The Milwaukee Brewers and Cleveland Guardians pulled off a 2-for-2 swap Saturday morning, with each club using a surplus to patch a hole.
Cleveland sent catcher Bo Naylor and reliever Matt Heuer to Milwaukee for outfielder Blake Perkins and pitcher Cameron Yoho in a deal that fits the shape of both rosters. The Guardians had already made Patrick Bailey’s addition, which made Naylor expendable, and they used the opportunity to address an outfield group that has been a problem. The Brewers, meanwhile, have more outfielders than places to put them and are already looking ahead to life after William Contreras, who is a free agent after 2027.
For Cleveland, the outfield has been a real weakness. The Guardians’ outfielders rank 25th in batting average at .234, 25th in on-base percentage at .305, 30th in slugging at .357, and 30th in home runs with 28. Even with Steven Kwan’s +6 outs above average, the group sits at just +3 OAA overall.
Perkins isn’t a headline name, but he brings exactly what Cleveland needed. He’s viewed as a strong center field defender and a switch-hitter who does most of his damage from the right side. The 29-year-old has been roughly league average against lefties this season and over his career, which matters in a market where right-handed outfield help is hard to find.
Here are his career splits:
vs. RHP vs. LHP
AVG
.208
.249
OBP
.298
.321
SLG
.304
.372
Kwan has made 47 starts in center field this season, his first there since his rookie year in 2022. Otherwise, the Guardians have leaned on Angel Martínez, Daniel Schneemann and Petey Halpin. In that mix, Perkins gives them a clearer answer both offensively against lefties and defensively.
Yoho is a 26-year-old reliever whose game is built on movement more than power. His sinker, changeup and four-seamer all run to his armside, and even his cutter doesn’t move much against lefties. The changeup is the standout pitch, sitting around 80 mph and diving out of the zone for plenty of swing-and-miss.
He’s held back by average fastball velocity and below-average command, but both Milwaukee and Cleveland have strong track records with pitcher development. There’s at least some hope a new environment helps him find a role.
For Cleveland, the appeal is obvious: Perkins gives them 3 ½ years of control, while Yoho comes with six years, though reliever control is always a tricky thing to bank on. Still, for a pair of spare parts in Naylor and Heuer, the Guardians came away with a trade that makes sense. Cleveland gets a B.
Milwaukee’s side is a little harder to read, and not just because Naylor has yet to put it all together. The 26-year-old, Josh’s younger brother, broke through in 2023 with a .237/.339/.470 line, but since then he’s hit .192/.266/.351. After the Bailey move, he was pushed to Triple-A, where he has been solid at .224/.346/.436.
The underlying numbers offer some encouragement. Since 2024, Naylor’s 89.2 mph average exit velocity is right there with the MLB average of 88.8 mph. His 38.4% hard-hit rate is nearly identical to the league mark of 38.8%, and his 9.2% barrel rate is better than the 7.8% average.
The problem is what happens after contact. He pops the ball up too often, and those are basically automatic outs.
He also has trouble with harder velocity and with non-fastballs in general. Behind the plate, he’s been average at best as a blocker, thrower and framer.
Maybe there’s more in there. Maybe not.
The Brewers have earned trust when it comes to player development, and they’ve already shown they can get a bat pointed in the right direction, as they did with Andrew Vaughn last year. But that’s not the same as assuming every project turns into a success.
Heuer, 30, brings more injury baggage and less roster flexibility. He barely pitched from 2022 through 2024, throwing only 12 2/3 innings total in that span, all in 2023.
This year he’s bounced on and off the Triple-A shuttle. Like Yoho, his best pitch is a changeup, and both pitchers average around seven feet of extension down the mound.
Heuer also mixes in a slider and a mid-90s four-seamer.
The difference is that Yoho has one minor-league option left for next season, which gives Cleveland more freedom to move him up and down in 2027. Heuer is in his final option year, so he’ll need to stick on the MLB roster or pass through waivers next year. He’s older, has the rougher injury history and doesn’t offer the same flexibility.
Milwaukee has already sent Naylor to Triple-A, and barring injury, that’s where he figures to stay the rest of the season with Contreras and Gary Sánchez in place at the big-league level. Depending on when he gets called up, he’ll remain under team control through either 2029 or 2030. Heuer will be under control through 2028.
Both teams are smart enough to deserve the benefit of the doubt, but this deal still tilts toward Cleveland. Perkins fits the need more cleanly, and Yoho looks like the more interesting pitching piece. Milwaukee gets a C.
In Other News...
Jacob Misiorowski Sends A Message As Brewers Face Dodgers Pressure
The Brewers keep stacking wins at a pace that has put them in rare territory, and their latest victory over the Angels only added to the sense that this group has been built to withstand pressure. Through 110 games, Milwaukee owns the best record in franchise history, a milestone that has naturally sharpened the attention around the club as the playoff picture starts to come into focus.
Jacob Misiorowski is not backing away from the challenge, even with the Dodgers reshaping their roster by landing two-time AL Cy Young Award winner Tarik Skubal from the Tigers. The Brewers ace made it clear he believes Milwaukee can handle whatever name-brand talent gets thrown at it, a confidence that fits the way this team has carried itself all season and one that will be tested if the path eventually runs through Los Angeles. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Just Got A Brutal Deadline Twist In The NL Race
The deadline market shifted hard on Friday, and it did so in a way that could matter for Milwaukees National League race. While the Brewers made their own move earlier in the day, the bigger jolt came from national reports that the Dodgers were landing one of the most coveted arms available just ahead of the Aug. 3 deadline, adding even more weight to a postseason picture that already looked crowded.
For Milwaukee, the sting is less about what it did and more about what it did not do. The Brewers had been in the mix for upgrades, but this latest twist sends a reminder that the teams chasing the same October ceiling are not standing still, and Los Angeles reportedly paid three prospects to get the deal done. With the deadline clock still ticking, the pressure only grows for Milwaukee to answer back somehow. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Fans Will Have Strong Feelings About Freddy Peraltas New Trade
Freddy Peralta is on the move again, and this time the deal sends the two-time All-Star from the Mets to a Rays club that is trying to stay in the thick of the AL East race. Peralta never really found his footing in his first season in New York, but Tampa Bay is betting his arm still belongs in a rotation built to chase wins deep into the summer.
For Brewers fans, any Peralta trade news is bound to sting a little more than most. He was one of the more familiar high-end arms in the organization not that long ago, and seeing him continue his career elsewhere keeps his name tied to a familiar question around Milwaukee: what kind of pitcher might he look like once he settles in somewhere again? [Read more 🡒]