lineup upgrade.
Jo Adell fit the kind of bat Minnesota could have used, especially with his track record against left-handed pitching, but the choice was made to pass and keep building around pitching. If the Twins reach October with the offense still searching for that extra punch in certain matchups, this will be the move fans keep revisiting, because the upside they sacrificed is the sort of thing that can linger long after the deadline dust settles. [Read more 🡒]