Byron Buxton Just Reignited A Twins Debate They Can't Ignore

Despite a history of injuries, Byron Buxton's recent awards underline his invaluable contributions as an outfielder for the Twins, challenging the notion of confining him to a designated hitter role.

Byron Buxton’s latest hardware makes the Twins’ choice pretty clear: keep him in center field.

The Minnesota Twins recently announced the recipients of the 2026 Diamond Awards, which are voted on each year by the Twin Cities Chapter of the Baseball Writers’ Association of America and the Minnesota Twins Community Fund Board of Directors. Buxton came away with two of them, including the Jim Kaat Award for Twins Defensive Player of the Year. He also took home the Bob Allison Award, which is “given to the Twins player who exemplifies determination, hustle, tenacity, competitive spirit and leadership both on and off the field.”

That recognition arrived even though Buxton was a non-factor in the second half of the season. A hip issue limited him to three IL stints and eventually led to surgery, though he should be ready for Opening Day.

And that matters, because it undercuts the idea that Buxton should simply be parked at designated hitter full time from here on out. Yes, the injury history is real. But so is the fact that he remains one of the Twins’ best defensive players.

Buxton, 32, is still elite in center more than a decade into his MLB career. This year, he posted +2 Defensive Runs Saved and +3 Outs Above Average across 597 2/3 innings in center field.

Minnesota also has a crowded outfield picture to sort through next season, with Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez and Luke Keaschall all needing regular at-bats if everyone is healthy at the same time. Buxton is the oldest of that group, and the easy answer might be to shift him to DH full time. But the Twins have already seen that route doesn’t solve everything.

In 2023, Minnesota made Buxton a full-time DH, and it didn’t go smoothly. He still had trouble staying on the field, appearing in just 85 games, and his offense lagged too, as he hit .207/.294/.438 with a 96 wRC+.

The Twins could still use Buxton at DH here and there in 2027, just as they did this past season. But if the question is whether he belongs in the outfield regularly, the answer is yes. The risk may rise the more he plays there, but Buxton has already shown he’s injury-prone either way, and his defensive value is too strong to leave on the table.

In Other News...

Twins Ownership Uncertainty Just Got More Frustrating For Minnesota Fans

The chatter around the Twins ownership has only added to an already restless stretch for a fan base that has watched the club navigate payroll cuts, a roster fire sale and a series of organizational changes. The Pohlad family previously explored selling the team, then opted to keep control and bring in minority investors, leaving plenty of uncertainty about where things go next and who, exactly, will be steering the franchise in the years ahead.

Recent reports tied the Twins to a possible sale involving a limited partner in the organization, but the story was quickly met with pushback from multiple sources. The latest denials have made the situation more confusing than clarifying, which is the last thing Minnesota supporters needed after months of frustration over how the club has been run. [Read more 🡒]

Twins May Have Already Found Their 2027 Rotation Cornerstone

Taj Bradley gave the Twins exactly the kind of season teams dream about when they go looking for a long-term arm. After arriving in Minnesota, he settled in as a frontline presence in 2026, handling a heavy workload and giving the club both durability and swing-and-miss stuff while earning Pitcher of the Year recognition. For a rotation that has spent too much time searching for stability, Bradley suddenly looks like the sort of pitcher around whom a plan can be built.

Minnesota has plenty to sort out this winter, from catching help to bullpen depth, but Bradleys emergence changes the conversation at the top of the staff. The Twins are already weighing the idea of locking in more certainty beyond the seasons they control, and the bigger question may be how aggressively they try to turn one breakout into a true rotation anchor while the rest of the pitching infrastructure catches up. [Read more 🡒]

Twins Prospect Eduardo Tait Has One Tool Keeping His Future Alive

Eduardo Taits first full season in the Twins system gave Cedar Rapids plenty to watch, even if the overall line was uneven. The catcher arrived in a 2025 trade and showed why Minnesota targeted him in the first place by driving the ball enough to leave the yard 22 times, a reminder that his bat still carries real impact potential.

The rest of the profile was tougher to sort through, though, with the offense backing up around that power and the defensive questions behind the plate still hanging over his development. For a player whose future value depends on proving he can handle both sides of the catcher position, 2027 now looms as a pivotal year for Tait to show the Twins he is more than just raw pop. [Read more 🡒]