Sonny Gray turned in a serviceable outing for the Red Sox in their Wild Card loss to the Yankees, but it was his neck - not just his stuff - that drew the loudest reaction.
Gray, who was Boston’s go-to starter for much of the 2026 season and posted career highs in wins and ERA in seasons where he pitched more than 65 innings, gave the Red Sox 4.2 innings and allowed two runs while striking out five. That wasn’t enough to get Boston past New York, and it also wasn’t enough to quiet the speculation that followed him off the mound.
The focus of the chatter was a strange substance that appeared on the right side of Gray’s neck. Throughout the start, he repeatedly swiped at that spot, and some viewers wondered whether it was part of a sticky substance situation.
The moment gained traction online, with one post noting, “Sonny Gray asks for a new ball and then immediately touches his neck. He was doing this all game 🕵️♀️”
The theory got even more attention after a Jomboy breakdown suggested Gray may have been using a foreign element to help his spin rates. Jomboy posted, “Sonny Gray obviously had sticky stuff on his neck, a breakdown”
Still, there’s no clear proof of anything beyond suspicion. Officials believed Gray’s performance was legitimate, and one social media user pointed out that Gray has been known to wipe at his neck before. That same observation noted he made the motion several times in the first inning, before the visible residue showed up later.
Another post pushed back on the pine tar talk, saying, “This video is for anyone who thinks Sonny Gray used pine tar tonight”
Even so, the rumor mill kept spinning. Social media was filled with claims that Gray had crossed the line by using pine tar to make his pitches tougher to hit. And some, including Jomboy, even floated the idea that Red Sox manager Chad Tracy pulled Gray early to keep him from getting caught up in the cheating allegations.
In Other News...
Brewers Send A Clear NLDS Message With Latest Pitching Cut
With the postseason picture tightening, the Brewers made a quick roster adjustment this week by designating right-hander Lyon Richardson for assignment just two days after calling him up. It was a brief big-league stay for Richardson, who made one appearance for Milwaukee in 2025 after arriving with some recent organizational familiarity as a former Cincinnati Red.
Richardson later elected free agency rather than accepting an outright assignment to the minors, closing the book on his short stint in Milwaukee for now. For a club focused on lining up its pitching staff for October, the move underscored how little room there is on the roster this time of year and how decisively the Brewers are treating every final decision. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Drew A Dangerous NLDS Matchup At The Worst Time
San Diego just took care of the Cubs in the National League Wild Card Series, and now the reward is a Division Series date with the top-seeded Brewers. For Milwaukee, it is a tough draw at a time when both teams have earned their way here with strong regular seasons, and the Padres arrive looking every bit like a club that can shorten games with pitching and jump on opponents early at the plate.
The Brewers do not have much time to exhale before this one starts, and the matchup is built around San Diegos arms as much as anything else. The Padres are expected to lean on a bullpen-heavy approach, while also lining up starters Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson and Robbie Ray, which makes this feel like a series where one quiet inning can turn into a real problem in a hurry. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Fans Have One Big Reason To Watch Cubs Padres Game 2
The Brewers are already locked into waiting mode as the Padres and Cubs sort out the other side of the NL bracket, and Game 2 now carries plenty of weight for Milwaukee's next opponent. San Diego took the opener in convincing fashion behind key contributions from Fernando Tatis Jr. and Manny Machado, which at least gave Brewers fans a glimpse of the kind of lineup the club could be preparing for in the NLDS.
Game 2 also puts a couple of fresh playoff storylines on display, with the Cubs turning to Kevin Gausman against Nick Pivetta for San Diego. Brewers fans will be watching the starting pitching closely, along with Alex Bregman's status and effectiveness after injury, because the winner of this series could bring a very different challenge to Milwaukee depending on which arms hold up and which bats keep carrying the day. [Read more 🡒]