The Brewers built a 103-win season and a fourth straight NL Central title on strength everywhere, but this NLDS has already put their bullpen under the microscope. Milwaukee drew San Diego after finishing with the best record in Major League Baseball, and through two games the late innings have been a nervous ride. That matters now, because the Brewers already dropped four of six to the Padres in the regular season, and some of those losses traced back to relief work that usually isn’t a problem for this club.
Abner Uribe has been one of the game’s most dominant relievers this year, finishing with a 1.97 ERA, 62 strikeouts and a .199 opponent average over 61 outings and 59 1/3 innings. It was the second straight season he finished under 2.00, which is exactly why San Diego’s success against him stands out.
In two regular-season appearances against the Padres, Uribe posted a 13.50 ERA with two walks and two strikeouts in two innings, both outings coming in early May. One of them was fine; the other featured a go-ahead three-run homer.
Even then, he walked a batter in each appearance, something he only did 19 times during the regular season.
That pattern has carried into this series. In Games 1 and 2, Uribe hit a batter, walked another and allowed three hits, all of them hit hard.
The Brewers could point to shaky defense and a couple of tough calls, but the bigger picture is clear: Padres hitters have found a way to square him up. Milwaukee would love for him to be less central the rest of the way, or at least to see him against a different part of the order.
The top four hitters in San Diego’s usual alignment have already seen him twice.
Trevor Megill has been steadier, but he hasn’t been immune either. The closer put together another excellent season, finishing with a 2.63 ERA, a 0.89 WHIP, 69 strikeouts and 30 saves, tied for 10th-most in MLB and his second straight year reaching that mark. Against San Diego, though, he had one uneven regular-season outing that lines up with what happened late in Game 2.
Megill faced the Padres twice during the season and posted a 3.38 ERA with three strikeouts and one walk over 2 2/3 innings. On May 12, San Diego tagged him for a run on two hits in an outing that came before he had fully taken over as the club’s closer; he was setting up Uribe that day.
Fernando Tatis Jr. singled, Miguel Andujar doubled, and Ty France was among the three batters Megill struck out. He was much sharper in August, when he got five outs and kept the winning run from scoring in both the ninth and 10th innings.
Even then, he showed respect for Tatis by issuing an intentional walk in the middle of that appearance. In Sunday’s Game 2, Megill worked the top of the ninth and kept the Brewers within one, though Tatis still drove a ball to the left-field wall that Jackson Chourio caught.
For Milwaukee, the matchup problems aren’t everywhere, but they are concentrated in the wrong places. Megill’s stuff plays well against much of the Padres’ lineup, yet Tatis and France have both given him trouble.
Uribe has had an even harder time finding clean answers. That’s the uneasy truth for the Brewers: they’ve survived the late innings so far, but they haven’t solved the top half of San Diego’s order.
Aaron Ashby may be the swing piece. He held Padres hitters to a .286 average in two outings without allowing a run, and he looked the best of Milwaukee’s three key relievers in the first part of the NLDS, though he worked with the advantage of seeing the bottom of the lineup and several left-handed bats. Even so, he’s a lefty, which brings its own danger against hitters like Tatis, Manny Machado and France.
If this series turns on one thing, it may be whether Milwaukee’s relievers can keep getting outs in the tight, late-game spots that decide October games. Uribe and Megill have both shown they can be vulnerable to this Padres lineup, and the evidence is fresh. Ashby could be the difference as the Brewers try to finish the job and reach the NLCS for a second straight year.
In Other News...
Brewers Fans Know Front Row Amy But Not The Full Story
For more than a decade, Brewers fans have been able to spot the same familiar face behind home plate at American Family Field. Front Row Amy has become part of the game-day scenery in Milwaukee, usually in Row 1, seat 5 of section 117, where she has shown up for most home games since 2007 with a scorebook in hand and a regular seat in the spotlight.
Her real name is Amy Williams, and her steady presence has made her one of the most recognizable super fans in baseball. She has often attended games alone, turning a personal routine into something the fan base now treats as a tradition, and her place in Brewers lore was cemented further when the National Bobblehead Hall of Fame honored her with a custom bobblehead. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Are One Win Away With One Big Game 3 Concern
The Brewers head to San Diego for Game 3 of the National League Division Series with a commanding 2-0 lead after rallying in both of the first two games. After twice finding a way to win from behind, Milwaukee now has a chance to finish the job on the road, but the margin for error gets thinner in a playoff series that has already featured plenty of tense innings and heavy bullpen use.
Before the first pitch, the focus turns to the starting lineups, the pitching matchup and how much each bullpen has already been asked to carry. For Milwaukee, the concern is less about where the series stands and more about whether the arms left available can keep holding up long enough to close out a Padres team that still has a home crowd and plenty of fight left. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Just Got A New NLDS Concern As Series Shifts Home
The Brewers cushion in the NLDS just got a little less comfortable as the series shifts to Milwaukee, with San Diego restoring right-hander Walker Buehler to its active roster for Game 3. Buehler had been away on the paternity list since before Game 1, and his return gives the Padres another experienced arm to lean on as they try to steady the matchup at a crucial point.
Nick Pivetta is set to start Game 3 for San Diego, but Buehlers availability adds another layer of intrigue for a Brewers club heading home with plenty still to sort out. If the series stretches further, the Padres now have a clearer path to mixing and matching on the pitching side, which is exactly the kind of wrinkle that can matter this time of year. [Read more 🡒]