The Cubs had a 3-0 lead and still walked out of Tuesday night with a loss that cost them the top Wild Card spot.
Chicago fell 4-3 to the Brewers at home, dropping the second game of the three-game series and slipping to 78-61 while Milwaukee improved to 86-53. With the Phillies winning as well, the Cubs moved into second place in the Wild Card standings and would be on the road if the season ended today.
The game turned in a messy sixth inning, when the Cubs’ bullpen gave up four runs and handed the lead back to Milwaukee. Daniel Palencia struggled again, but he wasn’t alone in the wreckage. Every one of Chicago’s five pitchers allowed a run, and the Brewers piled up 13 hits on the night.
That’s becoming the story with this group. Not long ago, Craig Counsell seemed to have found a bullpen he could trust, especially with optimism around arms like Palencia coming back into the mix.
Then came a rough six-game road trip, and Jacob Webb blew two saves in Seattle and Arizona. Since then, the relief corps has been leaking runs while the offense has done enough to keep the damage from looking even worse.
The underlying numbers are ugly. The Cubs bullpen has a -0.8 fWAR this year, and only the Nationals have allowed more home runs.
A league-worst 14.1% of their fly balls are leaving the park, while the group’s 3.93 ERA hides a 4.59 FIP that ranks fourth worst in the league. They’ve also been excellent at stranding runners, leaving 76.8% on base, but that hasn’t been enough to cover up the swing-and-miss problem.
There’s no simple fix sitting there right now. The hope is that Palencia and Ryan Zeferjahn can work through their struggles and settle things down before October. Edward Cabrera is close to returning and could add some needed swing-and-miss, but he has never been a reliever, so this isn’t a plug-and-play solution for the back end.
The Cubs’ offense had already given them a jolt Monday with a 17-3 win and nine home runs, so this wasn’t a night where the bats should carry all the blame. Still, after Chicago scored to make it 5-4 in the bottom of the sixth, the lineup went hitless over the final three innings. The Cubs are still very boom-or-bust, and while the long ball has become part of their identity, it can leave them too dependent on one big swing.
The top of the order didn’t help much either. Pete Crow-Armstrong, Seiya Suzuki and Alex Bregman combined to go 1-for-10 with five strikeouts. When that happens and the pitching lets the other side score in four straight innings, momentum disappears fast.
There was at least one bright moment for BJ Murray, who picked up his first MLB hit. The rookie switch-hitter was called up from Triple-A Iowa on Monday after hitting 16 home runs with an .895 OPS, and the 26-year-old’s best professional season got a small reward on Tuesday.
Defense usually gives the Cubs a boost, and the team has been excellent there all season, but not on this night. The biggest miss came in right field, where Seiya Suzuki dropped a tough fly ball from Andrew Vaughn in the sixth inning to tie the game. Earlier in the inning, Palencia was also called for a balk, moving the runner from second to third before Christian Yelich followed with a two-run homer that put Milwaukee ahead for good.
After the game, Counsell pointed to the defense’s lack of crispness.
"These were very difficult plays, but we have to play great defense. And we played good defense tonight, but against the best team in baseball, you gotta play great defense. We got our glove on a bunch of balls, didn't make plays, and that's the difference."
The Cubs didn’t commit an error, but the night still fit the larger concern: this team depends on elite defense and enough bullpen stability to make it all work. Right now, they’re not getting enough of either, and the losses are starting to stack up with the final month approaching.
In Other News...
Former Brewers Reliever Gets Another Shot To Test Milwaukees Decision
Easton McGees path away from Milwaukee has already taken a few turns since the Brewers designated him for assignment and shipped him to Kansas City in July. He got a brief look with the Royals, then spent most of August in Triple-A, where the results were rough enough to push him back out of the spotlight for a while.
Now he is back on Kansas Citys major league roster as a September call-up, which gives him another chance to show he belongs in an MLB bullpen. For the Brewers, it is the kind of move that keeps a former arm on the radar and quietly reopens the question of whether the organization gave up on him too soon. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers May Have Found The Tweak Antonio Senzatela Needed
Antonio Senzatelas move to the Brewers has already come with a clearer role and a different pitch mix, but the early returns were uneven. After his transition from the Rockies rotation to the bullpen, he had found more success leaning on a cutter and four-seam fastball, yet Milwaukee initially had him working more with a sinker-cutter combination that did not produce the kind of results the club was hoping for.
The good news for the Brewers is that the answer may have been less about the pitch itself than where he was throwing it from. A later adjustment to Senzatelas position on the mound helped his sinker play better, giving Milwaukee a possible path to a more effective version of the right-hander as it continues to sort out how he fits into the staff. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Deadline Gamble Is Turning Into An October Rotation Problem
When Milwaukee dealt for Dustin May at the deadline, the move was supposed to deepen a rotation the Brewers hoped would hold up into the stretch run. Instead, the right-hander has been searching for answers since arriving, and the early returns have been rough enough to change the tone around what was meant to be a stabilizing addition.
May has posted a 6.41 ERA in five appearances with Milwaukee, part of a season that has already been uneven overall. His 6-9 record and 4.69 ERA underscore why the Brewers were betting on upside when they brought him in, but the performance has not matched the ask, and it now looks unlikely the club will pick up his option for 2027. [Read more 🡒]