Shane Drohan’s last outing against the Minnesota Twins made one thing clear: when his slider disappears, the whole plan gets shaky.
After the rookie left-hander was tagged for a season-high six earned runs, he didn’t need long to diagnose the problem. “I was just too low with the slider,” he said postgame.
That pitch is supposed to be the weapon that ties everything together. Drohan’s tight gyro slider is his best offering, and FanGraphs’ Stuff+ model gives it a 108 grade, his top mark.
Big-league hitters have posted just a .215 xwOBA against it this season, and they’ve whiffed on 41.6% of their swings. But against the Twins, it never really entered the game.
Sliders usually work as a chase pitch, something hitters commit to before the late break pulls the ball away. For that to happen, though, the pitch has to start around the bottom of the strike zone.
Drohan wasn’t close enough. Only a quarter of his sliders were in the zone, and most of the rest were buried in the dirt well short of the plate.
“I was just throwing it too low,” Drohan said. “It could be a couple inches higher, so out of hand it's looking like that fastball at the bottom of the zone.”
Minnesota adjusted fast. Once the Twins could ignore anything down in the zone, they sat on the upper part of the strike zone where Drohan likes to work with his fastballs. Eight of the nine hits he allowed came on fastballs, and five of those were heaters at or above the belt.
The line looked worse than the contact really was. Drohan’s average exit velocity against was 78.6 mph, and only six of the 18 balls put in play against him were hit 95 mph or harder.
That speaks to how deceptive his fastballs can be. The problem was that his usual swing-and-miss shape at the top of the zone wasn’t there.
The Twins managed only two whiffs each against his four-seamer and cutter.
That was the difference. With the slider taken away, the bottom of the zone stopped mattering, and the contact started finding grass.
“They eliminated down, and the breaking ball didn't come into play,” Pat Murphy said. “His slider did not come into play much, and that's been key for him.”
It hasn’t been a one-game issue, either. Drohan has had trouble with uncompetitive sliders in recent starts.
Before facing Minnesota, he was spiking plenty of them in Anaheim, but he still threw enough quality sliders near the bottom of the zone to work six solid innings and strike out seven. He even coaxed some chases on those poor misses against a weak Los Angeles Angels lineup.
The next opponent made him pay for it.
“They hit them hard,” Murphy said. “You give up 10 hits, or whatever you gave up, that's unusual.
A couple homers. He missed some spots.”
Even with that rough start, Drohan’s rookie year has been a useful one for Milwaukee. His 3.87 ERA is above average, and his 3.50 xERA and 3.34 FIP sit a little lower. He’s been part of the reason the Brewers’ staff has kept rolling through injuries and workload management.
“He's throwing the ball great for us,” Murphy said. “Let's not act like he hasn't been good. If you had to pick four guys from the July time frame, this guy would be one of the four in everybody's ballot who have put us in this position.”
The Brewers will eventually have to decide what Drohan is best suited to be once October gets closer: a back-end starter or a multi-inning reliever capable of handling high-leverage innings. He has the stuff and the demeanor for either path, and he’s shown flashes in both roles.
But if he’s going to keep starting, the formula is simple enough. The slider has to get closer to the plate.
In Other News...
Brewers Suddenly Face A Brice Turang Problem They Couldn't Afford
Brice Turang has become one of the Brewers most important offensive pieces, which is why a thumb injury at this stage lands with immediate concern. He sprained it against the Padres, and for a club already navigating life without infielder Cooper Pratt on the Injured List, any absence from Turang would put extra strain on a group that has tried to keep the infield steady while the lineup holds together.
If Turang needs time, Milwaukee would have to find answers quickly from elsewhere on the roster, with Jihwan Bae, David Hamilton and Joey Ortiz among the names likely to matter more. None of those options can fully replace what Turang has brought, but this is the kind of shuffle the Brewers may have to manage if they want to avoid one injury turning into a deeper infield problem. [Read more 🡒]
Jackson Chourio's Early Exit Sent Brewers Fans A Clear Message
Jackson Chourios night ended early in a move that fit the Brewers bigger picture more than the box score. With a comfortable lead and the club already managing some bumps and bruises, Milwaukee chose to play it safe and get one of its most important young players out of the game before anything could turn into a larger problem.
Pat Murphy framed the decision as part of a broader effort to keep the roster in one piece entering the postseason, especially with Brice Turang dealing with a sore thumb and William Contreras having taken a swing off the wrist. For a team that has spent much of the season valuing depth and availability, the message was clear: the Brewers would rather absorb a little awkwardness in the moment than risk something worse later. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Suddenly Face A Depth Test They Cant Escape
The Brewers have spent much of this demanding stretch patching together their infield and outfield at the same time, with injuries forcing manager Pat Murphy to keep adjusting the lineup card. Rookie shortstop Cooper Pratt is on the injured list with a hamstring strain, Brice Turang is dealing with a sprained thumb, and Milwaukee has brought in Ji Hwan Bae while also leaning on Andrew Vaughn and Turang to cover different spots around the diamond.
Sal Frelicks absence has added to the squeeze in the outfield, where the Brewers have had to manage without one of their more reliable regulars because of a right shoulder strain. The encouraging part for Milwaukee is that help should be coming, but for now the club is still operating in survival mode as it tries to keep its season on track through a roster that keeps getting thinner before it gets whole again. [Read more 🡒]