Three teams in the 2026 MLB playoffs are still chasing something no one in their current bracket has ever done: win a World Series.
That alone makes this divisional round stand out. Nearly 40% of the remaining field is made up of clubs looking for their first championship, and the race to be first among them feels pretty clear. The Milwaukee Brewers, San Diego Padres and Tampa Bay Rays are all still alive, but they do not enter this stage with the same kind of title odds.
Start with the Brewers, because the case for them is the easiest to make. Milwaukee finished 2026 at 103-59 and comes in with the best record in baseball.
The franchise’s lone pennant came in 1982, when it was still in the American League, which gives the Brewers a strange little footnote: they could become the second team, alongside the Astros, to win pennants in both leagues. Houston did it after moving from the NL to the AL and later collected five AL pennants plus its first two World Series titles.
Milwaukee’s current run has been as steady as anything in the sport. This is its eighth playoff berth in nine seasons, and the club has now won the NL Central in six of the last nine years, including four straight.
That is a massive shift from the long stretches of nothing that came before. From that 1982 pennant through 2007, the Brewers didn’t reach the postseason at all.
They finally got back in 2008, reached the NLCS in 2011, then went through another six-season playoff drought.
The problem, of course, is what happens when October gets serious. These Brewers teams have had trouble clearing the final hurdles.
They’ve reached the NLCS twice in this stretch and lost both times. They’ve also been knocked out in the Wild Card round four times and in the NLDS once after a bye.
Last year, the Dodgers swept them out of the NLCS and outscored them 15-4 in the process. Even so, Milwaukee enters this postseason as the most dangerous title threat of the three.
The Padres are the most familiar name in this group, and their history is a long mix of breakthrough moments and hard stops. They finally popped in 1984, winning the NL West and then rallying from an 0-2 hole in the best-of-five NLCS against the Cubs to grab the pennant.
That run ended with a 4-1 loss to the Tigers in the World Series, but it remains a landmark season for the franchise. The Padres then went to the postseason in 1996 and were swept in the NLDS, got back to the World Series in 1998 and were swept by the Yankees, and added a pair of playoff trips in the 2000s without advancing.
More recently, San Diego has been in the mix often enough to matter. The Padres have made the postseason five times in the last seven years, though they’ve reached the NLCS only once in that span.
That came in 2022, when the Phillies beat them 4-1. They look strong again now, but the path is not exactly friendly.
Their immediate challenge is Milwaukee, which is the best team in this round, and the road beyond that could be even more demanding.
Tampa Bay sits in a different kind of place. The franchise was long a punchline as the Devil Rays before dropping “devil” ahead of the 2008 season and turning into a regular contender.
The Rays went from annual cellar dwellers in the AL East to making the playoffs in four of six seasons from 2008-13. After five straight years without a postseason berth, they then reeled off five in a row from 2019-23.
They missed the next two, but they are back now and finished with the best AL record this year.
There is also a neat little oddity with Tampa Bay’s playoff résumé: the Rays have never lost an ALCS. They’ve only been there twice, but they won both times and then lost in the World Series.
That pattern gives this run a pretty clear fork in the road. History suggests the Rays either go out in the ALDS or keep rolling all the way to the World Series, where they would likely be underdogs again.
Their previous World Series trips ended against the Phillies in 2008 and the Dodgers in 2020.
All three clubs have a real shot to make a run. But if you’re ranking who is best positioned to break through first, Milwaukee is the obvious No. 1.
In Other News...
CC Sabathias World Series Pick Gave Brewers Fans A Strange Laugh
CC Sabathias latest studio moment gave Brewers fans an odd little jolt, even if it was more amusing than alarming. Working as an analyst for NBC Sports, the former Milwaukee left-hander picked the New York Yankees to beat the Brewers in the 2027 World Series, a prediction that naturally landed with a little extra flavor coming from someone who once wore both uniforms.
Sabathia said he was trying to get his two former teams to the Fall Classic, but the explanation carried an awkward omission: the Cleveland Guardians, where his pro career began, were left out of the picture. Cleveland remains active in the postseason conversation, and Sabathia has long spoken fondly about his formative years there, which made the snub feel even stranger for anyone following along. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Draw A Padres Problem Fans Wont Love In The NLDS
The Padres come into the NLDS with a very different feel than the club that stumbled out of the gate earlier this season. They closed the regular season on a strong note, then carried that momentum into the postseason by sweeping the Cubs in the Wild Card Series, setting up a matchup with Milwaukee that has a little more danger in it than the Brewers probably wanted.
Fernando Tatis Jr. is a big reason San Diego no longer looks like an easy out. After a rough opening stretch, he turned things around after May 17 and became one of the driving forces behind the offense, launching 25 homers over the final two-thirds of the season. For a Brewers team that has spent the year trying to keep tabs on every edge in October, that kind of late surge is the sort of problem that can change a series fast. [Read more 🡒]
Brewers Enter Padres Series With One Flaw Fans Can't Ignore
The Brewers head into the National League Division Series in a spot plenty of teams would envy, backed by a strong regular season, home-field advantage and a rotation led by Jacob Misiorowski and Logan Henderson. On paper, Milwaukee has the kind of pitching that can carry October baseball, and the setup is about as favorable as a playoff team can ask for.
Still, the concern hanging over this matchup is hard to miss: Milwaukee just does not bring much home-run pop to the table. The Brewers finished near the bottom of the league in that category, and against a Padres club that pairs power with elite pitching, that lack of extra-base thump could become the difference if this series turns tight late. [Read more 🡒]