Brewers Prospects Just Drew A Clear Fall League Divide

Young Brewers prospects showcase talent and face challenges in eventful Arizona Fall League stint.

The Brewers’ group in the 2026 Arizona Fall League came with a little bit of everything: power, speed, promise, and more than a few command issues. Some prospects used the Scottsdale Scorpions stage to reinforce what they’d already shown during the season. Others left with the same question hanging over them - can they throw enough strikes?

Jett Williams was one of the most interesting bats in the bunch, even if the average didn’t pop. Coming off the final three months of the season lost to a right wrist injury, he hit .217 (15-for-69).

But that line only tells part of the story. Five of those hits went for extra bases, including a home run, two doubles, and two triples.

He also swiped 12 bags and drew 16 walks against 19 strikeouts. Among Brewers prospects in Scottsdale, only Bitonti came close to matching his 69 at-bats.

Bitonti, fresh off a breakout 2026 season that included a .916 OPS at High-A Wisconsin, kept flashing the kind of power that has the Brewers intrigued. He posted a .757 OPS in 65 at-bats and even earned a spot in the AFL Home Run Derby. The swing-and-miss is still part of the package - 26 strikeouts against 10 walks is not ideal - but the raw pop is very much real.

Matthew Wood also carried his breakout momentum into the fall. He went 12-for-43 with four doubles and finished with an .828 OPS, the best mark of any Scorpion with at least 40 at-bats.

He’ll be 26 on Opening Day and is expected to start 2027 in Triple-A, though the path to Milwaukee may not be far off. With uncertainty behind starting catcher William Contreras, Wood could get a big-league look before the year ends.

Braylon Payne turned in one of the more eye-catching seasons in the system, and his AFL stint added a few more flashes. He went 7-for-35 with two triples.

That came after a regular season in which he put up a 25-homer, 25-steal campaign, making him the fourth-youngest minor leaguer to reach that mark since 1946. The 16 strikeouts in Scottsdale are a concern, especially since the assignment was likely meant to sharpen his bat-to-ball skills, but a 35-at-bat sample doesn’t erase the ceiling he showed all year.

On the pitching side, Miqueas Mercedes probably helped himself the most. The 20-year-old, who won’t turn 21 until next July, logged a 3.52 ERA over 15 1/3 innings, giving up 10 hits and striking out 19.

The issue was the same one that followed him through the regular season: walks. He issued 15 of them in the AFL.

Still, the stuff clearly played.

Peyton Niksch opened well enough after finishing the season at Double-A Biloxi, allowing just two earned runs over his first 6 2/3 innings. After that, things got rough.

He ended the fall with 16 earned runs allowed on 18 hits in 15 2/3 innings. The strikeouts were there - 16 of them, about one per inning - but so were the free passes, as he walked eight.

Ryan Birchard’s fall was even bumpier. He gave up three earned runs over his first three outings, covering 3 2/3 innings, and two of those appearances were hitless and scoreless.

Then the wheels came off. In his final two outings, he recorded just four outs and was tagged for 10 earned runs.

Command was the problem throughout: 12 walks against seven strikeouts. For a pitcher who walked nearly a quarter of the batters he faced this season, that’s not the kind of line the Brewers wanted to see.

Joshua Quezada worked strictly out of the bullpen and finished with a 7.27 ERA in eight appearances, covering 8 2/3 innings. He allowed 10 hits, walked five, and struck out 12, while also picking up one save in two chances. The ERA isn’t pretty, but the strikeout total stands out in a league that can be rough on pitchers.

José Meneses rounded out the group with a mixed bag of results. The left-handed long reliever held hitters to a .174 average and struck out 11 in six innings.

But the walks piled up - seven of them - and that helped lead to seven runs, four earned, on just four hits for a 6.00 ERA. Even so, he had a strong 2026 overall, posting a 1.88 ERA with Single-A Wilson before moving up to High-A Wisconsin.

If the command sharpens, the swing-and-miss ability gives him a real shot at a big-league bullpen.

In Other News...

Brewers Just Bet On A Former Shutdown Arm To Bounce Back

The Brewers added a familiar kind of bullpen gamble by acquiring right-hander Ryan Walker from the Giants, sending minor league pitchers Blake Holub and Gavin Perry back to San Francisco. Milwaukee confirmed the move after it was first reported by an MLB insider, and the fit is obvious enough: a reliever with late-inning experience and the kind of track record that suggests there is still something to reclaim.

Walker arrives in Milwaukee after a strong 2024 season, though his 2026 results were far less encouraging. For a Brewers club that has long valued bullpen depth and the ability to turn around pitchers with usable stuff, the bet is simple enough on paper, even if the real payoff will depend on whether Walker can rediscover the form that once made him such a dependable arm. [Read more 🡒]

Kyle Harrison Suddenly Gives Brewers A Real 2027 Rotation Question

Kyle Harrison arrived in Milwaukee with the kind of upside that can change a staffs long-term outlook, and for a while in 2026 he looked every bit like that kind of addition. After coming over from the Red Sox, he gave the Brewers a strong start to the season as a starter, flashing the sort of early results that made him look like more than just a short-term fix for a contending club.

Then the forearm injury interrupted the momentum, and the rest of the year never quite matched the opening stretch. Harrison still finished with a 4.20 ERA and was on the postseason roster for Milwaukees World Series run, even if he never got into a game, which leaves the Brewers with a familiar kind of winter question: how much of his early promise was the real version, and how much of his 2026 season was shaped by what came after the injury? [Read more 🡒]

Cubs Face A Tough Dustin May Decision In Crowded Market

Dustin Mays path into free agency opened after the Brewers declined his mutual option, and he has remained unsigned as the market around him continues to take shape. Even with a recent run of starts that produced a high ERA, the right-hander is still being viewed as a young starter with upside, which helps explain why so many clubs have stayed in the mix.

The Cubs are among the teams linked to May, but they are hardly alone, with the Nationals, Orioles, Giants, Reds, Guardians, Marlins, White Sox and Blue Jays also showing interest. For Milwaukee, the situation is another reminder of how quickly a pitcher with talent can become a sought-after name once the contract piece is stripped away, and how crowded the chase can get when clubs are hunting for rotation help. [Read more 🡒]