Tarik Skubal’s path to free agency has only gotten murkier, and the latest rumors are making the trade deadline story look a lot different than it did a few months ago.
On Wednesday night, Cam Schlittler of the New York Yankees became the American League’s new Cy Young Award winner, taking the honor unanimously and ending Skubal’s run at the top. Skubal won the award with the Detroit Tigers in both 2024 and 2025, but this year he was out of the race in part because he spent half the season in the National League. Even so, the soon-to-be 30-year-old left-hander is heading into his first trip through free agency with a résumé that includes multiple Cy Young Awards, an ERA title, a Triple Crown, and multiple All-Star selections.
That kind of track record comes with a price tag, and Skubal’s market is expected to be a narrow one. The Los Angeles Dodgers were long viewed as the obvious favorite, especially after reports that Skubal wanted to be there all along. But early free agency buzz now points to the New York Mets as the clear front-runners, and that has cast new doubt on the version of events that shaped the trade deadline.
Back then, Skubal, a California native, was said to prefer Los Angeles both now and down the road. He had no say in Detroit’s final call, but some around the situation believed the Tigers felt pressure to respect that preference. That idea helped explain why they accepted a package of outfielder Zyhir Hope and right-handed pitchers River Ryan and Brady Smith.
Milwaukee was believed to be right behind Los Angeles in the chase. Jeff Passan of ESPN reported that the Brewers had multiple offers on the table, with combinations that included infielder Luis Peña, outfielders Josh Adamczewski and Alexander Frias, and utility player Jett Williams.
Those names didn’t match the controllable pitcher Detroit was reportedly after, but the value was still significant enough that it was hard to dismiss. So when the Tigers moved quickly on the Dodgers’ offer, it naturally fueled the belief that Skubal’s stated preference had helped tilt the deal.
Now that the Mets are being described as the early favorites to sign him, that whole narrative looks shaky. It could simply be Scott Boras doing what Scott Boras does and keeping the field open, especially with teams like the Mets able to spend at a level most clubs can’t. But if Skubal truly saw the Dodgers as his long-term destination, it would make sense for both sides to already be moving toward a deal before the looming work stoppage and possible changes to the Collective Bargaining Agreement.
The bigger question now is whether the Dodgers talk was ever as firm as it sounded. The latest rumors suggest it may not have been, and that the idea Detroit traded him to Los Angeles to honor his wishes might have been overstated.
There’s also another angle here: maybe the Dodgers talk was part of a broader strategy to avoid a smaller market like Milwaukee, where less media exposure before free agency could have affected his visibility and earning power. Either way, the Brewers can look back on the deadline and feel good about how it turned out. They kept Logan Henderson under contract for the next five years, still have Luis Peña in the farm system, and retained a deep group of promising bats in the minors.
Even so, the image of Skubal going to the Dodgers had a way of feeling inevitable at the time. Now, with those free agency rumors in the mix, one of the main reasons behind Detroit’s apparent lean toward Los Angeles doesn’t look nearly as solid as it once did.
In Other News...
Brewers Leave GM Meetings With Roster Questions Already Building
The GM Meetings in Las Vegas gave the Brewers a little bit of everything, from roster chatter to a few organizational wins. Jake Bauers moved on to Boston after declining Milwaukees qualifying offer, which at least leaves the club with a compensatory draft pick, while the front office also picked up some good news on the developmental side when Jeferson Quero was granted a fourth option year and can stay in the minors for another season.
Still, the bigger conversation around Milwaukee followed Matt Arnold around the meetings, where trade speculation kept circling around Trevor Megill and William Contreras. The Brewers also had plenty to celebrate on the awards front, with Pat Murphy taking home NL Manager of the Year and Jacob Misiorowski earning the NL Cy Young award, but the offseason questions are already piling up as the club tries to sort out what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Face A Big Bullpen Question As Yankees Search For Help
The Yankees have already made clear that bullpen help is near the top of their offseason to-do list, and their latest move only reinforces that priority. After extending a qualifying offer to free agent closer David Bednar, New York is still weighing ways to shore up the late innings, with general manager Brian Cashman openly focused on improving that part of the roster.
One possible path that has surfaced is a trade idea involving Brewers closer Trevor Megill, who would give the Yankees a cost-effective alternative if they decide not to bring Bednar back. Nothing has been finalized, of course, but the speculation alone is enough to put Milwaukee back in the middle of a familiar winter conversation: how much value the Brewers can keep in the bullpen, and whether a contender comes calling with a deal that makes sense. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Offseason Spotlight Just Shifted To One Uncomfortable Question
The Brewers spent part of the offseason celebrating a haul of individual honors, but the conversation around the roster quickly turned to a more uncomfortable topic. Matt Arnold addressed questions about William Contreras trade status, stressing how important the catcher remains to Milwaukee without offering any clarity on whether the front office is considering moving him.
The uncertainty lands against a backdrop of plenty of good news for the organization. Pat Murphy won his third straight National League Manager of the Year Award while recovering from hip surgery, Jacob Misiorowski took the NL Cy Young Award unanimously, and Brice Turang and Jackson Chourio joined him on the All-MLB First Team. Contreras was recognized on the Second Team, which only underscores why his name carries so much weight whenever the Brewers offseason plans come up. [Read more 🡒]