The Brewers have spent this season surviving on a pitching staff that should have run out of answers a long time ago. Instead, they’re still here, still throwing strikes, still tracking down wins with a rotation that has been constantly reshaped by departures, injuries and innings piling up on the wrong arms.
That starts with what Milwaukee lost from 2025. By innings pitched, the top three hurlers were Freddy Peralta, Quinn Priester and Jose Quintana.
Those three logged 465 2/3 regular-season innings, then added 25 more across the club’s two playoff series. That was nearly a third of the entire staff’s workload from last year, and then the group changed fast.
Quintana walked in free agency, the Brewers traded Peralta to the New York Mets, and Priester never really got a chance to fill the hole because thoracic outlet syndrome ended his season before it began. One departure was passive, one was intentional, one was just bad luck.
Either way, replacing that much volume was always going to be a problem.
Early on, Milwaukee found temporary fixes. Jacob Misiorowski emerged as the ace.
Kyle Harrison, Chad Patrick and Brandon Sproat all had stretches where they looked like they could help replace the innings that disappeared. Together, that trio threw 318 2/3 innings this season, with most of that work coming before the All-Star break.
They piled up 239 innings before the break, about 28% of the team’s total, and then less than 80 after it. None of them has appeared in a postseason game.
The Brewers have been forced to turn over a huge chunk of their pitching workload even over the last three months.
Then the staff got thinner. Logan Henderson stepped in after injuries and poor performances opened a lane, and he has grown into the real No. 2 behind Misiorowski.
But the workload is the part that should have the alarm bells ringing. Last season, Misiorowski threw 141 1/3 innings at every level, including the playoffs.
This year he’s up to 183 and counting. Henderson went from 103 innings last year to 131 1/3 already.
Milwaukee’s two most important starters are well beyond their previous career highs.
And that’s only part of it. The Brewers also poured resources into acquiring Ángel Zerpa, only to lose him to Tommy John surgery early in the season.
Jared Koenig pitched through major elbow trouble and eventually fell out of the mix. Brandon Woodruff got $22.025 million and returned just 45 1/3 innings.
It has been one hit after another for a team trying to patch together a staff on the fly.
And yet the run prevention has held up. Milwaukee finished the regular season with the fourth-fewest runs allowed per game in the league.
Some of that came from defense, and some of it came from the first-half production of Harrison and Woodruff, but the bigger point is that the Brewers were asking a lot from pitchers who were barely on the depth chart in the spring. On paper, that should have caught up with them.
A staff leaning this hard on young arms and overextended starters should be scrambling by now.
Instead, Milwaukee handled the stretch run with unusual care. With a cushion in the standings, the Brewers still pushed for a first-round bye and home-field advantage, but they managed Misiorowski and Henderson as carefully as possible.
Misiorowski has made 31 starts this season, including his two postseason outings. Only four of those came on four days’ rest, and one of them was a planned abbreviated September outing built to get him ready for a possible short-rest assignment in Games 1 and 5 of a best-of-seven series.
More than half of his starts came on five days’ rest, and eight came on six. That slower schedule helped keep him fresh and slowed the rise in innings.
Henderson got the same treatment. He has made 27 starts, with just 16 coming on five days of rest or fewer.
He has started on six days’ rest five times and on seven or more days’ rest five more times, not counting his first rehab start after spending more than a month on the injured list in midseason. That approach has also kept Robert Gasser and Shane Drohan reasonably fresh.
The scheduling break has mattered in the postseason, too. Winning the first two series in four games gave Milwaukee extra rest and let the bullpen absorb more of the innings the team still had to cover.
There are only about 60 innings left, seven dates left on the calendar, three more days before the first one, and two off days in the mix. The Brewers have already dodged a lot of what should have crushed them.
They lost the pitchers who threw 500 innings for them last year. They’ve shelved the pitchers who gave them 320 this year.
They’re down to no more than 10 trustworthy arms, and most nights they’re trying to get from Pitch No. 1 to Out No. 27 with five or fewer. Even so, they’ve allowed only 21 runs in eight playoff games.
They shouldn’t have had enough pitching to get this far, but they do now. Four more wins, and they’ll have more than enough to finish the job.
In Other News...
Brewers Just Got A World Series Break They Desperately Needed
After sweeping the Dodgers to clinch a spot in the World Series for the first time in 44 years, Milwaukee can finally exhale for a moment. This has been a season built on pitching depth and relentless run prevention, with Jacob Misiorowski giving the staff an edge even if he has not been asked to go deep in October games.
The bigger benefit now may come from the calendar. A few extra days before the World Series should help a bullpen that has carried a heavy workload through the playoffs, with Abner Uribe, Aaron Ashby and Trevor Megill all taking on a lot of responsibility along the way. For a team that has leaned so hard on its arms, the pause could be just as valuable as any on-field adjustment. [Read more 🡒]
White Sox Fans Have A Familiar Reason To Watch Milwaukee Now
Andrew Vaughns move from the White Sox to the Brewers has turned into the kind of second act both sides can file away for different reasons. Milwaukee gave him a fresh start last season, and he has settled in with better on-base production and more consistent overall value since the trade, the sort of steady improvement that makes a lineup look deeper and a front office feel better about the deal.
For White Sox fans, the familiarity only goes so far from here. Chicago now has Munetaka Murakami at first base, and the club is not expected to chase Vaughn once he reaches free agency, so the path back never really looks like its opening. In the meantime, his progress in Milwaukee stands as another reminder that a change of scenery can matter just as much as raw talent. [Read more 🡒]
Aaron Ashby Is Giving The Brewers An October Weapon Few Teams Ever Find
Aaron Ashby has turned into one of those October arms managers dream about but almost never find. The Brewers left-hander has delivered multiple scoreless, multi-inning relief outings in their postseason run, helping steady games in both the NLDS and the NLCS while pushing his name into a conversation usually reserved for elite playoff relievers. The company is notable too, with Ashby drawing comparisons to the kind of postseason weaponry associated with Bruce Sutter, Goose Gossage, Andrew Miller and Yusmeiro Petit.
For Milwaukee, the bigger point is what Ashby has meant in the moment: every time he has taken the ball this postseason, the Brewers have won. In an October shaped by thin margins and short benches, having a pitcher who can cover more than an inning and still miss bats has given the club a valuable edge, and it has raised the question of just how deep this run can go if he keeps being available in the biggest spots. [Read more 🡒]