Two Former Brewers Just Reopened A Hall Of Fame Debate

As two former Brewers relievers, Francisco Rodrguez and Joakim Soria, join the competitive 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, the debate intensifies over their contrasting legacies and potential for baseball's highest honor.

Two former Brewers relievers have landed on the 2027 Hall of Fame ballot, with right-handers Francisco Rodríguez and Joakim Soria among the 21 players under consideration.

Rodríguez and Soria each spent time in Milwaukee, though their cases for Cooperstown look very different. Rodríguez was with the Brewers for parts of five seasons and finished his Milwaukee run with a 2.91 ERA and 95 saves in 263 career appearances. That save total ranks fifth in franchise history, behind Dan Plesac (133), Josh Hader (125), John Axford (106), and Rollie Fingers (95).

Soria’s Brewers stint came during part of the 2018 season, when he joined a Milwaukee club that reached the NLCS before falling in seven games.

The voting process gives writers up to 10 selections on the ballot, and a player needs 75% approval to be inducted. Anyone who falls below 5% does not return to the next year’s ballot.

This is Rodríguez’s fifth year on the ballot, while Soria is appearing for the first time.

Of the two, Rodríguez has the far stronger Hall of Fame résumé. He owns the regular-season all-time saves record with 62, won a World Series title in 2002, and finished his career with 437 saves.

He posted a 2.86 ERA and a 28.5% strikeout rate, and among relievers with 500 innings from 2002 to 2017, that strikeout rate ranks seventh. He also sits 17th in park-adjusted ERA-, with a 69 mark that means he was 31% better at preventing earned runs than the average pitcher.

Billy Wagner’s induction in 2026 could help create more room for closers in the Hall, and Rodríguez is now sixth all-time in saves. The only two pitchers ahead of him who have not been inducted, Craig Kimbrel and Kenley Jansen, are both still active.

For Rodríguez, the debate is whether 437 saves and six All-Star appearances will eventually be enough. It also doubles as a test of how the Hall values the one-inning closer. Wagner had fewer saves and a weaker postseason résumé, but he was better at preventing runs.

Soria’s case is much easier to sort through. He was a strong closer for a long stretch, but his career totals stop at 229 saves over 763 innings.

His best stretch came early, from 2007 to 2010, and he did not age nearly as well as Rodríguez. He is likely to be a one-and-done candidate.

In Other News...

Brewers Just Made Their Priorities Clear With Two Key Players

The Brewers have drawn a pretty clear line as they sort through their long-term plans, and it starts with William Contreras. Milwaukee has made it known that the catcher is not available in trade talks, while also showing interest in working toward a contract extension that would keep him at the center of the roster for years to come. With his option already exercised for the 2027 season, the organization is treating him like more than just a core piece - he is part of the foundation.

Trevor Megill, on the other hand, appears to be in a different category. Milwaukee is open to trade discussions involving the closer, a sign that the front office is willing to listen if the right deal comes along. The contrast between the two players says plenty about where the Brewers see their priorities, with one being protected and the other at least available for conversation as the roster picture continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]

Brewers Suddenly Face A Tough Bo Naylor Decision

The Brewers catching depth has become one of the more interesting roster questions of the winter, and Bo Naylor sits right in the middle of it. Milwaukee already has William Contreras and Jeferson Quero in the mix, which gives the club options behind the plate but also forces some hard choices as the front office sorts out who fits best for the long haul.

Naylor has been mentioned as a possible non-tender candidate, even with the track record and upside that make him an appealing piece on paper. For a team with legitimate catching depth, the issue is less about whether he can help and more about whether Milwaukee wants to commit a contract spot to him when the roster picture is already crowded. [Read more 🡒]

Brewers Have Three Silver Slugger Races Fans Will Be Watching Closely

The Brewers will have a few familiar names in the mix when the 2026 Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards are announced on Nov. 17, with Brice Turang, Jackson Chourio and Jake Bauers all earning nominations at their respective positions. For Milwaukee, it is another sign that the lineup has produced enough across the board to put multiple players in the conversation, and it gives fans a reason to keep one eye on the awards season while the offseason chatter continues.

What makes these races worth watching is how crowded they are, with each Brewer facing a legitimate challenge from players around the league. Turang, Chourio and Bauers all have cases, but none of them can assume anything with the announcement coming during FanSideds The Baseball Insiders podcast and YouTube show. For a team that has leaned on balanced production, the final verdict could offer one more snapshot of how Milwaukee stacks up against the rest of the National League and beyond. [Read more 🡒]