William Contreras has become one of the offseason’s most talked-about catchers, but the noise around him doesn’t mean the Milwaukee Brewers should rush to move him.
The buzz exists for a reason. Contreras has only one more season of team control, and The Athletic’s Ken Rosenthal reported that he is among the catchers drawing trade interest. Rosenthal wrote, “The trade market further complicated the equation for [Ryan Jeffers],” and added, “The Athletics’ Shea Langeliers, Colorado Rockies’ Hunter Goodman, and Milwaukee Brewers’ William Contreras are among the catchers drawing trade interest, and the San Diego Padres could move Felix Fermin or Luis Campusano.”
That kind of market chatter makes sense when the free-agent pool behind the plate is thin. Ryan Jeffers would have been a possible option, but he accepted the qualifying offer from the Minnesota Twins. Other names available in free agency include Carson Kelly, Tyler Stephenson, Kyle Higashioka, Gary Sanchez, James McCann and Jake Rogers.
Still, the Brewers’ best move is to hold on to Contreras. He showed exactly why during Milwaukee’s run to the World Series, and his playoff production was impossible to ignore.
In 13 games, Contreras hit .373/.448/.588 with a 1.037 OPS, three home runs, nine RBIs, one stolen base, two doubles and seven runs scored. He also delivered behind the plate, throwing out six base runners trying to steal.
If Milwaukee were to trade him, the organization would likely turn to Bo Naylor and No. 11 prospect Jeferson Quero in the majors. Naylor, a former first-round pick, is 26.
Quero is 24 and was once the Brewers’ top prospect before injuries slowed him down. Both have upside, but neither is Contreras.
That matters because the Brewers are coming off the first World Series title in franchise history, and Contreras was a major reason they got there. With much of the roster still intact, another title run is on the table next season, and Contreras is a central piece of that picture. The return for him might not outweigh the value of keeping him for another push.
There are signs Milwaukee may feel the same way. ESPN’s Jeff Passan said Contreras “isn’t going anywhere,” and The Athletic’s Jim Bowden reported that the Brewers will try to extend him this offseason.
Even if no extension gets done, Contreras should still be in the clubhouse on Opening Day. He is a leader for the organization, and if the Brewers don’t look like contenders next summer, they could always revisit a trade then and still bring back a strong package. For now, though, moving Contreras would create more problems than it solves.
In Other News...
Brewers Trade Is Worth Revisiting As Former Prospect Breaks Out
The Brewers have had a few trade decisions age in interesting ways, and the Josh Hader deal is one of the biggest reasons the front office still gets credit for its long view. Robert Gasser and William Contreras both became part of the organizations climb to a World Series title, a reminder that Milwaukee has often been willing to move a big name when the return can help across the roster, not just in the moment.
A similar thread runs through the more recent 2025 swap that sent Mason Molina to the Rangers for Grant Anderson. Molina later landed with the Cardinals and has since been recognized as their 2026 Minor League Pitcher of the Year, while Anderson has settled in as a dependable arm in Milwaukees bullpen. It is the kind of deal that does not always look tidy right away, but for the Brewers it has already become another example of why these transactions tend to be worth revisiting. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Suddenly Have A Real Opening Day Battle To Watch
The Brewers spent part of the roster deadline sorting out their 40-man picture, and one of the more interesting names to come through was Jett Williams, the prospect acquired from the Mets. Milwaukee added six players overall, but Williams stands out because he has yet to play in the majors and still has a path to the Opening Day roster, a reflection of how little turnover the club is expecting this winter.
Third base has emerged as one of the few real battlegrounds on the Brewers roster, and Williams versatility only adds to the intrigue. He can handle shortstop, third base and center field, though third is the spot that looks most realistic if he breaks camp with the team. For a club with so few obvious lineup changes ahead, that kind of competition is worth watching closely. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Add More Infield Insurance After Last Seasons Depth Scare
The Brewers have added another layer of infield depth, bringing back Braden Shewmake on a minor league contract that includes an invitation to big league Spring Training. Shewmake spent part of last season in Milwaukee after arriving in a trade from the Houston Astros, and the club is clearly comfortable keeping a versatile glove in the organization as it looks to guard against another depth crunch.
Shewmakes major league track record has been limited, but his ability to handle multiple infield spots gives the Brewers a useful option if injuries or roster churn create openings. For a team that learned how quickly the middle infield picture can get thin, this is the kind of low-cost move that can matter more than it looks at first glance. [Read more 🡒]
