Twins First Base: A Closer Look
When you scan the Twins' depth chart for first base, a clear pattern emerges: none of the key players have been developed within the organization. This isn't a new approach for Minnesota. In recent years, they've leaned on free agents like Ty France, Carlos Santana, and Donovan Solano to fill the position.
This season, the Twins have brought in top free agents Josh Bell and Victor Caratini, along with waiver wire pickups Kody Clemens and Eric Wagaman. It seems the Twins view first base as a spot that can be filled with cost-effective external options, allowing them to focus their development efforts elsewhere.
While this strategy has its merits, it hasn't always yielded the desired results. Last year, despite having a Gold Glove winner for part of the season, the Twins ranked 22nd in fWAR at first base. So, how will this year's mix of players fare?
A Quick Overview
- Last Year's fWAR Ranking: 22nd out of 30
- This Year's fWAR Projection: 24th out of 30
The Positives
In a lineup filled with uncertainties, the Twins needed a reliable bat, and they found one in Josh Bell. With an impressive OPS in every season except the shortened 2020 campaign and a career 114 OPS+, Bell is a consistent offensive force. He's a switch-hitter known for quality at-bats and solid power, making him a great fit for first base.
However, Bell's defensive struggles suggest he might see more time at designated hitter. In 2025 with Washington, he started 98 games as a DH compared to 33 at first base. The Twins might follow a similar pattern, using Bell more at DH to enhance their defense.
This opens the door for Clemens, Caratini, and potentially Wagaman to share playing time. Each brings unique skills, though none are standout stars.
Clemens was initially considered for the starting role, with the Twins' GM expressing confidence in his potential. His power and speed make him an intriguing option, especially for a team that values those attributes. While the depth chart is fluid, expect a balanced distribution of starts among these players.
The Challenges
If only the Twins could combine Bell, Caratini, and Clemens into one player, they'd have the perfect first baseman. Instead, they must navigate each player's limitations.
- Bell: Best hitter but struggles defensively.
- Caratini: Solid for a catcher, but his offense is less impactful at first.
- Clemens: Offers speed and defense but has a career OPS+ of 81.
These limitations mean the Twins might only achieve competent offense and adequate defense at first base, similar to last year's performance with Ty France. If projections hold true, this won't be enough to improve their standing.
The lack of a promising first base prospect in the pipeline adds to the uncertainty. While there's talk of transitioning outfield prospect Hendry Mendez to first, this experiment is in its early stages. Currently, no top-tier prospects are primarily first basemen.
The Bottom Line
First base remains a challenging spot for the Twins, with no standout candidates emerging. Bell is more suited for DH, Caratini for catcher, and Clemens and Wagaman for bench roles. The team lacks a strong first baseman on the roster or in the minors, leaving the position as one of the most uncertain as the season approaches.