After coming up short in the Tarik Skubal chase, the Milwaukee Brewers still found a way to add pitching help before the deadline - just not the kind that was likely to change the entire shape of their roster.
Milwaukee is set to acquire rental starter Dustin May and rental left-handed reliever JoJo Romero from the St. Louis Cardinals, according to The Athletic. In return, the Cardinals will get minor-league outfielders Alexander Frias and Josiah Ragsdale.
May, who turns 29 next month, has now been traded at the deadline in consecutive seasons. He went from the Los Angeles Dodgers to the Boston Red Sox last summer, then landed with St.
Louis on a one-year, $12 million deal in the offseason. Romero, also 29, is on the injured list after undergoing an appendectomy earlier this month.
For Milwaukee, May looks more like a stabilizer than a headline grab. He should deepen a rotation that already includes Jacob Misiorowski, Shane Drohan, Logan Henderson, Brandon Sproat, and eventually Kyle Harrison. He’s had some excellent outings this year, and depending on how the next two months unfold, there’s still a path for him to crack the postseason rotation.
Romero gives the Brewers another lefty option out of the bullpen, joining Aaron Ashby and DL Hall. That kind of depth could matter if Milwaukee runs into left-handed-heavy lineups like the Dodgers with Freddie Freeman, Max Muncy, and Shohei Ohtani, the Phillies with Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber, or the Braves with Drake Baldwin and Matt Olson in October.
The Brewers entered deadline day with baseball’s best record at 69-42, sitting a half-game ahead of the Dodgers, who just added Skubal. Milwaukee did go after Skubal, but it’s not clear whether the price was too rich or the Dodgers simply won the bidding. Either way, the Brewers ended up with May and Romero to help cover the pitching gap.
St. Louis, meanwhile, kept moving in the direction the standings had already pointed toward.
The Cardinals had dropped 18 of their last 26 and were under .500, four games back of the third wild card spot. President of baseball operations Chaim Bloom was always expected to lean into the long-term plan and sell, and the 8-18 stretch sealed it.
MLB Pipeline has Frias and Ragsdale ranked No. 11 and No. 13 in Milwaukee’s system.
Brewers trade grade: C
May and Romero are useful additions, but they don’t really solve the problem Milwaukee was trying to fix. The Brewers needed more ceiling at the deadline, and this move mostly gives them floor.
May might not make the postseason rotation, and Romero could end up no higher than second on the lefty relief depth chart behind Ashby. It’s a fine deal in isolation, just not the kind of swing that screams deadline win.
Cardinals trade grade: B
The return fits the market for a veteran rental starter, which usually lands around two good-not-great prospects. Frias and Ragsdale fit that mold.
Romero’s appendectomy knocks down his value for now, but St. Louis still got a reasonable package back.
Frias brings big power and is in Single-A, while Ragsdale is a Double-A bat with plate discipline.
In Other News...
Brewers May Be Trying Another Deadline Turnaround Fans Have Seen Before
The Brewers were active again at the deadline, working a four-player deal with Cleveland that added catcher Bo Naylor and reliever Codi Heuer to a roster built around constant roster churn and opportunistic bets. In return, Milwaukee sent reliever Craig Yoho and outfielder Blake Perkins to the Guardians, another reminder that this front office is rarely afraid to swap pieces if it thinks theres a path to squeezing more out of them.
Naylors arrival is the part that makes the move feel familiar to longtime Brewers watchers. He is at a similar stage in his career to Andrew Vaughn when Milwaukee brought him in previously, and the club has shown before that it believes a fresh setting can unlock a player it thinks still has room to grow. Both Naylor and Heuer were optioned to Triple-A after the trade, so the next phase of this move will play out away from the majors while the Brewers see whether another deadline swing can produce the kind of turnaround they have chased before. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Fans Just Got Another Trade Deadline Twist In Relief Market
Another familiar bullpen name is on the move at the deadline, and this one has a Milwaukee tie. Brent Suter, the left-handed reliever who recently faced his former club, has been dealt from the Angels to the Braves, according to ESPNs Jeff Passan, with Atlanta sending infielder Nacho Alvarez Jr. back the other way.
For Brewers fans, it adds another layer to a market that has already been buzzing around relief help. Suter is heading to a contender for the stretch run, and there is at least one more twist to monitor if the schedule lines up, because the Brewers could see him again when the Braves come to town later this month. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Just Made A Staff Move Pat Murphy Really Needed
The Brewers have been looking for another layer of stability around a pitching staff that has had to keep adapting all year, and a recent move with St. Louis gives Pat Murphy another pair of arms to work with as the calendar turns toward the stretch run. It is the kind of trade that makes sense on Milwaukees side: add big-league help where it can matter most, while dealing from a deeper group of minor-league position players to make it happen.
For a club trying to piece together innings and shorten the distance from starter to endgame, the attraction is obvious. The shuffle also shows how much the Brewers value getting immediate pitching support without waiting on a prospect timeline, even if it costs them two outfielders who had been part of the organizations future depth. What comes next is the part Milwaukee will care about most: whether the new arrivals can settle in quickly enough to help right away. [Read more 🡒]