Michigan’s escape against Western Michigan is officially in the books, and the fallout is not changing the outcome.
The FBS Oversight Committee weighed in on Wednesday after the MAC pushed to have the result overturned and asked both the committee and the College Football Playoff Committee to recognize the Broncos as the winner. The answer was no. Michigan’s 13-12 victory stands, and the Wolverines remain 2-0.
The committee said it could not overturn a final ruling on the field. It also acknowledged that the replay process was not handled properly on the game’s second-to-last play, and that if the protocol had been followed, the result would have been different.
"The committee confirmed that it does not have the authority to overturn the contest. The playing rules governing the result of a contest are clear. Once the referee declares a contest to be final, no appeal of the outcome is permitted, according to Rules 1-1-3-b and 5-2-9 of the NCAA football rules:
"The committee consulted with national officiating leadership regarding the instant replay protocols. Based on that information, the committee agreed that the instant replay protocols were not followed in the contest’s second-to-last play. Had the protocols been followed, the outcome of the game would have been different...."
That ruling closes the door on the wild Week 1 ending, even if the debate around it won’t disappear anytime soon. Michigan looked outplayed for much of that game and seemed to have one foot pointed toward Oklahoma, but Western Michigan still had the chance to let Bryce Underwood launch a Hail Mary. That kind of play works only so often, and this time it did.
The bigger question now is what all of this means for Michigan’s playoff path. The source of the controversy may be a 13-12 escape, but the argument that the Wolverines would be kept out of the College Football Playoff because of it doesn’t hold up if they finish strong. If Michigan goes 10-2 or better, the belief here is they are getting in.
There’s still plenty of work ahead. Michigan already got one of its toughest tests out of the way with a 17-10 win over Oklahoma, and the road gets much tougher from here with Iowa, Penn State, Indiana, Oregon, and Ohio State still on the schedule.
But the brand is real, and so is the pull. Michigan is two years removed from winning the national title, and a 10-2 Wolverines team would command attention.
Rival fans can hang an asterisk on the Western Michigan result if they want. The record says Michigan won, and the playoff picture is not going to ignore that if the Wolverines keep stacking wins.
In Other News...
Former Gophers Are Already Making Minnesotas Transfer Losses Look Different
After a busy 2024 offseason that sent 20 players out of the Gopher football program, the immediate question was how much those departures would actually sting once the new season arrived. The early answer is not as simple as a blanket loss, because the ex-Gophers have scattered into very different situations, from clear-cut starters to players still fighting for snaps, and that makes Minnesotas transfer picture look a lot more complicated than a simple count of exits.
Some of those former Gophers are already showing up in meaningful roles at their new schools, while others are active but not yet starting, or still working their way onto the field at all. A few have not even surfaced on rosters in a way that suggests an immediate impact, which is why the value of the departures cannot be judged all at once. For Minnesota, the real story is not just who left, but how quickly those players are either validating the change or fading into the background. [Read more 🡒]
Gophers Suddenly Have A Bigger Problem Than One Bad Loss
P.J. Fleck did not spend much time sugarcoating Minnesotas 38-13 loss to Mississippi State, and for good reason. The Gophers were flagged too often, missed too many tackles and never found enough rhythm on offense, even as Fleck said he liked the game plan overall. The bigger concern may be that the problems were spread across the operation, from the offensive line to the defensive line rotations, leaving Minnesota with a lot more to clean up than just one ugly result.
Anthony Smith is part of that broader conversation, too, after moving around positionally and still making only a limited statistical impact through two games. Flecks comments suggested the staff is still searching for the right combinations and the right answers, which is not what any team wants to be doing in early September. The loss itself stung, but the unfinished business around personnel and execution may be the more telling issue for a Gophers team trying to steady itself quickly. [Read more 🡒]
Minnesota Just Reached A Crucial Moment In The Malik Olajuwon Race
Minnesota has already added one piece to its 2027 class with Isaiah Santos' verbal commitment, and the Gophers are still pressing for more perimeter help as they chase four-star shooting guard Malik Olajuwon out of Texas. Olajuwon turned heads over the summer, climbing in the recruiting rankings and picking up MVP honors at a tournament, the kind of run that tends to sharpen interest from high-major programs looking for scoring and shot-making on the wing.
Now comes the part that matters for Minnesota. Olajuwon is set to transfer to IMG Academy for his senior year, and he has adjusted his official visit schedule, a sign that the recruitment is moving into a more serious phase. For a Gophers staff trying to build momentum in the class, the timing is important, and the next move in this one could tell a lot about where Minnesota really stands. [Read more 🡒]