Pat Murphy has a way of turning a routine media session into a long, winding conversation, and when the Brewers manager decides he wants to keep talking baseball, he’ll do it on his own terms.
That happened one day in April, when Murphy was asked about Joey Ortiz’s recent at-bats and chose to walk the writers and broadcasters in his office through the way he grades hitters from the dugout.
“I'll let you in on this,” Murphy said, gesturing to one of the many papers strewn across his desk.
What looked like a basic scorecard is really Murphy’s shorthand system for judging each Brewers at-bat as it happens. He marks the sheet with symbols that tell him how he felt about the plate appearance.
“I make notations on the type of at-bat it is,” he said. “If it's a dot, that means solid at-bat.
If it's a plus, that means really good. If it's a minus, that means ******.
If it's an equal sign, that means, 'Meh.'”
Murphy’s method is built around process, not just the final result. In that sense, it lines up with the way modern baseball tries to measure hitters: less obsession with whether a ball found grass, more attention to whether the swing decision and contact quality were right.
He said he’ll even factor in the shape of the at-bat itself.
“If it's an 11-pitch strikeout, I might give them an equal sign. Good battle,” Murphy said.
“But the key is to not have too many minuses. That's what gets guys in trouble, the minus, minus, minus.
Poor at-bats, at-bats that hurt us.”
The parallels to Statcast are obvious, even if Murphy isn’t sitting around reading Baseball Savant pages. He doesn’t need the jargon, in his view, because his eyes are already telling him what the data would.
“Hard contacts are usually a plus,” Murphy said. “If it's straight down or straight up, I can't give you a plus. I can give you a dot, not a plus.”
He also keeps his own version of a barrel on the card, even if he’s not using the official Statcast definition of a ball hit at least 98 mph within a certain launch angle range.
“If you get one good and it goes on that perfect trajectory… I'll give you a plus with a circle,” Murphy said.
Murphy was quick to note that the system is not meant to be a scientific model.
“It's not scientific,” Murphy said with a laugh. “It's really for me to remember without putting the actual scoring down there.”
Still, the card says plenty about how he sees the game. Murphy may come from an old-school baseball background, but his way of evaluating hitters fits neatly alongside an analytical front office. The language is different, but the priorities often match: good contact, good decisions, fewer empty trips.
In Other News...
Brewers Just Got Another Big Reminder They Nailed The Andrew Vaughn Trade
More than a year after Milwaukee sent Aaron Civale to the White Sox for Andrew Vaughn, the trade keeps looking better for the Brewers. Vaughn has settled in at first base and given the lineup the kind of steady production the club was hoping for, with his offensive work showing both consistency and real value in the middle of the order.
Civale, meanwhile, has kept trending the other way, which only sharpens the contrast in what was once a straightforward swap. Milwaukee does not need a reminder that Vaughn has been the more dependable piece, but the latest turn in Civales career makes the return look even stronger and leaves the Brewers with another example of a deal that has aged well in their favor. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Just Got A Costly New Reality On Jacob Misiorowski
Chase Burns new deal in Cincinnati has quietly changed the conversation for Milwaukee, because it gives the Brewers a fresh measuring stick if they want to lock up Jacob Misiorowski. The right-hander has been one of the most electric arms in the game this season, and his emergence has only sharpened the question of how aggressive the Brewers will need to be to keep him in place long term.
Misiorowskis rise has put him in a different class of extension candidate, and the timing matters because the market for young pitchers keeps moving. Milwaukee has not yet gotten into extension talks with him, but the Burns contract makes clear that any serious effort to buy out Misiorowskis future is going to come with a hefty price tag and a lot more urgency than it might have just a few weeks ago. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Civale's Exit From Milwaukee Keeps Looking Worse
Aaron Civales path since asking out of Milwaukee last June has only gotten bumpier. The right-hander was designated for assignment by the Athletics after 16 appearances and a 5.82 ERA, another rough stop for a pitcher who once looked like a useful rotation piece and has instead spent the last year bouncing from one roster crunch to the next.
The latest move also brings back an uncomfortable pattern for the Brewers to watch from afar. Civale was DFAd by the White Sox last summer after the trade out of Milwaukee, and this is the third time in a little over a year that he has landed in DFA limbo, a striking turn for a veteran who has already worn six big league uniforms in eight seasons. [Read more 🡒]