Brewers Suddenly Face A Tough Bo Naylor Decision

The Milwaukee Brewers face a perplexing decision as they weigh the financial implications and future potential of their talented trio of catchers.

The Brewers have a crowded catcher room, and that’s exactly why Bo Naylor’s name showing up on a non-tender list stands out.

Milwaukee already has William Contreras as the starter, with talk this offseason about a possible long-term extension still hanging out there, though nothing has been completed. Behind him, the Brewers also have 26-year-old former first-round pick Bo Naylor and No. 11 overall prospect Jeferson Quero. Quero was once Milwaukee’s top prospect before injuries slowed him down, but he’s still only 24.

That gives the Brewers a real surplus at the position. If Naylor wins the backup job in Spring Training, fine.

If Quero does, that works too. Either way, Milwaukee looks set up well for 2027 with two of those three in the majors and one in Triple-A.

Still, MLB Trade Rumors included Naylor among its surprise non-tender candidates, alongside Joey Bart, Nick Fortes, Rafael Marchan, Logan O’Hoppe and Connor Wong. That’s a head-turner, especially with Naylor’s projected arbitration salary coming in at just $1.5 million.

The case for keeping him is pretty straightforward. Naylor appeared in only three big league games for Milwaukee in 2026, going 2-for-7 with a homer and three RBIs. But he’s also a former first-round pick who hit at least 11 homers in each of three straight seasons from 2023 through 2025.

Even in 2025, when he hit just .195, he still posted 1.6 WAR. That matters, because one win above replacement is often valued at $8 million or more. In other words, even when the bat wasn’t carrying him, he was still helping.

Naylor also made an impact in Triple-A after Milwaukee acquired him, hitting .283/.353/.550 with a .903 OPS, four home runs, 17 RBIs and four doubles in 14 games. If he were on the market, he’d be the kind of low-cost upside play the Brewers would be wise to chase. But they already have him.

And with the Brewers having been granted a fourth option year for Quero, there isn’t much risk in keeping Naylor around. At that price, with that power and that kind of upside, there doesn’t seem to be much reason to non-tender him.

In Other News...

Brewers Just Made Their Priorities Clear With Two Key Players

The Brewers have drawn a pretty clear line as they sort through their long-term plans, and it starts with William Contreras. Milwaukee has made it known that the catcher is not available in trade talks, while also showing interest in working toward a contract extension that would keep him at the center of the roster for years to come. With his option already exercised for the 2027 season, the organization is treating him like more than just a core piece - he is part of the foundation.

Trevor Megill, on the other hand, appears to be in a different category. Milwaukee is open to trade discussions involving the closer, a sign that the front office is willing to listen if the right deal comes along. The contrast between the two players says plenty about where the Brewers see their priorities, with one being protected and the other at least available for conversation as the roster picture continues to take shape. [Read more 🡒]

Two Former Brewers Just Reopened A Hall Of Fame Debate

The 2027 Hall of Fame ballot has put a familiar Brewers connection back in the spotlight, with two former Milwaukee relievers now part of the conversation. Francisco Rodrguez, who spent time in Milwaukee and is back on the ballot for the fifth year, brings a rsum that includes 437 career saves and six All-Star selections, while Joakim Soria is making his first appearance after a long run as one of the games steadier late-inning arms.

For Brewers fans, it is a reminder of how much bullpen history can linger long after the final out. Rodrguez has already spent years trying to gain traction with voters, and Sorias debut adds another layer to the discussion because his career came with a different kind of profile but still plenty of closing experience, with 229 saves to his name. Whether either one can turn that recognition into a real Hall push is the question now hanging over the ballot. [Read more 🡒]

Brewers Have Three Silver Slugger Races Fans Will Be Watching Closely

The Brewers will have a few familiar names in the mix when the 2026 Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards are announced on Nov. 17, with Brice Turang, Jackson Chourio and Jake Bauers all earning nominations at their respective positions. For Milwaukee, it is another sign that the lineup has produced enough across the board to put multiple players in the conversation, and it gives fans a reason to keep one eye on the awards season while the offseason chatter continues.

What makes these races worth watching is how crowded they are, with each Brewer facing a legitimate challenge from players around the league. Turang, Chourio and Bauers all have cases, but none of them can assume anything with the announcement coming during FanSideds The Baseball Insiders podcast and YouTube show. For a team that has leaned on balanced production, the final verdict could offer one more snapshot of how Milwaukee stacks up against the rest of the National League and beyond. [Read more 🡒]