Three teams punched their tickets to the League Championship Series on a night when the margins were razor thin, and two of the biggest swings came at the wall.
The Dodgers, Rays and Brewers all won Thursday to advance, but the baseball that mattered most was the kind that barely stayed in the yard. In the Bronx, the Rays edged the Yankees, 4-3, to complete a sweep and reach the ALCS for the third time in franchise history. Out in San Diego, Milwaukee survived a furious late push and held off the Padres thanks to a catch that erased what looked like a certain homer.
The Yankees had a shot to flip the game in the sixth inning on Anthony Volpe’s drive to left, which was first scored as a game-tying two-run home run. Replay changed everything.
A fan reached into the field of play and interfered, and after review the umpires ruled that Rays left fielder Victor Mesa Jr. would not have caught the ball. Volpe was placed on second base, George Lombard Jr. was allowed to score, and nobody crossed the plate again.
The ruling was messy, but the result was backed up by the replay. One angle made it look as though the ball had already cleared the fence before the fan touched it, but another showed it was headed for the wall. The crew chief review gave the officials room to sort it out, and even Rays manager Kevin Cash said after the game that he thought the umps made the right call.
Tampa Bay’s other big break at the plate came earlier, when Ryan Vilade’s solo homer in the fourth inning gave the Rays their second run. It was the kind of flyball that can die anywhere else, but in the short porch in right field it had just enough to sneak out. Spencer Jones nearly pulled it back, but couldn’t quite get there.
Milwaukee’s moment was cleaner and louder. The Brewers were up 3-1 in the bottom of the eighth when Fernando Tatis Jr. opened the inning with a walk and Manny Machado stepped in. Machado launched a ball to deep center, the kind that had the crowd already rising, but Garrett Mitchell ran it down and reached over the wall to take it back.
“It kind of just happened,” Mitchell said of his play. “Instinctually, just do what I do. Make a good jump and see what happens.”
It looked spectacular in real time, and it came at the perfect moment for Milwaukee. The wall in that part of Petco Park is only seven feet high in center-right, and Mitchell, who’s 6'2", didn’t need to do much more than get to the spot and finish the play. Machado knows that corner of the park well; in the 2017 World Baseball Classic, he hit a ball to nearly the same spot and Team USA center fielder Adam Jones robbed him there, too.
Earlier in the night, the Dodgers handled the Braves to set up another NLCS meeting with Milwaukee. The Rays are still waiting to learn their ALCS opponent, with the Guardians beating the White Sox to stay alive.
Game 4 of that series is tonight at 8 p.m. ET.
There were plenty of memorable moments across the playoff slate, but the night’s defining plays were the ones that almost became homers: the Yankees’ unorthodox 6-5-3 double play, Michael Harris II’s heads-up baserunning to score on a pitch in the dirt, Victor Mesa Jr.’s stone-cold reaction after his go-ahead homer for the Rays, José Ramírez’s strong play to save at least one run, and Garrett Mitchell’s robbery at the wall.
Game 4 between the Guardians and White Sox is set for 8 p.m. ET on TBS, and Chicago has another chance to clinch its first playoff series at home since 1906.
The Buccaneers and Cowboys meet at 8:15 p.m. ET on Prime, with winless Tampa Bay facing a Dallas team that has averaged 34 points over its last three games.
In Other News...
Brewers Ended San Diegos Season With A Play Fans Will Relive
The Brewers did more than advance by taking Game 4 of the National League Division Series, they closed the book on a Padres season that had stayed tense right up to the final innings. San Diego got the kind of swing that can change a postseason game when Fernando Tatis Jr. delivered a solo home run, and the matchup still felt like it could tilt either way because the margins were so thin throughout the series.
Milwaukee, though, had the kind of response playoff teams need, and Garrett Mitchells critical defensive play stood out as the sort of moment Padres fans will keep replaying. The loss leaves San Diego staring at an uncertain offseason, with aging cornerstone players, several pitchers headed toward free agency and a looming lockout all hanging over what comes next. [Read more 🡒]
Garrett Mitchell Gave Brewers Fans A Play They'll Never Forget
Garrett Mitchell turned one swing into a moment Brewers fans will be replaying for a long time. In Game 4 of the National League Division Series, with Milwaukee protecting a 3-1 lead, Mitchell tracked down Manny Machados drive at the wall and took away what looked like a game-tying two-run homer for San Diego. It was the kind of defensive play that can change the feel of an entire October series, and it came at exactly the right time for a Brewers club trying to keep control of the game.
Milwaukee still had to finish the job, and the Brewers did exactly that by closing out the Padres in the ninth inning to clinch the series. Mitchells catch ended up standing out as one of the defining moments of the matchup, the sort of play that helped push Milwaukee into the National League Championship Series against the Los Angeles Dodgers. It was a reminder that in the postseason, one out in the outfield can carry nearly as much weight as a big hit at the plate. [Read more 🡒]
Pat Murphy Made One Brewers Adjustment The Padres Never Matched
Pat Murphys bullpen blueprint became one of the quiet separators in the Brewers NLDS win over San Diego. After watching how the matchup unfolded at Petco Park, Milwaukees manager made a clear adjustment in the postseason by keeping a short leash on his starters and trusting the depth in the relief corps to cover the heavy lifting late. It was the kind of October decision that can look conservative on paper and decisive by the time the series is over.
The contrast with the Padres was just as telling. Craig Stammen also avoided pushing his starters deep into games, but the Padres never seemed to have the same level of comfort in the arms waiting behind them. For Milwaukee, that confidence mattered as the series tightened, with the Brewers finding a way to lean into their pitching depth while San Diego was still searching for the same stability. [Read more 🡒]