Tarik Skubal Debate Just Took An Unexpected Turn For Contenders

The Milwaukee Brewers' surprising position in the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes reveals strategic priorities and financial constraints that shape their offseason approach.

The Milwaukee Brewers made a real run at Tarik Skubal last summer, but that doesn’t mean they’re suddenly the kind of team ready to chase him again now that he’s on the open market.

Milwaukee put together a serious package for the two-time Cy Young Award winner, offering No. 2 prospect Luis Pena, No. 3 prospect Josh Adamczewski and No. 10 prospect Jett Williams. By the sound of it, the Brewers had one of the strongest bids on the table. Detroit still chose the Los Angeles Dodgers’ offer, and Milwaukee moved on to win the World Series anyway.

That’s why ESPN’s David Schoenfield putting the Brewers in the middle of his Skubal rankings stood out. In his breakdown of every team’s odds to land the left-hander, Schoenfield slotted Milwaukee at No. 15 in the “Maybe, but they don’t really need a starter” group.

“The Brewers’ projected payroll sits right about where it was in 2026. Even if there is room to go a little higher following their title, that might go into locking up World Series MVP William Contreras on a long-term deal before he heads to free agency following the 2027 season. In the meantime, while they did make a deal for Dustin May for temporary rotation help down the stretch in 2026, they have depth here with Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson, Robert Gasser, Kyle Harrison, Shane Drohan, Brandon Sproat and the hopeful return of Quinn Priester,” Schoenfield wrote.

The bigger issue for Milwaukee is the price tag. The Athletic’s Jim Bowden reported that teams “know going in” Skubal’s next contract is expected to land somewhere between $350 and $500 million.

That kind of number doesn’t fit the Brewers’ history. Christian Yelich owns the biggest contract in franchise history at $215 million over nine years, while Ryan Braun’s $105 million deal over five years ranks second.

So even with Schoenfield placing Milwaukee ahead of teams like the Texas Rangers, Atlanta Braves, Baltimore Orioles, Los Angeles Angels and Houston Astros, the fit still feels unlikely. A franchise that has never come close to that level of spending is not suddenly about to reset its market for a pitcher who had surgery during the 2026 season.

For Brewers fans, the message is pretty clear: don’t count on Milwaukee making that kind of leap this winter.

In Other News...

Two Former Brewers Just Reopened A Hall Of Fame Debate

The 2027 Hall of Fame ballot has brought an old Brewers conversation back into focus, with two former Milwaukee relievers now in the mix at the same time. Francisco Rodrguez, who spent part of his career in Milwaukee, is back on the ballot for the fifth year, carrying a rsum built around 437 saves and six All-Star selections, while Joakim Soria is making his first appearance after a long career that produced 229 saves.

For Brewers fans, it is a reminder of how much late-inning history has passed through Milwaukee, even if the Hall of Fame case for relievers has always been a tricky one. Rodrguez has the stronger statistical argument and the longer ballot runway, while Soria enters as a fresh name whose candidacy will be judged against a different standard, leaving the larger question of how voters weigh elite closers unresolved for now. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Are Betting Big On Dustin May For One Reason

The White Sox are taking a sizable swing on Dustin May, agreeing to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the right-hander after he declined a mutual option with the Brewers. May, 29, heads to Chicago as a rotation addition with a track record that has long made evaluators believe there is more upside there than the injury history alone would suggest.

For Milwaukee, it closes the book on a pitcher who helped the club during its 2026 World Series run and gave the Brewers a look at the kind of arsenal that can still play in a big league rotation when he is right. Chicago is betting that the mix is worth the risk, and the real question now is how quickly May can settle in and give the White Sox the stability they are paying for. [Read more 🡒]

Brewers May Have A New First Base Decision Looming

The Brewers already have enough to think about as they sort out their infield plans, but a possible change in Boston is worth keeping an eye on. Triston Casas has been floated as a candidate to be moved if the Red Sox decide they need more roster flexibility and a fresh start for the young first baseman, and that kind of left-handed power bat would naturally draw interest from clubs looking for a longer-term answer at the position.

Milwaukee is one of the teams mentioned as a fit, which makes sense given the way the Brewers tend to weigh upside against fit and cost. Nothing is confirmed, and there has been no official move, but if Boston does open the door, the Brewers would be among the clubs with a reason to at least check the price and see whether a first base decision could be made for them. [Read more 🡒]