Dustin May’s latest outing only added to the uncertainty hanging over Milwaukee’s postseason rotation, and the Brewers now have one more decision to sort through before October arrives.
Since coming over from the St. Louis Cardinals with JoJo Romero ahead of last month’s trade deadline, the 29-year-old right-hander has been a study in extremes. There have been starts that looked exactly like the Brewers hoped for, and others that made it hard to picture him taking the ball in a critical playoff game.
His Brewers debut was a good place to start. Against the Pittsburgh Pirates, May worked six innings, allowed just three hits and was tagged with three walks, but still turned in a quality start and helped Milwaukee to a 5-2 win. He backed that up with one of his best showings in a Brewers uniform, holding the San Diego Padres to one run over seven innings.
Then the wheels came off.
In an August 19 start against the Seattle Mariners at American Family Field, May was charged with seven earned runs and didn’t get through the third inning. The next week, he took a comebacker off the first pitch of a start against the New York Mets. Four days later, he was back on the mound and again couldn’t provide length, finishing with just 4.1 innings against the Texas Rangers while giving up six hits and four earned runs.
There were signs of a reset in September. An outing against the Cincinnati Reds on September 5 was interrupted by a rain delay, but six days later May went right back out and blanked the same lineup over six innings. That start, combined with Kyle Harrison’s recent struggles, had some Brewers fans thinking May could settle in as a workable No. 3 starter behind Jacob Misiorowski and Logan Henderson.
Last night against the Baltimore Orioles, though, the questions came right back.
The raw numbers since Milwaukee acquired him on August 3 are rough. In eight starts, May has a 5.40 ERA and has allowed an opponent OPS of .789. That’s the kind of line that makes it easy to understand why Brewers fans are uneasy about handing him a big October assignment.
Still, the stuff hasn’t disappeared.
May has said in postgame interviews that he feels good, that his pitches are doing what he wants, and that the results simply haven’t followed. The underlying numbers support that view, with the movement and velocity on his six-pitch mix still looking strong since the trade.
What has changed most is how often he’s throwing certain pitches. In line with Milwaukee’s preference for multiple fastball shapes, May has leaned much harder on his cutter and sinker than he did before the trade, while using his four-seamer less often.
That shift may not explain everything, but it’s hard to ignore that the cutter has produced the highest opponent batting average and opponent slugging percentage of any pitch in his arsenal. It can work against lefties, but right-handed hitters have done damage with it too, including Pete Alonso, who hit a three-run homer on one of May’s cutters last night.
That’s why May remains such a tricky case for Milwaukee. The ceiling is obvious, and the Brewers have already seen enough flashes to know the upside is real.
His postseason experience matters, especially on a pitching staff that doesn’t have much of it. He may not end up functioning as a true starter in the playoffs, but he looks like a lock to be part of the postseason roster.
For now, the Brewers are left hoping May can deliver one more strong regular-season start and calm some of the noise around the rotation before October.
In Other News...
Christian Yelich Keeps Giving Brewers Fans Another Reason To Love Him
Christian Yelich keeps finding ways to matter to the Brewers beyond what he does in the batters box. This week, he was named Milwaukees nominee for the Roberto Clemente Award for the second time in four seasons, a recognition that goes to players whose work in the community reflects the legacy of Clemente and his lifelong commitment to service.
Yelichs resume off the field has only deepened his standing with fans in Milwaukee, where he has backed military veterans, youth baseball and programs focused on childrens health and education. For a player already central to the Brewers identity, it is another reminder that his influence around the organization stretches well beyond the lineup card. [Read more 🡒]
Pat Murphy Sends A Clear Message With Brewers Lineup Choice
The Brewers are back in action this afternoon for the second game of their series against the Orioles, and Pat Murphys lineup gives a pretty clear read on where his priorities are in the middle of a long season. With left-hander Robert Gasser on the mound for Milwaukee and Trevor Rogers set to start for Baltimore, the Brewers are leaning into a different look than the one fans might expect, with several regulars getting the day off.
It is the kind of move that can say plenty without anyone needing to explain it, especially with first pitch set for 3:05 p.m. and the game available on Brewers.TV, WTMJ 620 and the Brewers Radio Network. For a club trying to balance the grind of the schedule with the demands of staying fresh, Murphys lineup choice suggests there is a bigger picture in mind, even if the immediate question is how the Brewers will piece together this one. [Read more 🡒]
Christian Yelich Is At The Center Of A Huge Brewers Debate
Christian Yelich has been at the heart of the Brewers rise for nearly a decade now, ever since Milwaukee landed him from Miami in a four-player trade on Jan. 25, 2018. The move changed the shape of the franchise almost immediately. Yelich became one of the teams defining players, won the National League MVP award in 2018, and helped lead Milwaukee to the playoffs eight times in nine seasons, giving the Brewers a steady centerpiece through a long stretch of contention.
Even with all that production, the conversation around Yelich is no longer just about what he has done in the past. Injuries have interrupted parts of his run, and that has made his place in the Brewers present and future a more complicated debate than it once seemed. For a team that has leaned on him so heavily, the question is how much more he can still provide, and how Milwaukee chooses to weigh the star power, the durability concerns and everything he has already meant to the organization. [Read more 🡒]