Freddy Peralta’s 2026 season took a turn nobody could have plotted in February.
Back then, the former Brewers ace was shipped from Milwaukee to the New York Mets in a deal that sent right-hander Brandon Sproat and utility prospect Jett Williams back to the Brewers. The Mets were supposed to be a contender, expected to win the NL East and chase a World Series title. Instead, their 2026 collapse pushed former Brewers president of baseball operations David Stearns to move Peralta again, this time to the Tampa Bay Rays at the trade deadline.
The move unlocked Peralta in a big way.
After struggling to a 4.99 ERA in 22 starts with the Mets over the first four months, the 30-year-old settled in with Tampa Bay. He made 10 regular-season starts after the deadline and posted a 3.25 ERA, looking much more like the All-Star version of himself from 2025.
That late surge carried straight into October. Peralta became a major part of the Rays’ postseason rotation alongside fellow former Brewer Drew Rasmussen and veteran right-hander Nick Martinez. He worked as Tampa Bay’s No. 2 starter behind Rasmussen, then turned into the most important arm on the club’s ALCS roster and, by the end of the series, the most valuable overall player in the Rays’ defeat of the Cleveland Guardians.
After Game 6 last night, when Peralta went 5.1 innings and allowed just one earned run, he added an unlikely piece of hardware to the collection: ALCS MVP.
The award itself comes with plenty of surprise. Peralta began the year with an NL contender, and pitchers do not usually take home LCS MVP honors.
The last pitchers to win either the ALCS or NLCS MVP were Jon Lester, who shared the NLCS award for the Chicago Cubs, and Andrew Miller, who won the ALCS award for the then-Cleveland Indians, back in 2016. Even more striking, Peralta was sitting on a 5.37 ERA as recently as August 4.
Still, the case for him is strong. A lot of eyes will go to Yandy Díaz, who homered twice in the six-game series, but both of those blasts came in the ninth inning and changed the score from 5-3 in Tampa Bay’s favor to 7-3. They were decisive exclamation points, not the engine of the series.
Peralta’s work, by contrast, was the backbone. He threw 12.0 innings of one-run ball across two starts and one relief appearance, and the Rays won all three games he pitched in. He also out-pitched Rasmussen just enough to make the selection feel earned, not just unusual.
Now the Brewers are left hoping the pitcher they know so well has cooled off by the time the Fall Classic begins on Friday. Peralta is expected to start Game 2 for the Rays on Saturday night at American Family Field, which would mark his second outing in his old home since the offseason trade. He already pitched there once this year, starting for the Mets on July 20 and allowing seven earned runs on eight hits in 5.1 innings.
He’s not the same pitcher now. Tampa Bay made mechanical adjustments that helped change his shape on the mound, but Milwaukee still presents a tricky matchup because of its patient approach at the plate, which can drive Peralta’s pitch count up.
And somewhere in the middle of all this, Brewers fans get the odd reality that Jake Bauers is the 2026 NLCS MVP and Freddy Peralta is the 2026 ALCS MVP. Before the season, that would have sounded impossible without a heavy dose of faith in both players and a complete loss of faith in the Mets, who wound up selling at the deadline.
Baseball, as always, found a way to surprise everyone.
In Other News...
Brewers Just Sent A Familiar NL Threat Into Its Next Chapter
The Dodgers NLCS sweep at the hands of Milwaukee did more than end a threepeat bid. It also pushed Los Angeles into a winter of figuring out how to keep its biggest star on track after the wear and tear that comes with Shohei Ohtanis rare two-way workload, a challenge that has become part of the clubs long-term planning as much as any roster decision.
Dodgers president Andrew Friedman offered one encouraging update this week, saying Ohtani is expected to return to the mound after a period of rest and remain a central piece of the teams future. For the Brewers, who just sent a powerhouse lineup home earlier than expected, it is another reminder that the opponent they knocked out is still built to reload quickly, with Ohtanis next chapter still very much in play. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Ashby May Decide Whether The Brewers Survive This Series
Aaron Ashby has become one of the quiet reasons Milwaukee is still hanging around in this World Series. The Brewers have leaned on him for multiple innings at a time, and his presence has given Pat Murphy the kind of bullpen flexibility every manager craves in October, especially against a Tampa Bay Rays club that forces every pitching decision to matter.
What makes Ashby so valuable is also what makes this next stretch so delicate: he has to keep the Rays from dictating the matchup flow and preserve enough of the staff for everything that follows. His command has been steady through the postseason, but Milwaukee still needs him to keep handling big innings in a series where one rough night can change the entire shape of the pitching plan. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Enter Rare World Series With One Edge Fans Will Love
The Brewers and Rays dont have much history to lean on, but they do have a useful recent sample from the regular season. In their three-game series, both clubs had stretches where pitching and relief work dictated the tempo, a reminder that this matchup is likely to be decided by the same kind of small margins that often define October baseball. It also sets up something rare for the sport: a World Series pairing that guarantees a first-time champion.
For Milwaukee, that kind of stage is the payoff for a roster built around run prevention and staying power on the mound. The Brewers have spent the year showing they can hang in tight games, and the matchup with Tampa Bay only sharpens the focus on who can hold up deeper into the night when the starters exit and the bullpen takes over. However the series unfolds, the clubs recent meetings suggest the deciding edge may come from which side can keep the pressure on after the first few innings. [Read more 🡒]