MLB World Reacts To Trump's Pete Rose Announcement

Will Pete Rose's presidential pardon tip the scales in the ongoing debate over his Hall of Fame candidacy?

Pete Rose’s Hall of Fame case has a new wrinkle, and it comes from the White House.

On Thursday, President Trump announced on Truth Social that he had issued a posthumous pardon for the Cincinnati Reds icon. In his post, Trump wrote, "I have just given a Complete and Total Pardon to the Late, Great Pete Rose, a true Baseball SUPERSTAR & LEGEND," Trump posted on Truth Social.

The pardon does not appear likely to change much when it comes to Rose’s Cooperstown chances, at least not with the Hall of Fame voters who will weigh in next December. What it does do is wipe away the two counts of filing false tax returns Rose admitted to in 1990.

Rose’s route back into the Hall conversation already took a major turn in May of 2025, when Major League Baseball Commissioner Rob Manfred posthumously removed him from the permanently ineligible list. That move, in effect, made Rose eligible for election into Cooperstown.

Even with that opening, the debate around Rose remains as divided as ever. Plenty of Reds fans - and plenty of baseball fans beyond Cincinnati - believe his on-field production should have been enough to put him in the Hall long ago.

But the decision is not in the hands of the public. It will come from a 12-person panel that meets next year.

The Classic Baseball Committee will not consider Rose until next December, when Reds fans will finally learn whether the panel believes he belongs in the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

There is no argument about the numbers Rose put up. He remains baseball’s all-time hits leader, and his 4,192nd hit on September 11, 1985 against the San Diego Padres stands as one of the most unforgettable moments in Reds history. The issue has always been what came after that: the gambling problems that damaged his standing and led to his permanent ban from baseball in 1989.

For some, that remains disqualifying. For others, MLB’s embrace of sports books and betting apps only makes Rose’s case look stronger, adding a layer of hypocrisy to the league’s stance and giving the 17-time All-Star another argument in the Hall of Fame fight.

In Other News...

Brewers May Have Solved First Base Sooner Than Expected

The Brewers moved quickly on the first-base picture ahead of the non-tender deadline, tendering a contract to Andrew Vaughn and signaling that they may have their answer there sooner than expected. Vaughn is projected to make about $8.5 million in 2027, and Milwaukee appears comfortable with him as a steady option while the organization waits for its next wave of prospects to push for bigger roles.

Jake Bauers, who had been tendered a qualifying offer, ended up signing with the Boston Red Sox, which helped clear the path for the Brewers to keep Vaughn in the fold. For a club that has spent plenty of time piecing together first base, the move suggests a preference for stability now rather than forcing the issue before the younger bats are ready. [Read more 🡒]

Diamondbacks May Have A New Third Base Trade Angle To Watch

The Brewers took care of several arbitration-eligible players ahead of the MLB deadline, including Joey Ortiz, and that alone was enough to keep him in the middle of the offseason conversation. Ortiz has been part of Milwaukees infield picture, but his name is now popping up in a different kind of discussion as clubs sort through their own roster fits and long-term plans.

One of those clubs is Arizona, where The Athletic has floated Ortiz as a possible target if the Diamondbacks decide to move Nolan Arenado off third base and chase a defensive upgrade. Milwaukee also has multiple prospects who could be in line for third base by 2027, which is part of why Ortiz could be viewed as movable, but for now it remains only a possibility rather than a deal in motion. [Read more 🡒]

Brewers Player Just Reopened A Brutal Dodgers Playoff Debate

Cooper Pratts recent appearance on the Baseball is Dead podcast brought a fresh angle to Milwaukees 2026 National League Championship Series loss to the Dodgers, and it was the kind of detail that tends to linger long after the final out. The Brewers infielder said the atmosphere at Dodger Stadium during the series felt more like a regular season game than the louder, more charged setting he experienced in San Diego, a comparison that immediately invites a bigger conversation about what home-field advantage really looked like in that matchup.

The backdrop only sharpens the point. None of the Dodgers home playoff games were sellouts, even with ticket prices running notably high, which makes Pratts observation feel less like a throwaway comment and more like part of a larger debate about the energy around that postseason run. For Milwaukee, it is another reminder that the series had plenty of baseball significance, but maybe not quite the October edge people expected from one of the sports marquee venues. [Read more 🡒]