P.J. Fleck keeps preaching complementary football, but Minnesota’s offense is making that message harder to sell by the week.
The defense did enough Saturday at No. 4 Indiana.
The Gophers held a talented Hoosiers offense to one touchdown and won the turnover battle. Special teams also delivered, with another blocked kick and another strong outing from Luke Drzewiecki.
In those two phases, Minnesota gave itself a real chance.
The offense didn’t come close to matching it.
That has become the story, not just of one afternoon, but of the last three games. Minnesota has scored only one touchdown in each of those contests, and the lone touchdown at Indiana came after a trick play set up by a shanked punt that handed the Gophers excellent field position.
This is no longer a small sample issue. It is a pattern.
The problems run through the entire operation. Fleck’s conservative approach, Greg Harbaugh Jr.’s play-calling, the quarterback’s misses and mistakes, the offensive line’s struggles in the run game and the wide receivers’ inability to help out - all of it is dragging the unit down.
A lot of the attention naturally lands on Lindsey, who has not come close to the preseason NFL Draft buzz surrounding him. He is currently 11th in the Big Ten in yards per game, 16th in efficiency, 10th in touchdowns, 10th in completion percentage and tied for the third most interceptions.
The numbers tell part of the story, but not all of it. More troubling is that his play has not lifted the offense at any point.
The “good defense” defense for Minnesota is getting harder to lean on, too. Nebraska’s Anthony Colandrea threw for 264 yards against this Indiana defense.
Northwestern’s Aiden Chiles went 22/29 for 293 yards and two touchdowns. Washington’s backup quarterback came off the bench to throw for 251 yards and three touchdowns against Iowa.
Even Iowa’s Hank Brown, against Michigan, threw for 227 yards and two touchdowns.
Yes, the Gophers have faced quality defenses. But at some point, the staff has to trust Lindsey to make throws, and Lindsey has to make them. That hasn’t happened often enough.
There’s no denying Lindsey has talent, and there’s no reason to think he should be benched. But he is not playing nearly as well as expected, and the offense seems to be getting less comfortable as the season goes on. That raises questions about his development, but it also raises bigger ones about the scheme and the answers the staff is finding when defenses take things away.
That’s where the frustration really sits. Lindsey has not been good enough, but the responsibility for this offense eventually moves upward.
Harbaugh is now in his fourth season as offensive coordinator, and “mixed” might be the kindest way to describe the results. Even that feels generous.
His best offense came in 2024, when Minnesota had Max Brosmer at quarterback, a healthy Darius Taylor, Daniel Jackson at wide receiver and a second-round NFL Draft pick at left tackle. Even then, the Gophers finished 80th nationally in scoring offense, 107th in total offense, 109th in rushing and 76th in passing.
That was the peak. Most of Harbaugh’s offenses have lived in the bottom third of the FBS, just as Blake noted in the preseason.
Through eight games, Minnesota ranks 130th in total offense and 89th in scoring among 138 teams. That scoring number is propped up by 59 points against Eastern Illinois and 41 against Akron.
Against the six Power 4 opponents, the Gophers have topped 20 points only twice. In four of those six games, they have scored one touchdown or fewer.
The numbers are ugly, but the way Minnesota gets there is almost as maddening. Harbaugh and the staff had all week to build a plan for Indiana, script the opening series and adjust from there. The opening script produced nothing.
The idea was clear enough: get the ball out fast, attack the edges and use Taylor in space. Indiana shut that down right away, and Minnesota kept trying it anyway.
Lindsey opened 9-for-11, which looks good on paper until you see that six of those completions went for one yard or less and four went backward. By the time the Gophers had that 9-for-11 start, they had gained just seven passing yards.
The plan wasn’t working, and it wasn’t adjusted until the third quarter.
That same issue showed up against Iowa. Minnesota started with the ball at the Iowa 13 after a blocked punt and came away with zero yards before settling for a field goal.
At this point, the blame has spread far beyond one player. If the talent isn’t enough, that lands on the offensive coordinator.
If the game plan isn’t enough, that lands on the offensive coordinator. If the adjustments aren’t enough, that lands on the offensive coordinator.
If the scoring keeps lagging, that lands on the offensive coordinator.
Fleck keeps talking about consistency and complementary football. Right now, Minnesota is getting neither.
The defense and special teams are carrying more than their share, and the offense keeps falling behind. Over the last four seasons, the only thing consistently true about the Gopher offense is that it has consistently lagged.
What happens over the final four games of the regular season will matter, but there isn’t much here to suggest a turnaround is coming. I’m not sure what it would take to see Harbaugh back for a fifth season, but there’s been little evidence of change or improvement on the horizon.
In Other News...
Gophers Opened With A Rout Despite One Early Concern
Minnesotas season opener looked every bit like the kind of clean start a coach wants on the scoreboard, with the Gophers rolling past North Dakota 85-50 behind a balanced offensive effort. Bobby Durkin set the tone with 16 points and four 3-pointers, while Jaylen Crocker-Johnson, Isaac Asuma and Malick Kordel all joined him in double figures, giving the Gophers plenty of early signs that the scoring load can be spread around.
Still, the opener came with an undercurrent worth watching. Minnesota took the floor without three players, and the reasons behind those absences leave a few roster questions hanging as the season gets underway. The win was convincing enough to quiet any immediate concerns on the court, but the availability picture is something the Gophers will have to sort through quickly if they want this kind of depth to hold up. [Read more 🡒]
Gophers Open Medveds Second Season With An Encouraging Early Sign
The first night of Niko Medveds second season on the Minnesota bench brought the kind of start coaches love to see: a lopsided 85-50 win over North Dakota that looked comfortable from the opening stretch. The Gophers shot well, controlled the game on both ends and put together a balanced effort with five players finishing in double figures, a sign that the offense had more than one reliable source right away.
Bobby Durkin paced Minnesota with 16 points, but the bigger takeaway was how many pieces fit together in the opener. For a program trying to build momentum under Medved, a 38-point margin is more than just a clean result against a nonconference opponent, it is the kind of early evidence that the rosters depth and structure may be ahead of schedule. [Read more 🡒]
Gophers Opened The Season Looking Better Than Anyone Expected
Minnesotas season opener offered an early glimpse of a team that looked sharper and more connected than expected, rolling past North Dakota 85-50 behind a balanced effort and a defense that set the tone from the start. Bobby Durkin provided the biggest scoring punch, giving the Gophers a reliable perimeter threat while the rest of the group helped turn the night into a comfortable first step.
The more encouraging part for Minnesota may have been how little room it gave North Dakota to breathe. The Gophers were disruptive on that end all night, forcing tough looks and keeping the visitors out of rhythm from deep, the kind of defensive start that can travel once the schedule gets tougher. If this opener is any indication, Minnesota may have more early-season substance than the outside expectations suggested. [Read more 🡒]