The Brewers are signaling that Kyle Harrison’s role is about to look different, and the team’s weekend pitching plans make that pretty clear.
For a good stretch of this season, Milwaukee looked like it had the makings of a nasty postseason setup with Jacob Misiorowski and Harrison leading the way. That was the conversation at the trade deadline, too: with those two dealing in the first half, the Brewers were in position to chase another starter and build one of the sport’s best playoff trios. That picture has changed in a hurry.
Misiorowski is still the staff headliner and the favorite for the NL Cy Young Award, but Harrison has not been nearly as sharp since coming back from the injured list. The 25-year-old lefty went down in early July with left forearm tightness, returned at the start of August, and hasn’t been the same pitcher since.
Before the injury, Harrison had put together a 3.01 ERA across his first 17 starts, along with a 5.05 strikeout-to-walk rate. In six starts since returning, he’s carrying a 5.67 ERA and a 2.54 strikeout-to-walk rate. The bigger worry is what’s happening with the stuff itself: his fastball has reportedly lost some of the velocity and shape it had before the injury.
That’s why Milwaukee has been weighing alternatives for him late in the season. A bullpen move.
Shorter outings. Something less than the usual starter’s load.
And the Brewers’ latest pitching schedule points toward a change arriving soon.
The team announced that Dustin May, another trade deadline pickup, will take the ball Friday night in the series opener against the Cincinnati Reds. But Milwaukee has not yet named a starter for Saturday or Sunday.
Under the normal rotation, Harrison would have been lined up for Saturday. Instead, the Brewers are holding off.
Manager Pat Murphy said Harrison will pitch over the weekend, but his exact role is still undecided. He could start.
He could relieve. What seems clear is that Milwaukee does not plan to give him a full starter’s workload, at least not right now, as the club tests whether shorter stints can get him back on track.
Brewers probable starters for the weekend so far:
Friday- Dustin May
Saturday - TBA (possibly a shorter Kyle Harrison start)
Sunday - TBA
The Brewers need Harrison to resemble the first-half version of himself if they want him to matter in October. They may not need him to grind through five or six innings in the postseason, but they do need him to be effective. Right now, that’s the part that’s missing.
So the final weeks of the regular season are shaping up as a real evaluation period for Milwaukee. The Brewers need to figure out whether Harrison can rediscover his dominant form, because the answer affects the shape of their playoff pitching staff. And if they can’t count on him, that creates a difficult problem for a team still chasing a World Series championship.
In Other News...
Brewers Bullpen Shuffle After Cubs Win Says A Lot About One Arm
The Brewers kept the good vibes rolling with a win over the Cubs, moving to 91-56 and stretching their division lead in the process, but the late-inning work still triggered a roster move. After Brandon Sproat struggled in the ninth, Milwaukee optioned him back to Triple-A Nashville and brought up Garrett Stallings, a reminder that even in a strong season, the bullpen is still a nightly test of depth and trust.
Stallings is hardly an unfamiliar face to the organization. He already made his major league debut earlier this season, and now he steps back into the mix to fill the opening created by Grant Andersons injury. For a staff built on constantly adjusting on the fly, the move says plenty about which arms the Brewers believe they can lean on as the schedule keeps tightening. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Already Face An Awkward Call On Deadline Bullpen Pickup
The Brewers brought in Antonio Senzatela at midseason hoping to stabilize a bullpen that needed more reliable innings, but the early returns have made the move look a lot more complicated than a simple deadline fix. After coming over from the Rockies, Senzatela has been hit hard in Milwaukee, and his 5.87 ERA over 16 outings has left the club with a longer-term decision that now feels more pressing than it did when the trade was made.
According to ESPNs Jeff Passan, Milwaukee is unlikely to exercise the $14 million club option for Senzatela in 2027, which would let the team walk away without owing a buyout. For a Brewers front office that has usually been careful with payroll and roster value, the question is whether there is still enough time for Senzatela to change the conversation before the offseason arrives. [Read more 🡒]
Brandon Sproat's Brewers Audition Just Raised A Tough October Question
Brandon Sproat got another look in the majors and, for stretches, showed why the Brewers remain intrigued by him. The arm talent is obvious, and the strikeout upside still gives him a path into bigger innings down the line, but his latest relief outing also showed why the evaluation is not simple. A game that should have been a routine step in his return instead turned tense when his control wavered and his command slipped.
Four walks and a hit batter nearly put a Brewers win in jeopardy, and it only reinforced the question hovering over his immediate future. The club has been open about the fact that Sproat has real potential, but the next step is not about stuff so much as composure and the pitching process that comes with it. A return to Triple-A Nashville now looks likely, and Milwaukee will keep sorting out whether there is enough time for him to sharpen up before October decisions get serious. [Read more 🡒]