Jacob Misiorowski has done everything a pitcher can do to make the National League All-Star start feel like his. That’s what makes the possibility of Shohei Ohtani stepping in and taking the job for a reason that has nothing to do with performance so jarring.
Misiorowski has been one of the most dominant arms in baseball through the first three months of the 2026 season. He leads all qualified major league starters, not just National League pitchers, in ERA at 1.45, strikeouts with 146, WHIP at 0.77, and batting average against at .144.
He also has a Maddux on his season line, a complete-game shutout on fewer than 100 pitches. That kind of run has already locked him into a second All-Star selection, and it has put him in the pole position to start the Midsummer Classic for the National League if he chooses to pitch.
The problem is that the race for the honor is not being decided on merit alone. The 2026 All-Star Game will be played at Citizens Bank Park, and Misiorowski’s biggest challenger is Phillies left-hander Cristopher Sánchez.
Sánchez leads the league in innings pitched at 110.0, ranks second in strikeouts with 127, and sits third in ERA at 2.13. If the decision comes down to a close call, the home-field factor could matter, because All-Star Game managers often lean toward the hometown player.
But even Sánchez may not be the real obstacle.
Dave Roberts, who will manage the National League team after the Dodgers won the pennant the year before, is already talking about the pitching plan for the game. According to Bill Shaikin of the Los Angeles Times, Roberts is considering Shohei Ohtani as the starter if Ohtani pitches in the game at all.
“Dave Roberts said there is no decision yet on whether Shohei Ohtani will pitch in the All-Star Game. If he does, Roberts said, he’ll be the starting pitcher (as he was in Colorado at the 2021 All-Star Game), as it’s impractical for him to warm up during the game while DH’ing.”
That logic may solve a logistical issue, but it does not answer the bigger question of who deserves the nod. As of June 29, Ohtani is not a qualified starter because of the way the Dodgers have handled his workload. He has a worse ERA, a worse WHIP, fewer strikeouts, and 20 fewer innings pitched than Misiorowski.
There’s no argument that Ohtani remains a singular talent, and MLB will always want to put him in the spotlight. But giving him the All-Star start would come at the expense of a pitcher who has clearly outperformed him this season. Misiorowski has even made more starts, 16 to Ohtani’s 13, because the Dodgers have worked with a six-man rotation to manage Ohtani’s innings.
That’s what makes the whole situation so uneasy for Milwaukee. If Ohtani gets the assignment because Roberts wants to make the logistics work, Misiorowski could lose the chance to open the game despite being the better pitcher by the numbers that matter most.
And if that happens, it won’t just be a Brewers gripe. It would raise real questions about how All-Star Game starters should be chosen and how much control managers ought to have over the honor.
In Other News...
Brewers May Need A Familiar Face To Fix A Lingering Problem
With the trade deadline coming up on Aug. 3, the Brewers are in a familiar spot: strong enough on the mound to contend, but still looking for a way to smooth out a few rough edges on the roster. One idea floating around is a reunion with players they already know, which would make sense for a club that values fit and familiarity as much as upside. Among the names to watch are Grant Wolfram, now with the Orioles, and Bryan Hudson, who has steadied himself with the White Sox after an uneven earlier stretch.
There is also a bench-piece angle to this search, with David Fry in Cleveland offering the kind of versatility that can quietly matter over the final two months. Even so, the bigger question for Milwaukee is whether the front office wants to use this deadline to chase a cleaner fix for the left side of the infield, or lean on the pitching depth that has carried the club this far. The Brewers have options, but not every option comes without a price. [Read more 🡒]
Jacob Misiorowski's All-Star Moment May Come With One Big Catch
Jacob Misiorowski has spent the first half of the season looking like the kind of arm that can change the conversation around a pitching staff, and the numbers back it up. The Brewers right-hander is 9-3 and sits atop the majors with a 1.45 ERA, a 0.77 WHIP and 146 strikeouts, a stretch of dominance that has made him an obvious All-Star candidate for Milwaukee and the National League alike.
The catch is timing. Milwaukee plans to keep Misiorowski on a heavy turn through the break, with three more starts lined up before the All-Star pause, which would leave him in line to make the roster but not necessarily take the mound in the game itself. It is the sort of scheduling wrinkle that can turn a first-half breakthrough into a showcase without the showcase moment, even as his work has put him in position to be one of the leagues most talked-about pitchers. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Suddenly Look Ready To Make A Real Deadline Push
With injuries hanging around and the roster not fully at strength, Milwaukee still has managed to keep itself in a premium spot in the National League. The Brewers are in first place in the Central and sit near the top of the league standings, which is a pretty good place to be when the calendar is closing in on the Aug. 3 trade deadline. Even with the setbacks, the foundation remains obvious: a deep pitching staff and an offense that has enough punch to keep the club in the hunt.
That kind of position changes the conversation from survival to reinforcement, and it has pushed Milwaukee into the group of teams expected to buy rather than sit still. The front office has internal answers it can lean on, but the market is also expected to offer help, especially where the roster could use a lift in the bullpen and more power in the lineup. For a team with this kind of standing, the next few weeks are less about whether it should add and more about how aggressively it wants to turn a strong summer into something even sturdier. [Read more 🡒]