Brewers Have A Rotation Opening That Could Spark A Real Spring Battle

With the departure of Dustin May, the Brewers are eyeing internal talent to fortify their starting rotation for the 2027 season.

The Brewers don’t have to go shopping to patch the hole Dustin May left behind.

With May gone after signing a three-year deal with the Chicago White Sox, Milwaukee suddenly has a vacancy in its 2027 rotation. But the way this front office tends to operate, the answer probably isn’t a splashy free-agent signing or a trade. It’s more likely to come from inside the building.

The projected group already includes Jacob Misiorowski, Logan Henderson, Kyle Harrison, and Robert Gasser. That still leaves one spot open, and the Brewers do have names lined up to compete for it.

Quinn Priester stands out first. He was a successful reclamation project for Milwaukee in 2025, but he didn’t pitch in 2026 after dealing with thoracic outlet syndrome in Spring Training.

When the issue didn’t improve, he went ahead with surgery. Priester remains the most established internal option, though the arm injury means he could be under innings and pitch-count restrictions for much of 2027.

Even so, he logged 157.1 innings in 2025, so he has already shown he can handle a starter’s workload.

After Priester, the next wave gets a little less certain. Left-hander Shane Drohan put together a decent 2026 season, posting a 4.19 ERA and 3.73 FIP across 124.2 innings. The underlying numbers point toward another shot in the rotation.

Brandon Sproat is more of a bet on upside, but the rookie right-hander had a rough 2026. One of the two players Milwaukee got for Freddy Peralta, Sproat struggled through a 5.57 ERA even while getting repeated chances because of injuries elsewhere in the staff. His year ended with a demotion to Nashville, and he was left off the postseason roster.

There are also Coleman Crow and Garrett Stallings, though both look more like depth than real answers unless things go sideways. Crow posted a 5.30 ERA in his rookie season and finished in Triple-A once the rotation got healthy. Stallings bounced between roles and was mostly used for multi-inning relief work.

That gives Milwaukee five possible starters for the spot May vacated, which may be enough to keep the front office from rushing into anything. If the Brewers do make outside moves, they may be more likely to focus on the bullpen or on replacing Jake Bauers in the lineup. And if the rotation needs another fix later, the trade deadline could be the place to do it.

In Other News...

Two Former Brewers Just Reopened A Hall Of Fame Debate

The 2027 Hall of Fame ballot has brought an old Brewers conversation back into focus, with two former Milwaukee relievers now in the mix at the same time. Francisco Rodrguez, who spent part of his career in Milwaukee, is back on the ballot for the fifth year, carrying a rsum built around 437 saves and six All-Star selections, while Joakim Soria is making his first appearance after a long career that produced 229 saves.

For Brewers fans, it is a reminder of how much late-inning history has passed through Milwaukee, even if the Hall of Fame case for relievers has always been a tricky one. Rodrguez has the stronger statistical argument and the longer ballot runway, while Soria enters as a fresh name whose candidacy will be judged against a different standard, leaving the larger question of how voters weigh elite closers unresolved for now. [Read more 🡒]

White Sox Are Betting Big On Dustin May For One Reason

The White Sox are taking a sizable swing on Dustin May, agreeing to a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the right-hander after he declined a mutual option with the Brewers. May, 29, heads to Chicago as a rotation addition with a track record that has long made evaluators believe there is more upside there than the injury history alone would suggest.

For Milwaukee, it closes the book on a pitcher who helped the club during its 2026 World Series run and gave the Brewers a look at the kind of arsenal that can still play in a big league rotation when he is right. Chicago is betting that the mix is worth the risk, and the real question now is how quickly May can settle in and give the White Sox the stability they are paying for. [Read more 🡒]

Tarik Skubal Debate Just Took An Unexpected Turn For Contenders

The Brewers were already in the mix once for Tarik Skubal before the Dodgers stepped in and outbid them, and that alone says plenty about how highly Milwaukee has long valued the Detroit left-hander. Now that Skubal is headed into free agency, the conversation around him has shifted from trade-market intrigue to a much bigger question about what kind of bidding war he might command this winter.

For Milwaukee, the appeal is obvious, but so is the reality of the market. Skubal is expected to land a massive contract, and with payroll limits to consider along with a roster that already has depth in place, the Brewers are not viewed as a club likely to press hard this time around. Still, when a pitcher of his caliber reaches the open market, even a team that seems priced out cannot help but be part of the conversation. [Read more 🡒]