Tyler Herro Is Creating A Bucks Problem They Can't Ignore

As the Bucks eagerly await Tyler Herro's transformation into a star player, his inconsistent performances and looming free agency raise questions about his future role and value in Milwaukee.

The Bucks went into this season hoping Tyler Herro would look like a different player in Milwaukee. Instead, he’s looked a lot like the version they already knew.

That’s the frustrating part for a team that expected a bigger leap from one of the key pieces in the Giannis Antetokounmpo trade return. Herro was supposed to grow into a star with the Bucks, and Milwaukee has treated him like one. But the production hasn’t matched the opportunity, and the gap between role and results is getting harder to ignore.

His latest game summed it up pretty well. Herro managed just 5 points against the Hawks, his worst outing of the season.

But the issue goes beyond one bad night. The scoring dip has been there all year, and it hasn’t shown much sign of changing.

Herro is averaging 20.3 points per game this season, which is solid but not exactly a breakout. It’s also below his career-best mark of 23.9 points per game from two seasons ago, when he earned his lone All-Star nod. Milwaukee was clearly hoping for that level or better once he got more runway in its system.

So far, that bigger role hasn’t produced a true star turn. Herro has only topped 30 points once this season, and even that came in a loss to the Bulls, a team with some of the worst perimeter defense in the league. That’s not the kind of game that changes the conversation.

The strange part is that Herro hasn’t really transformed at all. Other Heat players who landed in Milwaukee have found ways to expand their games, but Herro still looks like the same scorer.

He’s still taking about half his shots from beyond the arc and hitting them at a respectable clip. The problem is what’s happening inside the arc, where his 2-point efficiency has slipped and dragged down the rest of his scoring.

He’s putting up 45% shooting from the field and 38% from three, numbers that are useful but not enough to move the needle for a contender. Even with the Bucks giving him the kind of green light most players dream about, he hasn’t shown the kind of growth that would make him look like a true difference-maker.

That matters because Milwaukee may have had a bigger plan in mind. If the idea was to boost Herro’s value, the season hasn’t helped much.

The contract situation only adds another layer. Herro is making $33 million this season, and his deal expires next summer.

That leaves him in a tricky spot. He hasn’t built much momentum toward a bigger payday, and his profile - a non-superstar undersized shooting guard - is exactly the kind of archetype the league is starting to devalue.

That also makes him a complicated trade piece. He’s expensive, he needs the ball, and he’s not the sort of expiring contract that automatically draws a line of suitors. At the same time, the Bucks can’t count on a long list of teams eager to pay him next summer either.

For now, Milwaukee is still waiting for the next step that was supposed to come with this season.

In Other News...

Bucks Ugly Start Puts One Risky Star Scenario In Focus

Milwaukees miserable start has only intensified the sense that the Bucks are searching for a way back into the conversation, and the absence of a clear star anchor has made every roster question feel bigger. With the team sitting at 1-12, the usual patience that comes with a long season is already giving way to speculation about bold fixes, especially if a high-profile name somehow becomes available.

One scenario that has begun to surface is a pursuit of Zion Williamson if the New Orleans Pelicans ever decide to move him, though the path would not be simple. His trade value is complicated by injury concerns, and Milwaukees lack of a draft pick next offseason could make any deal even harder to navigate, particularly with New Orleans holding swap rights to that selection. [Read more 🡒]

Bucks Just Had Another Collapse Fans Are Tired Of

The Bucks had this one under control early, then watched it slip away in a way that has become far too familiar. Milwaukee built a 22-point lead in the second quarter against Atlanta, only to lose 113-106 after the offense stalled, the ball started flying around carelessly and the Hawks turned the game into a track meet.

Milwaukee shot just 25% in that second quarter and committed 18 turnovers, a stretch that let Atlanta rip off a 37-16 advantage and flip the night completely. Tyler Herro and Jalen Jaquez were quiet, while role players like Kasparas Jakuionis and Gary Trent Jr. did their part, but the Bucks still could not close the door when it mattered most, leaving fans with another collapse to stew over. [Read more 🡒]

Bucks Face A New Hawks Backcourt Problem Tonight

Atlanta comes in short-handed for its matchup with Milwaukee, with several rotation pieces unavailable because of injuries. Kingston Flemings is out with a lumbar strain, and the Hawks are also missing Keshon Gilbert, Mouhamed Gueye, Asa Newell, and Henri Veesaar, which leaves the backcourt and frontcourt thinner than usual heading into the night.

For the Bucks, the main wrinkle is how the Hawks reshape their guard rotation without those bodies. CJ McCollum is expected to take on a larger role in the backcourt, and Milwaukee will have to account for that adjustment while dealing with its own absence of Ousmane Dieng. Beyond that, the injury report is relatively clean for the Bucks, which should at least give them a more stable setup as they try to handle a shorthanded opponent. [Read more 🡒]