The Cubs added another trophy to the case last night, but the Silver Slugger haul also put a spotlight on the same problem that has been hanging over their offseason all along: the pitching staff needs a rebuild.
At the Louisville Slugger Silver Slugger Awards show, aired exclusively on FanSided’s own "The Baseball Insiders" podcast and YouTube show, the Cubs came away with three honors. Alex Bregman won at third base, Pete Crow-Armstrong took center field, and Chicago also claimed the Team Silver Slugger Award. That came on top of the team’s Gold Glove success earlier in awards season, when Bregman and Crow-Armstrong each won individual Gold Gloves and the Cubs grabbed the NL Team Gold Glove Award.
The hardware pile is real. So is the gap in the standings. Chicago finished 14 games behind the 103-win, World Series champion Brewers, even after a season that also saw Crow-Armstrong dethrone Shohei Ohtani in the NL MVP race, with Brice Turang finishing as the third finalist.
The Brewers’ awards run has been just as strong. Jake Bauers and Jackson Chourio both won their first Silver Sluggers this year, with Chourio earning his as an outfielder and Bauers taking the utility spot. That followed Gold Gloves for Chourio and Turang, Pat Murphy’s record-breaking third straight Manager of the Year Award, and Jacob Misiorowski being named the 2026 NL Cy Young.
For Chicago, though, the awards only underline what the numbers already said. The Cubs had the best defense in baseball, yet their team ERA still sat at 4.12, good for 14th in MLB.
Their 4.60 FIP was even less flattering, ranking 25th. In other words, the gloves were elite, but the pitching didn’t hold up its end.
That’s where the offseason pressure lands. A majority of the arms on the Cubs’ 2026 staff were free agents at season’s end, and seven multi-inning pitchers from the Wild Card Series roster are now on the market: Kevin Gausman, Matthew Boyd, David Peterson, Clay Holmes, Shota Imanaga, Colin Rea, and Aaron Civale.
Chicago has work to do, and not just in the rotation. The Cubs also lost Seiya Suzuki and Ian Happ to free agency, leaving the outfield picture unsettled as well. If the front office chooses not to bring either bat back and instead leans on internal options, Matt Shaw, Justin Dean, Pedro Ramírez, and Kevin Alcántara are all candidates to fill a corner outfield spot.
The problem is that pitching has to come first. The Cubs were already staring at a 14-win gap to the Brewers, and now they have to figure out how to replace a large chunk of their staff while also covering innings.
Free agency offers options, but the need for volume could make it harder to land top-end quality. A trade route is possible too, just as Chicago used at the deadline in August.
The trophies are nice. They also make the offseason assignment pretty clear: the Cubs have to reconstruct their pitching staff.
In Other News...
Brewers Just Sent A Clear Signal About Jett Williams Future
The Brewers used the Rule 5 Draft deadline to protect a sizable chunk of their young talent, adding six players to the 40-man roster and making sure Jett Williams was among them. Williams, ranked as Milwaukees No. 10 prospect, has dealt with injuries along the way, but the organization still views him as an important part of its long-term infield picture.
Along with Williams, the Brewers also selected Luke Adams, Dylan ORae, Matt Wood, Tate Kuehner and Cameron Wagoner for roster protection. It was a clear sign that Milwaukee did not want to risk losing any of that group, and Williams inclusion stands out as one of the more telling moves in the bunch given both his upside and the questions that have followed him. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Trade Buzz Just Put Two Crucial Roster Decisions In Focus
The Brewers are once again in a familiar spot as the market starts sorting itself out around the roster. Trevor Megill and William Contreras are both drawing trade interest as they enter walk years, which puts Milwaukee in the middle of two very different kinds of decisions: one involving a late-inning arm, the other involving a catcher who has become central to the clubs plans.
Contreras still looks like the likelier long-term piece, with the possibility of an extension keeping him in Milwaukee beyond this season. Megill is the name that feels more movable, especially given the Brewers recent tendency to deal pitchers before they reach free agency. If that path is taken, the bullpen has internal options to absorb the loss, and the club could also look outside the organization for help. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Could Still Gain More From One Departure Than Fans Realize
The qualifying-offer market is already starting to sort itself out, and for teams like the Brewers, the ripple effects can matter just as much as the names attached to them. Around the league, eight players received offers this cycle, with two choosing to accept and head back to their clubs for 2027, while the rest are moving on into free agency and setting up the usual compensation questions that follow.
For Milwaukee, that part of the process is worth watching closely because the draft-pick side of the equation can quietly shape how much value a departure really creates. The rules around teams losing or signing players who declined qualifying offers can be a real factor in roster building, and the Brewers could still end up benefiting more from the system than fans might first assume. [Read more 🡒]
