The Brewers are running out of time to figure out what to do with Kyle Harrison.
For much of the season, Harrison looked like one of the most dependable arms in the group. In the first half, he was dealing at a level that had him looking almost untouchable, and maybe even like a pitcher who could pick up some Cy Young votes, though still behind the ace of the staff, Jacob Misiorowski. His 3.01 ERA made it easy to believe Milwaukee had pulled off another steal from the Boston Red Sox.
Then came the forearm tightness.
Right before the All Star Break, Harrison went on the IL and missed nearly a month. He came back on August 5, but the version the Brewers got back has not looked anything like the one they had before the injury.
The fastball changed first. It lost some velocity, but more importantly, it lost the vertical break and movement that had made it so tough to track.
That put more pressure on the secondary pitches, especially his slurve, and those pitches are best when they’re built off a fastball that hitters have to respect. Instead, the whole package has led to a lot of hard contact.
The results have been ugly. Over his last 7.1 innings, spread across three outings, Harrison has given up 23 hits and 17 earned runs. His ERA has climbed from 2.79 to 3.98 on the season, a jump of more than a run in just three games.
Milwaukee responded by trying to shift him to the bullpen. The idea was simple: shorten the outings, protect him a bit, and maybe help the stuff play up when he didn’t have to reach back for 80 to 100 pitches. But the first test didn’t go the way the Brewers wanted.
On Saturday against the Reds, Harrison entered in the 8th inning with the Brewers leading 13-5, a spot that should have been about as low-pressure as it gets. Instead, the outing fell apart fast.
His velocity was back in the 96-97 MPH range, but the command and movement still weren’t there. He left a couple of fastballs in the middle of the plate and got hit hard.
Four batters came up, and all four reached base before Pat Murphy pulled him.
Afterward, Murphy said he spoke directly to Harrison about it:
“Look, Harry, we’ll get this straight. This will happen.
You’re going through a rough patch, we’ll get it straight. I mean, he gave up two balls off the fist, he did give up two hard contacts with misplaced pitches, but we’ll get it straight.”
Murphy still believes Harrison can get through this, and pitchers do hit rough stretches. The problem is timing. With the postseason just two weeks away, the Brewers have to sort out their trust tree now, and every shaky arm makes that job harder.
That bullpen move also sends a clear message about how Milwaukee views Harrison right now. He is not being lined up as a length starter for October, and at this point, that doesn’t seem realistic anyway. It’s a huge change from how he looked earlier in the season.
Murphy didn’t rule out a number of explanations for the dip.
“It could point to a little bit of fatigue. It could be a delivery issue.
It’s hard. It’s very, very, very hard.
A basketball 3-point shooter, if all of a sudden he’s not hitting a shot, everybody goes into like ‘what is it?’ And then you find a little thing in the mechanics and maybe that’s really not it, but it’s an outgrowth of maybe a lack of confidence, and it affects your physical a little bit.
So I think you got to suggest some things, you got to work through some things, and he’s got to get himself through it.” Murphy said.
A trip to Triple-A does not appear to be in the cards. The minor league season is winding down, and Harrison is in a different spot than Brandon Sproat, who also struggled out of the bullpen as the Brewers searched for a way to make him useful. Murphy’s public confidence suggests Milwaukee plans to keep working with Harrison where he is.
For now, the likeliest path is more bullpen work, with the Brewers trying to find him low-leverage innings and some confidence-building chances while Bryse Wilson works his way back from a back strain. Another possibility would be shorter starts in tandem with someone like Chad Patrick, enough to cover around six innings between them.
Pitching coaches Chris Hook and Jim Henderson will keep trying to clean things up. Even if Harrison’s fastball never fully returns to what it was before the injury during this final stretch, the Brewers can still look for ways to mix and match his arsenal and get more out of him.
With two weeks left, that’s the task: find out how much they can trust him before October arrives. If he can’t prove that trust, Harrison could wind up left off the postseason roster(s).
In Other News...
Brewers Fans Had One Immediate Concern After Garrett Mitchells Early Exit
Garrett Mitchells early exit in the Brewers game against the Reds sent a ripple through the fan base almost immediately, but Pat Murphy said the center fielder was pulled as a precaution after his blood sugar got too high. Mitchell, who has Type 1 diabetes and wears an insulin pump during games, left after going 0-for-2 with a walk, and the explanation was enough to calm the first wave of concern around his availability.
For Milwaukee, the episode was a reminder of how carefully Mitchells situation has to be monitored even on a routine night in the middle of the schedule. Murphy also weighed in on the bullpen and the teams recent stretch of games, but the larger focus after Mitchells departure was simply making sure this was a health issue being managed the right way, not a setback that would linger. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Suddenly Have A Luis Lara Decision That Wont Go Away
Luis Laras extended look while Sal Frelick was sidelined gave the Brewers a better read on what he can offer, and it was more than just a placeholder run. Over 125 plate appearances, Lara hit .259/.328/.375, enough to keep him in the conversation as a useful piece even after Frelick returned. Since then, his role has shifted into something more platoon-based, with the Brewers splitting his chances nearly evenly against right- and left-handed pitchers in a way that is a little unusual for a switch-hitter.
Lara has still managed to keep his on-base percentage at .333 lately, helped along by coaching decisions and the defensive value he brings to the roster. The larger takeaway is that Milwaukee keeps leaning into a merit-based approach with both Lara and Frelick, which is good process but also leaves a tricky question hanging over how much runway Lara is really going to keep getting as the roster gets healthier and the games matter more. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Trade Is Already Raising Questions About Their Catching Bet
The Brewers catching picture has shifted again after their deal with Cleveland brought Bo Naylor into the organization, a move that immediately invited scrutiny because of what Milwaukee gave up to get him. Craig Yoho and Blake Perkins went to the Guardians, with Codi Heuer later flipped to Baltimore for cash, and the early returns have only sharpened the debate around whether the Brewers made the right bet at a position that has been hard to settle.
Yoho has been productive for Cleveland, which has only added to the sense that the Guardians came out ahead in the short term. Naylor, meanwhile, has logged only limited major league time in Milwaukee but has shown enough promise in Triple-A to keep the long view alive, leaving the Brewers to wait and see whether the trade starts looking different as his role grows. [Read more 🡒]