With the trade deadline closing in, Joe Ryan has become one of the most intriguing names on the Twins’ board.
That may sound strange at first, since most of the deadline buzz around Minnesota has centered on the lineup. But Ryan is different.
He’s not just another pitcher who might draw interest. He’s the club’s top arm, and that makes the decision around him much bigger than a typical deadline move.
The case for dealing him now is straightforward. Ryan is under team control beyond this season and is set to enter his contract year in 2027, which means any team that lands him before the deadline gets more than a short-term rental.
That extra season of control matters, especially for contenders looking for multiple postseason runs with a starter they can trust. And from Minnesota’s side, the timing is hard to ignore: if the Twins are going to move him, his value is as strong as it’s likely to get.
Even with a rough start on Monday that pushed his ERA up by more than a full run, Ryan’s season still looks excellent. Through 114 1/3 innings, he owns a 3.86 ERA and has struck out more than five batters for every walk he’s allowed.
His ERA+ sits at 126, and it was all the way up at 151 before that Monday outing. In other words, this is the kind of performance that gets attention from teams chasing October.
But the baseball argument is only part of the story.
The bigger question is whether Tom Pohlad would actually be willing to make that move. The Pohlad family has taken plenty of criticism over the years, and Tom Pohlad has said he wants to do things differently since becoming the club’s primary owner. Trading away one of the team’s biggest stars would not exactly be the kind of message many Twins fans are hoping to hear.
That matters because perception matters. The Twins have already dealt with historically low attendance numbers at Target Field during the 2026 season, and the roster absolutely plays a role in that.
Last month’s game against Shohei Ohtani and the Dodgers was a reminder of that reality. Target Field was packed when Ryan was on the mound, and while Ohtani and the Dodgers were obviously a huge draw, the point still stands: who’s on the field affects whether fans feel like showing up.
Ryan has become one of the Twins’ biggest stars, and moving him would carry consequences beyond the rotation.
There’s also the memory of last summer’s fire sale, which still sits fresh in Twins Territory. That deadline changed the direction of the franchise and left a sour feeling behind.
Another selloff, especially one that includes Ryan, would almost certainly hit the fan base hard again. Even if the long-term return eventually makes sense, asking people to buy in after another step backward would be a tough sell.
So the calculus is clear enough. From a pure baseball standpoint, trading Ryan makes sense because the return should be strongest now and the Twins may not see a better path to maximizing that value later.
But this isn’t just a spreadsheet decision. It comes with business fallout, fan reaction, and the risk of sending a very loud message about where the organization thinks it stands.
Trading Joe Ryan would do more than change the rotation. It would tell everyone what kind of direction this front office believes in.
In Other News...
Twins May Be Creating A Keaschall Problem They Cant Hide
Luke Keaschalls move from second base into the outfield has become one of the more interesting side projects on the Twins roster. Since June, Minnesota has tried him in right field and then in center during Byron Buxtons injury absence, and now that Buxton is back, Keaschall has settled again on the right side while the club keeps working to turn his athleticism into something usable in the grass.
The challenge is that the Twins are asking him to learn on the fly in a spot where mistakes are hard to hide. They have been shading him deeper in center to make the job easier as he develops, but that also changes the look of the defense and puts a spotlight on every read and route. Buxton can play shallower because of his elite range, and Keaschall is still trying to find the balance between protecting against balls over his head and being in position to attack the ones in front of him. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Could Lose Two Key Regulars If This Slide Gets Worse
A four-game skid has nudged the Twins farther from the American League Wild Card picture, and the timing matters with the Aug. 3 trade deadline closing in. Minnesota is sitting at 49-53, which is the kind of record that starts forcing difficult conversations about whether to push for a run or listen on established regulars while there is still value to be had.
Ryan Jeffers and Trevor Larnach are the names to watch if the slide continues. Jeffers is in the final year of his deal and has drawn attention from clubs looking for catching help, while Larnach remains under team control through 2027 and could become expendable if the Twins decide their outfield depth gives them room to deal from strength. [Read more 🡒]