The Twins spent the year talking about September as the destination. That was the standard set back in January, when Tom Pohlad laid out how the club would judge the season.
"Let's get halfway through the year, to the end of the year, and let's judge the success of this year on wins and losses and whether we're playing meaningful baseball in September."
That message never really changed. General manager Jeremy Zoll kept circling back to it, including in July when he said the goal had been "to play meaningful games in September."
Now September is over, and the question is unavoidable: did the Twins actually get there?
There was a stretch when it looked possible. After sweeping the Atlanta Braves from August 17-19, Minnesota’s playoff odds climbed to nearly 40%. The club was hanging around the American League Wild Card race, and the schedule still left room for a late push.
Then the bottom dropped out. The Twins lost seven of eight games near the end of August, and the whole picture shifted fast.
When September opened, FanGraphs had Minnesota at 9.8% to reach the postseason. That is not nothing.
But it is a long way from the kind of September the organization had been promising.
Minnesota entered the month five games under .500. It was not chasing a division title.
It was not safely parked in a Wild Card spot. It needed a real surge, and it needed help.
The next week made the climb even steeper. The Twins went 2-4, and their playoff odds fell to 3.1%.
At that point, the math started sounding a lot like the old line from Dumb and Dumber: "So you're saying there's a chance." Sure.
In the strictest sense. In any practical sense, the margin was disappearing quickly.
By September 15, the odds were down to 0.1%, and the team was officially eliminated on September 20.
So were those meaningful games? That depends on what the phrase is supposed to mean.
Every September game carries some weight. Players are fighting for jobs.
Prospects are trying to show they belong. Veterans are trying to help shape what comes next.
Front offices are collecting information they can use down the road. None of that is meaningless.
But that is also not quite the same thing Pohlad and Zoll were describing. The original promise was framed around wins and losses.
It was about a team that would still be in the hunt in September, not one clinging to a sliver of mathematical life. The Twins did not spend most of the month in a real race.
They spent it trying to stay barely attached to one.
There is a difference between being alive on paper and controlling your own fate. The Twins were never in that second category once September arrived. Their path was narrow because they had already put themselves in a hole, and the American League’s openness only kept the door cracked a little longer.
The late-August Braves series briefly made the dream look real. The losses that followed erased that feeling almost immediately.
By the middle of the month, the question was no longer whether Minnesota could make a run. It was how long the math would keep the season alive.
That said, the last games of the year still matter for the next one. September is now about sorting through the roster and figuring out who belongs in the Twins’ future.
Luke Keaschall, Connor Preilipp, Emmanuel Rodriguez, Walker Jenkins, Brooks Lee and other younger players are getting a chance to show what they can do. Pitchers are trying to win roles in the rotation or bullpen. Veterans are making cases for 2027.
That work matters, especially with a major offseason ahead. The organization has already moved on from the previous baseball operations setup, and Zoll now has the task of building the next version of the club. September is part of that process, even if it is not the same version of meaningful baseball the Twins described back in January.
If the definition is games that affect individual jobs and future plans, then yes, these games count. If the definition is a real September race with a postseason berth on the line, then Minnesota last had that in late August.
The Twins began the month five games under .500 with a 9.8% playoff chance. Two weeks later, that number was down to 0.1%.
They were eliminated on September 20. They had a chance, but it was a tiny one.
Pohlad tied the season’s success to wins and losses. Zoll kept talking about meaningful games in September.
The Twins reached September, but not in the way they had spent months describing. Now they have an offseason to make sure this same conversation does not come back in 2027.
Because "we technically had a chance" was never the bar they set for themselves.
In Other News...
Twins Enter A Crucial Offseason With One Roster Weakness Looming
The Twins are heading into the offseason with more questions than answers after finishing 2026 below .500, and the front office has a pretty clear starting point for its winter work. The bullpen stands out as the biggest issue, especially with several key left-handed relief options set to hit free agency, leaving a hole that could affect the shape of the entire relief corps if it is not addressed quickly.
Catcher and first base also need attention, even if those spots are further down the priority list. Free-agent help looks limited, which means Minnesota may need to get creative through trades or complementary signings as it tries to rebuild a roster that has too many obvious gaps and not enough easy fixes. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Front Office Reset Just Took Another Significant Turn
The Twins front office makeover picked up another notch this week with the mutual parting of ways with assistant general manager Daniel Adler. Adler had been in the organization since 2017, when he was hired by former president of baseball operations Derek Falvey, and his exit comes as the club continues to reshape its leadership structure under general manager Jeremy Zoll.
Zoll is now expected to keep building out the department with new hires after a string of departures has changed the look of the operation. With Falvey already gone earlier this year and another longtime voice now out of the picture, the Twins are steadily moving into a new era in the front office. [Read more 🡒]
Twins Suddenly Have A Closing Debate They Cant Ignore
The Twins bullpen has been one of the seasons most revealing storylines, and not for the kind of stability clubs usually want at the back end of games. Minnesota set an American League record by turning to 15 different pitchers for saves, a sign of just how often the ninth inning has shifted from one arm to another. Jeff Hoffman became the latest name in that mix, but the larger picture is still centered on how the team has tried to piece together a reliable finish.
Yoendrys Gmez has been the most productive option overall, leading the club with 21 saves, though his season has been uneven enough to keep the debate alive. After a dominant stretch earlier in the year, he struggled in September, which is why the Twins are still weighing what the late-inning hierarchy should look like moving forward. Hoffmans emergence only adds another layer to a bullpen that has spent much of the season searching for a clear answer. [Read more 🡒]