The Milwaukee Bucks face a tricky Herro decision as they sort through a new era without Giannis Antetokounmpo. Tyler Herro came over from the Miami Heat in the blockbuster trade, and with one year left on his deal, he instantly becomes one of the biggest questions on the roster.
Herro brings obvious value. He’s a former All-Star, he can score 20-plus points a night, hit threes and create his own shot. For a Bucks team trying to piece together what comes next, that kind of offense is hard to ignore.
The debate now is whether Milwaukee should lock him in before the season or wait and see how things unfold.
One On SI take points to Herro’s numbers and his standing on the roster right now. He put up 20.5 points per game on 48% field-goal shooting last season, and the view is that “Tyler Herro is the closest thing the Bucks have to a franchise star at the moment.”
That same argument also acknowledges the size of the challenge in front of him. Milwaukee is trying to replace the production and presence that came with Antetokounmpo, and it won’t be simple in a reshaped Eastern Conference. Still, the logic is that Herro should be able to earn a long-term deal if he matches what he’s done in his Miami Heat days.
Another view says Milwaukee should keep Herro, but only on a shorter timeline. He’s 26, he’s already been an All-Star, and as a Wisconsin native he could help put more fans in Fiserv Forum.
At the same time, that same viewpoint sees Ryan Rollins and Brayden Burries as the backcourt the Bucks should be building toward, which makes Herro something of a roadblock if the team gets too committed. The reasoning is simple: Milwaukee may not want to watch a talented player hit free agency and walk away for nothing, especially if Herro is genuinely excited about being there.
If no trade comes together by February, a short extension could make sense without handing him a deal that clogs the path for Rollins and Burries.
A third perspective is more cautious about the price tag. Herro can score, but he remains hard to pin down when it comes to what he’s worth. His defensive issues and availability concerns are still part of the equation, which means he can’t consume too much salary space without limiting the rest of the roster.
That line of thinking also suggests Milwaukee should quietly shop him if the right offer appears, with Detroit floated as a possible fit because a team like that could use his scoring behind a star. If nothing materializes by February, then a shorter agreement could work, maybe a one-year deal with a player option, around the $30 million per year range and close to his previous contract. The note from Miami was that Herro wasn’t comfortable with that structure there, but the feeling is that might be different now.
In Other News...
Jaime Jaquez Jr. Faces A Bucks Test That Could Change Everything
Taylor Jenkins has made it clear that Jaime Jaquez Jr.s next step is not just about scoring or settling into a larger role, but about becoming a more dependable defender. For a player expected to start regularly, that matters in a hurry, especially with the Bucks looking for signs that he can handle tougher matchups without sacrificing the steady, versatile game that has made him so intriguing.
Jaquez does have the physical tools to answer the challenge, even if his past stretches on that end have left some questions behind. What happens this season could carry real weight beyond the nightly rotation, too, since his defensive progress may shape how Milwaukee views his upcoming contract extension negotiations. [Read more 🡒]
Bucks Fans Are Already Watching One Early Taylor Jenkins Decision
The Bucks are in the middle of a preseason stretch that feels more about sorting than scoring, with Taylor Jenkins using these games to size up a roster that is no longer being viewed strictly through the Giannis Antetokounmpo lens. For Milwaukee, the bigger picture is development and direction, and that has meant giving veterans extended looks even as the team tries to learn which younger pieces might matter most in the next chapter.
So far, the early read has already given fans something to monitor: how Jenkins balances experience against upside when the results are secondary to evaluation. Nate Ament, Brayden Burries, Ousmane Dieng and Kasparas Jakucionis all fit into that promising young group, but some are dealing with limited minutes or are sidelined altogether, which leaves the rotation picture unsettled and makes every preseason decision feel a little more revealing than usual. [Read more 🡒]
Spoelstra Knows The Heats Biggest Giannis Challenge Wont Be Talent
Erik Spoelstra is already thinking beyond the usual Xs and Os when it comes to Giannis Antetokounmpo, and for good reason. The Heat coach said in a SiriusXM NBA Radio interview that he plans to take his time building a relationship with the Bucks superstar, a process he contrasted with the close bond he already has with Bam Adebayo.
For Milwaukee, the takeaway is less about talent and more about the human side of a potential heavyweight matchup. Spoelstras comments suggest he understands exactly how much respect Giannis commands, but also how much patience it will take to develop the kind of trust that can shape the way Miami approaches him moving forward. [Read more 🡒]