The Brewers did not exactly sit on their hands in the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes. And if the reporting that surfaced after the deadline is any indication, Milwaukee had a much stronger hand on the table than plenty of people realized.
Two days before Monday’s trade deadline, Los Angeles and Detroit finalized the blockbuster that sent Skubal to the Dodgers, a move that set off a wave of frustration across baseball. With a system as deep as Milwaukee’s, the Brewers caught heat for not doing more to stop a contender like Los Angeles from landing the back-to-back Cy Young winner. But according to MLB.com’s Adam McCalvy, Milwaukee did make a serious push.
McCalvy reported Tuesday that the Brewers’ initial offer to the Tigers included three hitters, and at least two of them ranked among MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 prospects. One of those names was Luis Peña, Milwaukee’s No. 2 prospect and the No. 18 prospect in baseball. The other Brewers position players in MLB Pipeline’s Top 100 are Jesús Made, Luis Lara, Jett Williams and Josh Adamczewski, though McCalvy noted that different sources believed the third hitter was either on one version of a Top 100 list as well, or just outside it.
The exact full package remains a little murky, but the shape of it is clear enough: Peña was in it, and one of Williams or Adamczewski may have been too, along with another well-regarded hitter. That’s a meaningful return on paper, enough to make Detroit think hard about its options.
Instead, the Tigers took the Dodgers’ offer of outfielder Zyhir Hope and pitchers River Ryan and Brady Smith. Detroit was said to be looking for a controllable MLB pitcher in any Skubal deal, and that likely drove the decision. Whether Ryan truly fit that description is up for debate, especially when Milwaukee had arms that might have checked that box more cleanly.
Logan Henderson was never going to be part of the conversation, and that makes sense given how well he’s started his major league career, going 10 games deep to open his big-league run. But the Brewers still had other ways to elevate their proposal. Brandon Sproat or Shane Drohan, both highly regarded rookie starting pitchers, could have been the kind of pitching piece that tipped the scales.
A Brewers package built around Peña, one of those arms, and another top-end bat would have looked like this:
Brewers receive: LHP Tarik Skubal
Tigers receive: INF Luis Peña and LHP Shane Drohan OR RHP Brandon Sproat, and mystery hitting prospect
Peña would have been the centerpiece. He’s two years younger than Hope and sits a bit higher on the prospect list, with Peña at No. 18 and Hope at No.
- The 19-year-old has put up a .843 OPS across two minor-league levels this season, along with two homers, 19 RBIs and 21 stolen bases.
He’s got real offensive juice and elite speed, though the glove still needs work if he’s going to stick at shortstop. Second or third base may be his eventual home, and Detroit’s situation there would have made that a workable fit anyway, with Kevin McGonigle locked in as the shortstop of the future.
Sproat would have brought a different kind of value. The 25-year-old was one of the key pieces Milwaukee got back in the offseason trade that sent Freddy Peralta to the Mets.
He has made 25 career MLB appearances and owns a 5.18 ERA with 117 strikeouts in 116 1/3 innings. The results at the top level haven’t come easily, mostly because of command issues and the walks that have followed, but the raw stuff is real.
He works with a quality four-pitch mix and can run his fastball into the upper-90s. He’s also more than two years younger than Ryan, who turns 28 on Aug. 17 and hasn’t pitched in MLB since 2024.
Drohan would have given the Tigers another option. A few months younger than Ryan, the 27-year-old left-hander made his MLB debut this season and has looked solid in a split role, moving between the bullpen and the rotation.
He has a 3.48 ERA with 89 strikeouts and 24 walks in 88 innings. He’s older than Sproat, but he’s already had more success in the majors.
That kind of package would have given Detroit an MLB-ready pitcher with six years of control, one of the best infield prospects in the game, and possibly another valuable piece on top. The Tigers may be satisfied with the Dodgers’ return, but there’s a real question whether they moved too early, making a deal with more than 36 hours still left before the deadline and leaving room for a stronger offer to emerge.
What the reporting shows, though, is that Milwaukee was in the fight. The Brewers made a legitimate bid for Skubal, and with a little more time on the clock, they might have had enough to land him. Instead, the Dodgers get the ace, and the rest of baseball gets to watch the star-studded machine chase a third straight World Series title.
In Other News...
Tyler Herro Is Already Challenging Doubts Around This Bucks Team
Tyler Herros comments at a recent basketball camp added another layer to the early buzz around the Bucks, a team that has spent the summer trying to reshape its identity after trading away its superstar and turning the sideline over to new coach Taylor Jenkins. Milwaukee is leaning into a roster built differently now, one that mixes young pieces like Herro, Myles Turner and Ryan Rollins with the expectation that the group can still stay in the playoff hunt.
There is plenty of skepticism outside the building about whether that formula can work right away, and Herro made clear he understands why. Even so, his confidence points to the kind of internal belief the Bucks will need as they try to prove the change in direction is more than just a reset. The questions around this team are obvious, but so is the opportunity if the new mix clicks sooner than expected. [Read more 🡒]
Bucks Roster Reset Is Suddenly Bigger Than Fans Expected
The Bucks offseason reset has been deeper than a routine shuffle, with Milwaukee shedding several familiar pieces after a disappointing season. Giannis Antetokounmpo and Bobby Portis are now headed to Miami, Taurean Prince and Gary Harris have moved on to Detroit, and Andre Jackson Jr. has signed with Toronto, leaving the roster looking much less settled than it did a few months ago.
It has not been just the headline departures, either. Several other Bucks have signed overseas or are still unsigned while they weigh their next steps, which has only added to the sense that this summer has been a broader purge than expected. For a team trying to rebound quickly, the challenge now is not only replacing production, but re-establishing an identity after so much turnover. [Read more 🡒]
Nuggets Camp Battle Could Start With One Overlooked Roster Question
The early churn around the NBAs two-way market is starting to matter, even before the regular roster picture settles. Teams can carry three extra players on those contracts alongside the standard 15-man group, and those spots have become a useful way to stash developmental talent, split time with the G League and keep young players close without fully committing a roster place.
For a Bucks team watching the leagues depth chart take shape, the intrigue is in how many openings still remain and how quickly they get claimed. Fourteen NBA teams already have at least one two-way slot open, while a handful of other spots are believed to be headed toward named players but are not finalized yet, and several unsigned second-round picks loom as natural candidates. It leaves a lot of the market unresolved, which is exactly why this part of camp can swing from background noise to a meaningful roster decision in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]