The Brewers already know the arm they want on the mound when their 2026 postseason opens: Jacob Misiorowski.
Pat Murphy made that part clear Monday, confirming the National League Cy Young frontrunner will start Game 1 for Milwaukee on Saturday, October 3 at American Family Field. The opponent and start time for that opener still aren’t set, but the first name on the Brewers’ October card is no mystery.
Game 2, though, comes with a small wrinkle.
Rookie right-hander Logan Henderson is lined up for Sunday, October 4, and he’s the obvious candidate to follow Misiorowski after emerging as Milwaukee’s No. 2 starter in the second half. But Curt Hogg of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported that Murphy stopped short of locking it in, saying Henderson is lined up for Game 2, “But subject to change.”
That kind of wording fits Murphy’s track record. He doesn’t tend to hand out pitching plans unless he has to, and he has a history of keeping opponents guessing once the postseason starts. So while Henderson looks like the likely choice, the Brewers aren’t treating it like a done deal just yet.
Last year offered a perfect example. Most Brewers fans expected Quinn Priester to get Game 2 of the NLDS against the Cubs, only for him to wind up in Game 3 instead. Murphy played a little gamesmanship, Priester warmed up in the bullpen, and Craig Counsell and Chicago were braced for him before Murphy went with Misiorowski as the bulk pitcher in Game 2.
A similar twist this year wouldn’t be impossible, even if it still seems unlikely. The difference is that Priester was dealing with a late-season injury and his effectiveness was fading as the playoffs approached.
Henderson’s situation is different. He’s been steady through the second half, and he closed the regular season with a 1.93 ERA over his final seven starts.
Murphy’s “subject to change” line could also point to an opener. The Brewers used Aaron Ashby in that role three times last postseason, including in Game 2. If Milwaukee ends up facing the Cubs in the NLDS, a left-handed opener could be part of the plan to help neutralize expected NL MVP Pete Crow-Armstrong.
And that’s part of the reason the Brewers aren’t rushing to finalize everything. They won’t know their NLDS opponent until tomorrow night at the earliest, so there’s no need for Murphy to show his hand any sooner than necessary.
Misiorowski is taking the ball in Game 1 no matter what. That’s the luxury of having the best pitcher in baseball. Henderson is still the likeliest option for Game 2, but with Murphy’s postseason habits and Milwaukee’s unknown opponent, the caution flag makes sense.
In Other News...
Brewers Fans Turned A Meaningless Finale Into A Statement
With their postseason position already locked in before the final series against the St. Louis Cardinals, the Brewers still walked into a full house at American Family Field for all three games. The crowd turned what could have been a flat ending into something that felt more like a continuation of the summer run, and it pushed Milwaukee to 25 sellouts on the season, topping last years total.
Pat Murphy made clear the atmosphere mattered, because the Brewers were trying to keep their edge even with nothing left to gain in the standings. For a club that had already secured the top overall postseason seed, the challenge was less about chasing a result than preserving momentum, and the fan support gave that stretch the kind of energy teams usually hope to carry into October. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Have A Rare All-MLB Opportunity Fans Will Want To Track
The Brewers have put themselves in a spot that doesnt come around often, with a cluster of players showing up as All-MLB finalists across several positions. Jake Bauers is in the mix at first base, Brice Turang at second, William Contreras behind the plate, Jackson Chourio in the outfield and Jacob Misiorowski among the starting pitchers, giving Milwaukee a wide-ranging presence on a stage that reflects both production and recognition.
What makes it worth tracking from here is that the selection process is not left to one small corner of the game. Fans are part of the vote, along with other groups, which gives Brewers followers a chance to weigh in on a slate that already says plenty about how much talent Milwaukee assembled this season. Even with the finalist list in hand, the next step still carries some uncertainty, and that is part of what makes this one feel bigger than a routine honor watch. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Face Tough 2027 Decisions As Playoff Run Begins
The Brewers are about to open their 2026 playoff run Oct. 3 in the National League Division Series, but even with October baseball ahead, the front office already has a bigger list of issues waiting after the season. Milwaukee is staring at a roster that could look very different soon, with several key players either headed for free agency or carrying contract options that will need to be sorted out in the coming months.
Corbin Burnes and Freddy Peralta are among the names in that mix, which gives the Brewers a familiar kind of tension at this stage of a successful season: trying to chase a championship while knowing the groundwork for the next one has to start almost immediately. The article lays out each players status and the odds of Milwaukee keeping them around, a reminder that the clubs October push and its offseason questions are now moving on parallel tracks. [Read more 🡒]